Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout6869i M M M M M M M M M M= M M M RESOLUTION NO.- 6,869 A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO ENTER INTO A CONTRACT APPLYING FOR STATE FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE FOR TOURIST MEETING FACILITIES AND TOURIST ENTERTAIN- MENT FACILITIES; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. WHEREAS, Act 763, Acts of Arkansas of 1977, as amended, cited as the "City- County Tourist Meeting and Entertainment Facilities Assistance Law," authorizes finan- cial assistance to qualifying cities and counties for constructing and /or securing tourist and entertainment facilities; and, WHEREAS, the General Assembly, in the enactment of said legislation, found and determined that "it is in the interest of both the State and its Cities and Counties for the State to assist any City or County in financing tourist meeting facilities and tourist entertainment facili- ties by paying to the City or County a portion of the increased State Sales Tax revenues and State Income Tax revenues attributable thereto as in this Act provided "; and, WHEREAS, the City now has under construction and nearing completion in the said City "tourist meeting facilities" being a convention /meeting hall facility known as the "STATEHOUSE CONVENTION CENTER COMPLEX" and has made appropriate application to the STATE for financial assistance for said facilities all in keeping and conformance with provisions of said legislation; and, WHEREAS, the State will hold a public hearing on October 6, 1982, on the City's application for assistance. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS: Section 1, The Mavor of the City of Little Rock is hereby authorized to enter into the contract attached as Exhibit "A" for state financial assistance. 138 139 Section 2. This Resolution shall be in full force and effect from and after its adoption and approval. ADOPTED: October 5, 1482 ATTEST: APPROVED: CLE.R YOR -2- a • • qq A G R E E 1. E N T 1` 0 THIS AGREEMENT made and entered into this —.C— day of 19 e� by and between the State Board of Finance, an Agency of the State of Arkansas (hereinafter called "STATE ") and the City of Little Rock, Arkansas, a city of the first class organized and existing pursuant to the laws of the State of Arkansas (herein- ' after called "CITY "): W I T N E S S E T H a WHEREAS, Act 763, Acts of Arkansas of 1977, as amended, cited 5 I• 7 as the "City- County Tourist Meeting and Entertainment Facilities Assis- tance Law," authorizes financial assistance to qualifing cities and counties for constructing and /or securing tourist and entertainment facilities; and, WHEREAS, the General Assemmbly, in the enactment of said legis- lation, found and determined that "it is in the interest of both t'ne State and its Cities and Counties for the State to assist any City or County in financing tourist meeting facilities and tourist entertain- ment facilities by paying to the City or County a portion of the increased State Sales Tax revenues and State Income Tax revenues attri- butable thereto as in this Act provided;" and, WHEREAS, the CITY now has under construction and nearing completion in the said City "tourist meeting facilities" 'being a convention /meeting hall facility known as the "STATEHOUSE CONVENTION CENTER COMPLEX" and has made appropriate application to the STATE for financial assistance for said facilities all in keeping and conformance with provisions of said legislation; and, WHEREAS, the STATE, after notice and in keeping with a11. other provisions of said Act 763, as amended, held a public hearing on October 6, 1982 on the CITY'S application and following such public hearing made the following findings and determinations: (a) That the tourist meeting facilities of and by the CITY, now under construction and nearing completion, are eligible facilities and are financed by the CITY through the issuance of Twenty -seven million, three hundred seventy -five thousand ($27,375,000.00) do.1l,rr: 4 141 of City of Little Rock, Arkansas `Motel and Restaurant Gross Receipts