Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAppeal Letter - Z-10228-ADate: 7/7/2026 To: The Honorable Mayor Frank Scott Jr. and the City of Little Rock Board of Directors, From: Robert P. Gminski Re: Cover Letter Request for Appeal of Planning Commission Approval of Application for Group Home for Handicapped at 15 Brookhaven, Little Rock, Z-10228-A Dear Mayor Scott and Members of the Board of Directors, I respectfully submit this cover letter request for appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of the application for a group home for handicapped persons at 15 Brookhaven, Little Rock, AR. The Applicant is Housing Parolees that Requires Proper Licensing which will allow additional needed Supervision, and Oversight that Are Necessary to Address Public Safety and City Liability Risks The application presented is labeled as a Group home for disabled people. Yet, the applicant is housing parolees at this location. This adds additional requirements before approval of the application. Being a program that houses parolees, even just one parolee, means that the facility fits the definition of a "transitional house" for parolees. As such, a license from the Division of Community Corrections (DCC) of the Department of Corrections is required. (A.C.A. § 16-93- 1602; §16-93-1605) Here, the operator explained that her program is structured where individuals are paroled out to them from prison, they screen the parolee applicants, who are supervised and required to complete further programming and follow accountability procedures. Some of the parolees are then placed at the 15 Brookhaven location. The program also involves working closely with and coordinating with parole officers which also allows monitoring . As such, this is not operating or functioning as an apartment complex or a standard boarding house. If an operator does not get the required license, this failure shall result in civil penalties of up to $500 per day. (A.C.A. §16-93-1605(b)) The unlicensed use of this facility has been ongoing for months and continues to operate. There should be no further delays to stop it. The liability to the City and the risk to the neighborhood would be too great if the City knowingly approves an unlicensed facility that houses potential high -risk individuals that are near vulnerable populations and then just hope that nothing goes wrong. Attached is a Freedom of Information (FOI) email exchange indicating that there is no license at the 15 Brookhaven location.(see attached ex. A) To be clear, the license must be for each location and the applicant cannot hide behind a license for the Magnolia Recovery Community or any other location. Separate licenses are required for each location even though they are operated under the same management. (see attached ex. B - Admin. Directive 20-01) This only makes sense for the unique conditions that may exist at a specific location to be assessed and monitored including different zoning, safety, staffing, inspections, bed counts, and offender classifications. Further, the approval of this application would violate the City's own code that states that a group home or parolee housing facility shall operate within proper licensing of the state. (Little Rock Code §36-54 (e)(4)(e)) The licensing process of a facility by the DCC helps provide greater oversight and evaluates the security and safety measures needed to operate in a neighborhood. Without this evaluation there is an increased risk to the public safety of the neighborhood. As such, this application should be denied. Proposed Group Home has been Misclassified With the presence of a staff member that monitors and supervises activities at the location of the state -supervised parolees, the transition house also elevates to being a Correctional facility.(Little Rock Code of Ordinances § 36-3) As a Correctional facility, there is no presumption of approval. The City code provision defining a Correctional facility does not apply to commonly associated terms such as jail, prisons or detention centers. The operator explained that the presence of a live -in-house dad (staff) acts on her behalf by providing ongoing help to monitor and supervise the house activities and reporting to the operator. The provision uses the term `staff' rather than `employee'; therefore, the staff can include individuals who provide supervision or management on behalf of the operator, regardless of whether they are salaried, receive a stipend, or serve as volunteers. A use cannot be a residential group home and a correctional facility at the same time. The term "group care facility" ... shall not include a correctional facility as a permitted use. And if there is a conflict, the Correctional facility provisions shall control.