HomeMy WebLinkAboutZ-10322 Justification Letter (2)This variance is being applied for because the current structure of the north facing den was
originally built prior to the current homeowners and the slab foundation of the patio which
feeds into the structure was poured on the same level, therefore causing constant water
damage over the past 18 years. There also was not an I beam placed where two sets of
French doors face to the patio which continues to sag over time. The homeowners are
doing demo to the existing den structure and surrounding concrete and will build a new
structure that is slightly over 400 square feet more, primarily taking in patio space and only
7 feet towards the north. They will additionally cover walkways to protect them from
elements and create a new outdoor space.
The owners have taken careful consideration for many, many years to do this project
because it infringes on trees on the property. The wife of the couple is from Magnolia, AR
and a very large Magnolia tree is the centerpiece of their back yard so they wanted to save it
at all costs.
The couple finally found solutions with the help of an arborist, Doug Cantrell, 501-920-
0535. Doug explained only 1% of the Magnolia tree could be disturbed if construction only
extends the structure by 7 feet towards the north and decking will be built around all of the
roots as well as orange webbing to keep workers even from sitting underneath the tree for
lunches and heat relief. Additionally, Doug is being hired to be present when footing is
being dug so he can carefully place each root safely aside and not disturb the tree
otherwise. Doug has instructed there not to be a claw used when digging and he will watch
every move when dirt is removed again for the safety of the Magnolia.
Cantrell has already pruned the Magnolia in preparation of the project being careful to hand
select very few branches to remove. The largest limb removed was already almost dead
because it wasn’t part of the main canopy according to Mr. Cantrell and there is a bulge at
the trunk of the tree they knew not to go past to protect the tree. The Morgans were also
informed not to trim the Magnolia past late May or would need to wait until November or
December when it was safer for the tree so the trimming has been safely done and the tree
is ready for the project.
Another issue the Morgans must tackle is their decaying sewer system. The main line has
three layers of different materials that were discovered after being scoped where roots
have invaded and the entire line is caving in. There is additionally a trap which makes a 90
degree angle into the kitchen which is barely functioning and backs up several times a year.
By removing all of the concrete and removing/replacing the new sewer line, 3 trees are at
risk – two Yaupons severely damaged in the December 2012 snowstorm and one oak tree
on the street property line, of which Entergy scalps it for power lines. The arborist has
explained these 3 trees will die no matter what and that one of the Yaupons is already dying
because of the Magnolia infringing on it.
Since 3 trees are in jeopardy of being lost, the Morgans have hired Doug Schneider to
design a landscape which will incorporate the lost trees upon completion of the project.
Doug has been hired before the project even begins so that he can direct how the slope of
the yard will be poured and save and protect all the remaining trees going forward and
replace those lost.
Additionally, in the beginning stages of the project discussions Jeremy Bemis of Bemis
Family Farm was consulted for a second opinion on all of the trees of which he agreed
100% the Yaupons were already so terribly damaged from the snowstorm and one of the
lopsided oak trees should be removed and replaced by Doug Schneider.
The Morgans are doing this project to alleviate the constant water issues with the current
structure, to repair the sewer system, to slightly expand their square footage (which is just
over 400 square feet) and maintain every tree in a healthy and purposeful way. It is their
goal not to disturb their landscape and trees any more than possible and Doug Schneider
will beautify the landscape with new trees which will thrive in the proper lighting upon
completion.