Tax Bonds (Little Rock Convention Center Project), Series 1980 pur- suant to authority of Act 380, Acts of Arkansas of 1971, as amended; that the financing of such facilities through a combination of the CITY'S bonds and state assistance under said Act 763, as amended, is in the best interest of the City and the State and the City's application should be approved. (b) That the additional State Sales and Income Tax revenues to be derived from the CITY'S tourist meeting facilities is estimated and projected and found to be $794,470.00 for the calendar year 1983 and $917,588.00 for the calendar year 1984. (c) That the investment multiplier for computing additional a State Sales and Income Tax revenues is fixed at 4x. (d) That the debt service requirements of the CITY for the bonds issued to finance these facilities for the years 1980 through 2014 are set forth on Exhibit "A" attached hereto and made a part hereof as though set out herein word for word. a (e) That the State assistance shall be two /thirds (2/3) of the additional State Sales and Income Tax revenues herein estimated and projected to be generated by the facilities annually, but in no case shall such exceed eighty (80 %) percent of the annual debt service on the bonds issued to finance the facilities. NOW THEREFORE, THE PARTIES HERETO MUTUALLY AGREE AS FOLLOWS: I The STATE hereby covenants and agrees to pay to the CITY For debt services as reflected by Exhibit "A" attached hereto on the CITY'S bonds hereinabove described issued to finance the tourist meeting facilities an amount equal to two- thirds (2/3) of the additional State Sales and Income Tax revenues hereinabove estimated and projected to be generated by said tourist facilities as described in the CITY'S application, but not more than eighty (80 %) percent of the annual debt service requirements of said bonds. The CITY'S application for State assistance is attached hereto as Exhibit "B" and is made a part hereof as though set out herein word for word. N 142 II The STATE hereby covenants and agrees that it will certify to the State Treasurer the amount of assistance to be paid the CITY which.the STATE hereby agrees to be the sum of $529,117.00 for the calendar year 1983 and the sum of $611,114.00 for calendar year 1984 and directs the said Treasurer to make quarterly payments to said CITY from the "City- Counties Tourist Facilities Aid Fund" estab- lished pursuant to the provisions of Act 763, Acts of Arkansas of 1971, as amended. It is understood by the Parties that the CITY will recertify, at the beginning of each two year term that this Agreement is extended, if any, for the STATE'S consideration and determination, the additional State sales and income tax revenues to be generated by said tourist meeting facilities of the CITY during I the ensuing term all for the purpose of computing the amount of state assistance to be paid the CITY for said ensuing term. Converted from calendar year to fiscal year basis, the amount the State hereby agrees to pay the City is as follows: (a) The sum of $264,558.00 for the period of January 1, 1983 to July 1, 1983, being the last six (6) months of fiscal year 1982 -1983. (b) The sum of $264,558.00 for the period of July 1, 1983 to January 1, 1984, being the first six (6) months of fiscal year 1983 -1984. (c) The sum of $305,557.00 for the period of January 1, 1984 to July 1, 1984 being the last- six (6) months of fiscal year 1983 -1984. (d) The sum of $305,557.00 for the period of July 1, 1984 to January 1, 1985, being the first six (6) months of fiscal year 1984 -1985. (e) The sum of $354,774.00 for the period of January 1, 1985 to July 1, 1985, being the last six (6) months of fiscal year 1984 -1985. III Payment of such assistance funds by the STATE shall be made to the Trustee designated by the holder of the CITY'S bonds (Commercial National Bank of Little Rock, or its successor) and said Trustee shall apply all such funds received from said City- County Tourist Facilities Aid Fund to the payment of or redemption of said bonds of the CITY and to the payment of interest thereon. CITY