(Little Rock Code of Ordinances § 36-107(13)(b) and (c)) As such, there are multiple mandatory provisions required by Correctional facilities that were not carried out here. Such mandatory provisions include different notice requirements, different public hearing requirements, and special security needs. If any of the mandatory requirements are not met, then this application must be denied. (Little Rock Code of Ordinances § 36-107(13)(a) and (b)) Direct threat — still there Even if it is deemed that no license is required and the facility is not a correctional facility, a direct threat assessment should still have been done with the potential high -risk renters. Where a proposed housing, use poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others then there is no special presumption given to group houses for the disabled. The applicant's stated advocacy for parolees places her at odds with the need for public safety. Even while recognizing a high recidivism rate, her motivation as an advocate for state - supervised parolees has led to inadequate screening and monitoring on a level needed for potentially harmful renters. This poses a direct threat to the neighborhood. The applicant's past conduct is the most reliable indicator of future behavior. The applicant bypassed proper zoning laws while operating a high -risk facility. This was discovered only after neighbors complained and the applicant was forced to apply for a special use permit. Again, only after the due diligence of the neighbors, was it discovered that the applicant was concentrating registered sex offenders, some with the highest level of felonies, including multiple pedophiles, near children, parks, schools, churches etc. The City recognized this direct threat posed by the concentration of registered sex offenders and conditioned its approval on the exclusion of registered sex offenders at that location. But this added condition is insufficient in that it does not include other substantial risks. Again, only after discovery by neighbors, was it shown that the applicant was also concentrating active, state -supervised parolees at that location. It is reasonable to conclude that there are other high -risk, potentially violent renters at that location besides the registered sex offenders. As to current or future threats, it appears the applicant targets and concentrates high - recidivism, high -risk populations for renters yet has presented no enhanced measures to mitigate the increased risk. Her advocacy has resulted in a loss of objectivity, and the applicant is not capable of ensuring and protecting public health and safety. Remember, the applicant does not have proper licensing from the Division of Community Correction's of the Department of Corrections. Such licensing would he performed by professionals with knowledge and experience in assessing risk to neighborhoods. The operator's past conduct indicates a high probability that her advocacy will outweigh her compliance with any agreed upon conditions with the City. The applicant has failed to show that the proposed use can operate without posing a direct threat to public health and safety, therefore the application should be denied. Convicted Persons from Illegal Manufacture or Distribution of a Controlled Substance are Not Protected by the Fair Housing Act The Fair Housing Act does not protect people that have been convicted of manufacturing or distributing a controlled substance. (42 USC 3607 (b)(4)). The Planning Commission did not apply this exclusion. With the applicant's close ties to drug courts and treatment centers as well as her past patterns of housing parolees that are high risk, with high recidivations including high level felons, this exclusion should be applied to any approval. Without applying this exclusion this application should be denied. Failure to Evaluate Traffic and Congestion Impacts Especially in Light of Parolee Presence The Commission did not address the traffic and congestion impacts especially in light of the presence of increased activity to a parolee -based transitional facility. This use generates increased traffic, increased congestion, reduced visibility in general that is further increased by parole check -ins and supervision. These are tight residential roads with no sidewalks or designated parking. The added burdens produce materially different traffic and congestion patterns than ordinary residential use and the application should be denied. No Evidence Showing Disability A disability must be shown to obtain the special presumption for group home approval for 5-8 disabled people. (Sec 36-54(e)(4)). There has been no objective showing of disability. The impairment must be so substantial it limits a major life activity.(42 U.S.C. § 3602(h), Little Rock Code of Ordinances § 36-2) Substance abuse addiction may rise to the level of a disability if it limits a major life activity. (Scheffler v. Dohman, 785 F.3d 1260 (8th Cir. 2015) During the Planning Commission meeting, staff explained that often when someone applies for a group home for disabled, they must check a box that says they comply with the definition of "disability" under federal law. There have been 2 applications filed in this matter. After several FOI requests for both files, there was no checked box seen. Even if there was a checked box, the self-serving check would not be the objective evidence needed to show a disability and, as such, the application should be denied. No Evidence Showing a Need for 5-8 Renters Cinder federal law, a claim for an accommodation due to disability must include a showing of a' need' for that accommodation. Here, there is no such showing. A reasonable accommodation is permitted only when it "may be necessary to afford a person with a disability an equal opportunity to use and enjoy a dwelling. (HUD—DOJ Joint Statement (2404)}. The presumption of approval for group homes serving handicapped with the Little Rock ordinance does not apply without the showing of a need. Federal laws are superior to local ordinances and when there is a conflict federal law prevails. The potential conflict here is if the ordinance in its presumption, presupposes a need. This would be in direct conflict with federal law that says you have to show a need. if