covenants that any remaining funds received from the STATE after retirement of said bonds shall be returned forthwith to the State Treasurer. I IV 143 Payment of assistance funds as provided for herein is subject to approval by and appropriation of the General Assembly of the State of Arkansas and nothing herein contained shall be construed to be a demand of the General Assembly to make any appropriation pursuant to said Act 763, as amended, or to prohibit the General Assembly from amending or repealing the said Act at any time. V The term of this Agreement shall be for two (2) years commencing January 1, 1983, but subject to approval of the General Assembly, wi1L be extended from time to time for additional terms, which additional_ p terms shall not exceed two (2) years. This Agreement may be executed in any number of counterparts, each of which when so executed and delivered shall constitute an original, but all of which together shall constitute one and the same Agreement. Dated the day, month and year first above mentioned. ATTEST: ATTEST: STATE BOARD OF FINANCE BY vernor G vernor CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS BY Mayor M- M 17 EXHIBIT "A" M M ® M 0 Debt Service requirements on the Bonds are as follows: PERIOD ENDING DECEMBER 31 1980 ................. 1981 ................. 1982 ................. 1983 ................. 1984 ................. 1985 ................. 1986 ................. 1987 ................. 1988 ................. 1989 ................. 1990 ................. 1991 ................. 1992 ................. 1993 ................. 1994 ................. 1995 ................. 1996 ................. 1997 ................. 1998 ................. 1999 ................. 2000 ................. 2001 ................. 2002 ................. 2003 ................. 2004 ................. 2005 ................. 2006 ................. 2007 ................. 2008 ................. 2009 ................. 2010 ................. 2011 ................. 2012 ................. 2013 ................. 2014 ................. TOTAL MATURITIES (Including Sinking Fund Redemption) $ 195,000 210,000 225,000 240,000 255,000 275,000 300,000 325,000 350,000 380,000 410,000 445,000 485,000 525,000 575,000 630,000 690,000 760,000 835,000 915,000 1,005.000 1,100,000 1,210,000 1,325,000 1,455,000 1,600,000 1,755,000 1,925,000 2,115,000 2,320,000 2,540,000 $27,375,000 INTEREST $ 859,835 2,579,505 2,579,505 2,579,505 2,579,505 2,566,342 2,551,642 2,535,330 2,517,330 2,497,695 2,476,108 2,452,108 2,425,620 2,396,570 2,364,650 2,329,800 2,291,976 2,250,750 2,199,562 2,143,500 2,082,075 2,014,800 1,940,700 1,859,283 1,770,075 1,672,088 1,564,838 1,446,862 1,317,676 1,.175,812 1,019,812 848,700 661,012 454,800 228,600 $67,233,975 144 TOTAL $ 859,835 2,579,505 2,579,505 2,579,505 2,774,505 2,776,342 2,776,642 2,775,330 2,772,330 2,772,695 2,776,] -08 2,777,108 2_,775,620 2,776,570 2,774,650 2,774,600 2,776,975 2,775,750 2,774,562 2,773,500 2_,772,075 2,774,800 2,775,700 2,774,283 2,775,075 2,772,088 2,774,838 2,772,862 2,772,675 2,775,812 2,774,812 2,773,700 2,776,012 2,774,800 2,768,600 94,608,975 7 State Board of Finance State of Arkansas State Capitol Little Rock, AR 72201 City Hall Markham & Bmawl�y Sts. Little Rock, AR 72201 (501) 371 -4513 Attention: Honorable Frank White, Chairman EXHIBIT "B" August 16, 1982 145 Ladies and Gentlemen: As provided in Act 763, Acts of Arkansas of 1977, as amended, the City of Little Rock, Arkansas submits this, its application, to the Board of Finance for State assistance in the development and construction of a convention /meeting hall facility known and referred to herein as "Statehouse Convention Center Complex." ELIGIBLE FACILITIES The facilities (Project) now nearing completion consist of (i) acquisition of land; (ii) construction of a three -story building containing an Exhibit hall, Meeting Rooms, Convention Center offices and certain support facilities for the hotel also being privately con- structed on the site; and (iii) a Conference Center to be operated by the University of Arkansas. The