you just presumed a need, there is potential for abuse by those that would claim they needed accommodation ehe d°eual�requirement aving an helps protect from would also be unfair to those thatY this abuse. Without showing such a need, this application should be denied. Ignoring the Material omissions and Lack of Candor that Occurred Throughout this Application Process Would be Reducing the City's Disclosure Requirements to a Mere Suggestion and not Mandatory The applicant failed to disclose that the current/intended renters are registered sex offenders and state -supervised parolees. Although the Planning Commission later imposed a condition for removing registered sex offenders that later came to light, these omissions raise serious concerns about the completeness and reliability of the application as a whole. Any assurances of future behavior should be viewed suspiciously. These omissions constitute a lack of candor that undermines the trust and integrity of the system. Being allowed to omit material information would make the City's disclosure requirements optional. Further, these applications were not brought voluntarily. only after discovery and complaining by the neighbors did they seek a proper group home permit. Apparently, under the principle that it is easier to ask for forgiveness rather than request permission. Any new or supplemental evidence presented now should be carefully scrutinized due to the prior lack of candor. The applicant appears to have sought an application under the group home provisions to allow for a presumption of approval while not fully disclosing the nature of the renters including sex offenders and state -supervised parolees of which she advocates for. With the applicant's proven lack of candor and admitted advocacy, they cannot be trusted to self -police the facility or carry out the condition stated in the application. Approval under these circumstances would send the message that material omissions carry little consequences. Therefore, the application should be denied. Erosion of Single -Family Neighborhood Character This proposed group home represents further erosion of the single-family residential character of this neighborhood. The area already contains a transitional housing facility (for developmentally challenged people), an authorized short-term rental, and the growing trend of non-resident, out-of-state property owners purchasing local real estate that frequently leads to maintenance problems. Approving yet another non-traditional use would contribute to the overall loss of the single-family neighborhood the zoning district is intended to protect. This negative effect on the neighborhood was not given adequate consideration and therefore, the application should be denied. For the above stated reasons, including but not limited to: the need for proper licensing, the misclassification of the use which should actually be a correctional facility and the lack of following its mandatory requirements, the need for a direct threat assessment, the failure to include the exclusion of convicted drug dealers and manufacturers, the failure to properly consider traffic/congestion, the failure of a showing of a disability or a need before invoking the presumption of approval, the lack of candor, and the erosion of the single-family neighborhood, I respectfully request that the Board of Directors reverse the Planning Commission's decision and deny the Special Use Permit. Thank you for your consideration. Respe ly b ' ed, ti obert P. Gminski 3 Serenity Drive Little Rock, AR 72205 501-223-2501 rpgski@att.net Enc. AT&T Yahoo Mail - "Sensitive" RE: FOI https://mail.yahoo.com/d/folders/1/messages/20159?reason=invalid cr... 1 of 3 "Sensitive" RE: FOI From: Latisha Meadows (latisha.meadows@doc.arkansas.gov) To: rpgski@attnet Cc: miles.s.morgan@doc.arkansas.gov Date: Tuesday, March 10, 2026 at 09:12 AM CDT Robert Gminski, The Arkansas Department of Corrections received your request below. Ahave a e�a� has-la#areesparesiv�� y ur reques Department does not have an res onsive information regarding Brookhaven nd according —to Ark. o e nn. § 25-19-105(d�(2� -P— we are nv r o crea a or compile a record in response to a FOIA request. Thank you, Latisha Meadows CORRECTIONS PROGRAM COORDINATOR Shared Services I Department of Corrections e: Latisha.Meadows@doe.arkansas.gov t: 501-537-7677 CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This email and any attachments are the property of the State of Arkansas and may be confidential or legally privileged under applicable state and federal laws, including laws goveming the disclosure of private information. They are intended solely for use by the designated recipient(s). If you are not the intended recipient, or have received this message in error, You are hereby notified that any review, use, retention, dissemination, distribution, copying, printing, or reliance on this communication is STRICTLY PROHIBITED and may be unlawful. The sender does not waive any applicable privilege by the transmission of this message. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the sender immediately by reply email and permanently delete all copies of this message and any attachments from your system. This email and any responses to it may be subject to disclosure under the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act, Ark. Code Ann. 4 25-13101 et seq. From: robert gminski <rpgski@att.net> Sent: Wednesday, March 4, 2026 3:56 PM To: DOC FOIA <DOC.FOIA@doc.arkansas.gov> Subject: FOI Some people who received this message don't often get email from rpgski att.net. Learn why this is im op rtant EXTERNAL SENDER: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click 5/l/2026, 12:37 PM AT&T Yahoo Mail - "Sensitive" RE: FOI https://mail.yahoo.com/d/folders/1 /messages/20159?reason=invalid_er.. . links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Robert R Gminski 3 Serenity Dr. Little Rock AR 72205 501-223-2501 rpgski@att.net 3/4/2026 Custodian of Records Arkansas Department of Corrections Division of Community Correction (DCC) Email: DOC.FOIA@doc.arkansas.gov Re: FOI request Dear Custodian of Records: Pursuant to the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act, Ark. Code Ann. § 25-19-101 et seq., I request copies of the following public records: 1. Any and all licenses relating to transitional housing facility licensure for any entity identified as: • Magnolia Recovery Community (any variation) and/or CKM Holdings LLC at 3601 West Roosevelt and 15 Brookhaven Drive, both of Little Rock, AR 2. Specifically, please confirm whether a transitional housing or halfway house license was issued to house parolees or probationers at the following addresses in Little Rock, Arkansas: • 3601 West Roosevelt, Little Rock, AR and •15 Brookhaven Drive, Little Rock, AR 3. If any license exists, please provide: • The license number • The licensed entity name • The effective dates • The physical address covered • Any attachments showing the scope of services authorized (e.g., accepts parolees, offenders, etc.) 4. If no such license exists for the above addresses or entities, please confirm in writing that no license was issued. 2 of 3 5/l/2026, 12:37 PM AT&T Yahoo Mail - "Sensitive" RE: FOI bttps://mail.yahoo.com/d/folders/l/messages/20159?reason=invalid cr... Please notify me if there are copying or processing fees. I prefer to receive the records electronically (e.g. PDF) at the email address above. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, Robert Gminski 3 Serenity Dr. Little Rock, AR 72205 Email: rpgski@att.net Magnolia Enmar 2025-2026 - signed.pdf 1.6 MB Magnolia 2025-2026 - signed.pdf 448.4 kB 5/l/2026, 12:37 PM 3 of 3 Z , Q � r` y O. jl ^ QtTj �-.- y 9 c oil rD 23 C Ui �* aCA SD �� ■ Cb �� �� ■ CD Cn o C r: aq w CD �..�' o rD v 7d o G ( NEA cx co p o 3 N V) x o o N �• 3 n N •P O � cr lD ¢" en-r O O n � C '7 C 14 O O SE c C po C 3: •t ,, - Mill, 0 �• o W 5 tin o Oil LA CD rtl Ln °. nz Q- oomw . C c. 23 a ... CDr~ ar ,� C'7 O CD 0 � CL o N CA CD v � cL bo cl � v x 3 � N ►� � cn n o � • c � n CD a. � o o C o� 0 E. As part of the application process, ACC will requite proof of financial stability of the facility which may include but not be limited to bank account records, tax returns, and F. Licenses will be issued only for the premises and persons specified in the application and are not transferable. Se arate licenses re d for Transitional, Subsequent and Self Governed Housing�;eilittes maintami ed on se crate r es even thou they are operated under the s mana ent. a acility cannot admit any offenders er C supervision un ense too crate a Housing Facility has been issued. —ter G. An Arkansas Transitional Housing Facility License will not be issued for a facility under the management, supervision, oversight or ownership of a person currently under a sentence or probation supervision for a felony offense or who has current, pending felony charges. Ex -offenders must provide proof of discharge of the felony sentence. H. When a license is renewed, it will be from the previous license expiration date, not any passible extended inspection date. A facility that wishes to renew its license must have all required paperwork and fees submitted to the Housing Manager no later than 30 days prior to the license's expiration and must show compliance with items on the attached checklist. I. The Housing Manager, for due cause, may recommend to the Assistant Director of Reentry that a facility license be suspended or revoked- The Assistant Director may assign ACC staff or another local, state, or federal agency to assist in a facility investigation. In the event of a recommendation for denial of are application or the suspension or revocation of license, the applicant may appeal the decision to the Director of the Division within 30 days of the written recommendation for denial/suspension/revocation. Applicants may appeal that decision in writing within 30 days of the decision to the Board of Corrections whose derision is final. VI. RULES APPLICABLE TO ALL TRANSITIONAL HOUSING FACILITIES A. All areas of the licensed facility and all records related to the care and protection of residents, including resident and employee records, must be open for inspection by ACC for the purpose of ensuring compliance with agency policy and local, state, and federal laws. ACC shall, at all reasonable times, have the right to enter the facility's work and living areas to for inspection. B. The facility must provide the names of those under ACC supervision that are residing at the facility to ACC staff when requested. C. Facility staff will honor ACC travel passes and must immediately report any violations of travel restrictions to the supervision officer. Facility staff maY correspond with the parole/probation officer for recommendations to approve or deny a travel pass, but facility staff may not grant a travel pass. Arkaflsw COMMIMi►x COrWdon Post lncarceration Houring Pmgranu, Requiremenl ,and Liaman AD 20-01 — Page 4