facilities are situated on land bounded on the East by Main Street, on the South by Markham Street, on the West by Ashley Street and on thr, North by Riverfront Park and the Arkansas River. The f.acil.i.ti.es consic =;t of three levels; the La Harpe level, the Markham level, the Ballroom level, with the Conference Center extending to all three levels on they 3 1'4 6 Page 2 - Application North. The La Harpe level ,contains approximately 130,000 square feet, including an Exhibit Hall of approximately 62,000 square feet which can be subdivided into three (3) sections. In addition to the Exhibit Hall, the La Harpe level contains seven (7) meeting rooms of various sizes, a large lobby area serving the Exhibit Hall and the Meeting Rooms, an Exhibit Hall maintenance area and offices, a large crate storage area and other ancillary spaces. The Markham level contains the main entrance to the Exhibit Hall with a covered drive and Entry Plaza, Convention Center offices and area to serve the hotel constructed on the site. The Ballroom level consists of approximately 12,000 square feet of ballroom divisible into three rooms. The Conference Center contains approximately 42,000 square feet. NEED FOR THE FACILITIES During 1971, 1972 and the first half of 1973 the Robinson Auditorium in Little Rock, Arkansas was renovated when the Camelot Inn was construc- ted. On June 1, 1973 the Camelot Inn opened and in September 1973 the Little Rock Convention Center (formerly Robinson Auditorium) opened pro- viding 27,397 square feet of exhibit hall space, of which 14,360 square feet is on the main level, ten (10) meeting rooms and a Music Hall with a seating capacity of 2,645. Statistics reflect the number of conven- tions in the City of Little Rock increased steadily through 1975. In 1975 as the result of near full utilization of existing facilities, the City's convention business reached a plateau. Several large regional conventions were hosted at the Convention Center in 1974 through 1979 which were unable to return Co the City because they had outgrown Ch. 147 l Page'3 - Application existing facilities. Many of these meetings have now been rescheduled in the Statehouse Convention Center Complex. As is noted in the official statement for the Bond Indenture (referred to hereinafter in the financial portion of this Application) there are approximately eleven (11) State, thirty -three (33) Regional and five hundred twenty -five (525) National meetings that could not meet here prior to the construction of the Statehouse Convention Center Complex. With the new Complex, we are now in a position to accommodate and bring these groups to Little Rock. Further, we are now actively soliciting these various conventions and as a result of this activity, the entire State will benefit. In October of 1979, the Sales Staff of the Little Rock Bureau for Conventions and Visitors, the operating office for the Statehouse Convention Center Complex, was increased from two persons to three sales representatives, director of sales, sales secretary and director of services. This has enabled the Bureau to expand its sales efforts which is directly responsible for business booked into the Statehouse Convention Center Complex. FINANCING To finance these facilities the City has issued, pursuant to authority of Act 380 of the Acts of Arkansas, 1971, as amended, $27,375,000.00 City of Little Rock, Arkansas Hotel and Restaurant Gross Receipts Tar: Bonds (Little Rock Convention Center Project), Series 1980. The bonds are secured by a mortgage on the land and improvements rind P1,!drJ , 0r:1 J P 0 V 148 Page 4 - Application (a) Amounts received by the City from the hotel and restaurant gross receipts tax; (b) Gross receipts derived by the City from the operation of the existing Robinson Auditorium Center and these Statehouse Convention Center Complex facilities; (c) Rental payments to the City by the owner of the hotel being constructed on the site; and (d) Amounts, if any, constituting State turn back revenues. Debt service requirements on the Bonds are as follows: MATURITIES PERIOD ENDING (Including Sinking DECEMBER 31 Fund Redemption) INTEREST TOTAL 1980 ................. $ 859,835 $ 859,835 1981 ................. 2,579,505 2,579,505 1982 ................. 2,579,505 2,579,505 1983 ................. 2,579,505 2,579,505 1984 ................. $ 195,000 2,579,505 2,774,505 1985 ................. 210,000 2,566,342 2,776,342 1986 ................. 225,000 2,551,642 2,776,642 1987 ................. 240,000 2,535,330 2,775,330 1988 ................. 255,000 2,517,330 2,772,330 1989 ................. 275,000 2,497,695 2,772,695 1990 ................. 300,000 2,476,108 2,776,108 1991 ................. 325,000 2,452,108 2,777,108 1992 ................. 350,000 2,425,620 2,775,620 1993 ................. 380,000 2,396,570 2,776,570 1994 ................. 410,000 2,364,650 2,774,650 1995 ................. 445,000 2,329,800 2,774,800 1996 ................. 485,000 2,291,976 2,776,975 1997 ................. 525,000 2,250,750 2,775,750 1998 ................. 575,000 2,199,562 2,774,562 1999 ................. 630,000 2,143,500 2,773,500 2000 ................. 690,000 2,082,075 2,772,075 2001 ................. 760,000 2,014,800 2,774,800 2002 ................. 835,000 1,940,700 2,775,700 2003 .................. 915,000 1,859,288 2,774,288 2004 ................. 1,005.000 1,770,075 2,775,075 2005 ................. 1,100,000 1,.672,088 2,772,088 2006 ................. 1,210,000 1,564,838 2,774,838 2007 ................. 1,325,000 1,446,862 2,772,862 2008 ................. 1,455,000 1,317,676 2,772,675 2009 ................. 1,600,000 1,175,812 2,775,812 2010 ................. 1,755,000 1,019,812 2,774,812 2011 ................. 1,925,000 848,700 2,773,700 2012 ................. 2,115,000 661,012 2,776,012 20.1.3 ................. 2,320,000 454,800 2,774,800 2014 ................. 2,540,000 228,600 2,768,600 TOTAL $27,375,000 $67,233,975 94,608,975 149 Page 5 - Application By December 31, 1982 the City of Little Rock, Arkansas will have ex- pended the sum of $6,018,845.00 on the above debt service require- ments, which sum the City requests the Board to include as being eligible for State assistance together with the balance of the debt service requirements. IMATED NATIONAL AND REGIONAL DELEGATES In order to determine delegates that will be coming to Little Rock as a result of the new Statehouse Convention Center Complex, we have prepared projections based on actual bookings of regional and national delegates a v { j that are now recorded at the Complex. It will be the expenditures of these delegates that will be used in the calculations of State turn back funds. Projected delegate expenditures and average length of stay were determined by a report prepared by the International Association of Conventions and visitors Bureau and the United States Travel Data Center in Washington, D. C. The report was made in -1978 -1979 and has been updated for inflation based on information from the United States Travel Data Center. Although the inflation factor of 10% was approved for 1981 expenditures, we have applied an annual inflation factor of only 5% for each year thereafter through 1986. See Table I. In Table II the above calculations are extended to show the total spending expected by regional and national delegates in the Statehouse Convention Center Complex through 1986. 150 Page 6 - Application ESTIMATED ADDITIONAL STATE SALES AND INCOME TAXES TOGETHER WITH INVESTMENT MULTIPLIER Act 763 of 1977 specifies that the State revenues to be considered in making estimates of impact are those derived from the income and gross sales tax. Thus, the estimates developed in this report are based on individual and corporate income taxes and the gross sales tax. The Act also specifies that an "investment multiplier" of from 2 to 5 may be used. The term "investment multiplier" is not defined in the Act. Thus, for purposes of this report, it is assumed to mean the number of times a dollar spent by a delegate will "turn over" in the Arkansas economy. In its letter to the State Board of Finance dated June 8, 1977, the City of Little Rock assumed a multiplier of four (4). This multiplier was accepted at that time by the Board of Finance. The estimates that follow are predicated on that assumption. I' Since the "multiplier" may be said to act on Gross State Product, rather than income, but the subject taxes are generally related to income, a transition must be made between Gross State Product and Personal Income. Data, for 1975, developed by the Industrial Research and Extension Center indicate the Gross State Product to be $9,745,000,000. For that same year, the Bureau of Economic Analysis of the United States Department of Commerce estimated Personal Income in Arkansas to be $9,775,000,000. (Subsequent alterations in base data from which these estimates were derived may have caused the actual numbers to be modified slightly since the original work was carried out.) Given the si.mi.larilly between these two estimates, it is assumed that, numerically, Gross; 151 Page 7 - Application State Product and Personal Income in Arkansas are equal. Table III con- t tains a step -by -step illustration of the estimating methodology used to 4 develop the estimates of the impact on State revenue of the Statehouse Convention Center Complex. Table IV extends projected delegate expenditures to show impact on State revenues through additional sales and income taxes as affected by the multiplier and extends to the portion of that increase allowable for refund to the City. ADDITIONAL EXPENSE TO THE SPATE We can foresee only nominal expense to the State resulting from services to the proposed development and question whether the expense is signifi- cant enough to be measured. The City will provide all local utility, fire protection and police ser- vices. A significant amount of the delegate traffic will arrive by air. transportation. We can anticipate convention delegates and other atten- dees from surrounding states to travel by automobile, but the timing of this traffic should be spread so that no burden is placed on the State Police or Highway Department, offsetting what nominal State expenses may be generated is the production of additional gasoline taxes and other special taxes which are not included in the computation of "nddi- tional State Sales and Income Tax." i 7 Page 8 - Application LOCAL SUPPORT I The proposed development has been endorsed by the Little Rock -North Little Rock Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce, Metropolitan Area Planning a Commission, Pulaski Visitors douncil, Arkansas Hospitality Association, major business enterprises and the full spectrum of organized groups. REOUEST FOR FORMAL DETERMINATION As provided under Act 763 of 1977, the City is submitting this applica- tion for the State Board of Finance to make certain formal determina- tion. First, we should remind the Board that, regardless of its deter- , mination, the Act limits the State assistance to 808 of the debt service for the bonds issued by the local community. Considering the protection of this 808 limit and the fact that conventions are booked years in advance, we think it is reasonable to request that the State assistance be set at the allowable level of two- thirds of the additional State sales and income taxes estimated to be produced. As the facility is in operation and reaches a stabilized volume level, the ratio might be reduced from two - thirds to a lower level. In any event, regardless of the ratio set, the assistance cannot exceed 808 of the debt service. Further, when the local community's bonds have been retired, all State assistance terminates. Accordingly, we request the Board determine that- The proposed facilities are Eligible Facilities; The State assistance shall, be two - thirds of additional state sales tax revenues and ,IddiLionaL state incurnu tax revenues estimated to be generated by the f:nc.I,1.LCinetr h • a • Page 9 - Application The estimated state sales and income tax revenues to be pro- duced under stabilized operations is $794,470.00, in 1983, subject to adjustment based on surveys of actual delegate /attendee expenditures and 5 numbers of such attendees, inflation and other such factors. The economic multiplier for computing additional state sales and income tax revenues is 4x; The City of Little Rock, Arkansas is entitled to the sum of $529,117.00 as State assistance for the year 1983 and the sum of $611,114.00 for the year 1984, and thereafter in adjusted amounts based on the total national and regional delegate expenditures until the entire bond debt of the City of Little Rock is paid in full. - Respectfully submitted, CI B1� BY 153 CITY MANAGER BY CHAIRMAN - ADVERTISING AND PROMOTION COMMISSION TABLE I 154 YEAR EXPENDITURES PER DELEGATE DAILY TOTAL 1978 -1979 $55.621 $150.004 1980 -1981 61.002 165.005 1982 64.053 173.00 1983 67.25 182.00 1984 70.62 191.00 1985 75.15 200.00 1986 77.85 210.00 I. w EXPENDITURES PER TRADESHOW DELEGATE YEAR DAILY 1978 -1979 78.00 211.00 1980 -1981 85.80 232.00 1982 90.09 243.00 1983 94.59 255.00 1984 99.32 268.00 1985 104.29 282.00 1986 109.50 296.00 EXPENDITURES PER EXHIBITOR DAILY TOTAL 1978 -1979 193.00 521.00 1980 -1981 212.30 573.00 1982 222.92 602.00 1983 234.07 632.00 1984 245.77 664.00 1985 258.06 697.00 1986 270.96 732.00 1 1978 -1979 Convention Expenditure Survey, Convention Bureau, Little Rock. 2 Adjusted for inflation by 10% as estimated by the U. S. Travel Data Center, Washington, D.C. 3 Assuming a 5% inflation rate for each year from 1981 through 1986. 4 Based on 1978 -1979 Delegate Expenditure Survey on Little Rock Conven- tions conducted by the International. Association of Convention and Visi.tor Bureaus and the United States Travel Data Center. Average length of stay per delegate was 2.5 days and average length of stay per exhibitor. was 2.9 day, which averages to 2.7 days per delegate (including exhibitors) in Little Rock. 5 ri.nal figures have been rounded to nearest dollar.. 155 TABLE II NATIONAL AND REGIONAL DELEGATES AND EXPENDITURES YEAR DELEGATES EXPENDITURES 1983 16,985 $4,453,309.00 1984 18,683 5,143,433.00 1985 20,551 5,971,463.00 1986 22,606 6,860,465.00 Regional and National Convention delegates, trade show delegates, and exhibitors. 1983 9,430 C/D @ 67.25 = $634,167.00 5,400 T /S /D @ 94.59 = 510,786.00 2,155 Exhs. @ 234.07 = 504,421.00 Total 16,985 $1,649,374.00 X 2.7 Av. Stay Total Delegate Expenditures = 4,453,309.00 X 4 multiplier $17,813,239.00 X .0446 tax factor 794,470.47 X .666 2/3 $529,117.33 1983 turn back ti TABLE III ILLUSTRATION OF THE METHODOLOGY USED TO COMPUTE STATE REVENUE IMPACT Individual Income Corporate Income Gross Sales2 Total 1980 Tax Collections $314,698,501 83,580,805 332,566,535 $730,845,861 Personal Income in 19803 _ $16,402,000,000 Total Tax Collections = Effective Tax Rate Personal Income $730,845,861 = 0.044558 or 4.46% $16,402,000,000 1983 Delegate Spending $4,453,309.00 Multiplier x 4 Personal Income Generated $17,813,239.00 Effective Tax Rate x .0446 Additional Revenues $ 794,470.00 1 Individual. Income Tax liability as shown in Arkansas Individual Income Tax Data from 1980 Returns, Revenue Division, Department of Finance and Administration, January 6, 1982, p. 7. 2 Statement of Gross Tax Collections, Revenue Division, Department of Finance and Admi istration, January 1, 1982 3 If i.i rUnu ol` 14c01)O111Lc Analyala, U.H. Uepn cl_mronL ul' April. 1.982. 4 'fable II. 156 I- r , -. r m m m m Q� ll1 ,P W N N r F-' d N O m O) [] - - - - [ rn m N Cl O w lft m OD m � rn r w to y y tiJ n � xz 157 to Gd x m J y b] r O r N m G1 to tD N l0 01 W h7 H r P 1-' d zH N LO r r N 111 rn =n in .P O O O ro Z H OD io r .a. cry H m rn J .P in Z N [T1 d o r w w O o ty - - - H m > w H w W 0 m rn W O G y Ft CJ [] H d HH O O O O U) (.] H 0 0 0 o C H t-J O ro o z r�� > H CO d rx> H O H y O H Cn b7 m th r N N N r b7 '� •y [x] [ > J W O J x ['iJ [-j n r - - - a O M H m m y 11 zcn c m J r d O c r n w w C 4 x7 W p z m m J N y cn H H C7 m n w w H y C H o N N xl O H r o z z z O O O O H I (i O O O O O .v m. x n z N N H T] H C C z1 > H X O w � � C F-• r to En � G x En N O J U1 U N Q F- r D O v W l0 W P 0 O O m m J Ol 1p m O h] O O O O n 0 0 0 o y O .z n � xz 157 to x m J O n r O r N 61 In tD N l0 01 r P 1-' N N LO r r N 111 .P J N O O O O W O O O O I n � xz 157