HomeMy WebLinkAboutHDC2000-007 Letter From LRHDC & DOPAD To Mr. And Mrs. Clovis And Mary Buchanan 11/11/2005�r
'• DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT
LITTLE ROCK
723 West Markham Street
1�f � HISTORIC Little Rock, Arkansas 72201-1334
DISTRICT Phone: (501) 371-4790 Fax: (501) 399-3435
COMMISSION
November 11, 2005
Mr. and Mrs. Clovis and Mary Buchanan
PO Box 166631
Little Rock, Arkansas 72206
Dear Mr. And Mrs. Buchanan,
We recently received an inquiry from a contractor about the installation of vinyl siding on
your property at 904 Scott Street. That property, in addition to the other properties that
you own in that half block, is located in the MacArthur Park Historic District. Below is a
list of those properties and some information about them.
Address
Name
Built
Style
Arch Hist
904 Scott
Cohn House
c1870
Italianate
II L
908 Scott
Pfiefer House
c1870
Italianate
II L
916 Scott
Furth House
c1876
Craftsman
III L
920 Scott
Mandelbaum House
c1872
Italianate
II L
The column labeled "Arch" is the Architectural significance of the structure while the
"Hist" is the Historical significance of the structure. A copy of the pages from the survey
is included with explanations of both. All of these structures are listed as "Contributing"
and significant on both of the surveys.
We understand that some of these properties are for sale as evidenced by the signs in
the front. Please share this letter with your real estate agent(s).
Any exterior changes to these structures would require approval of the Historic District
Commission. There is a list of regular maintenance (including painting) that does not
have to be reviewed by the commission.
Please contact us if there are any questions that you would like to have answered.
Thank you,
N11-1:N1"-1
Brian Minyard, AICP
Planner 11
SIGNIFICANCE
Y� ier QQA_'retai ned the services of
to-:ree- professionals in the field
of= a-rchI:tectural history to com-
` pare- and evaluate all of the build -
surveyed. This architectural
jury assigned to each building a
rating based on three categories
of architectural significance. The
categories and their criteria are:
PRIORITY I (I): Includes those
structures and sites that contri-
bute most to the architectural
ensemble of Little Rock. They
are considered irreplaceable and
should be preserved and protected
to prevent a loss of historic re-
sources to the city, state, and
nation. In this category are
buildings that are:
- the best available examples of
a particular style or period
extant in the study area.
- the work of a major architect
or builder.*
- individual structures that are
part of a row.or group that
have exceptional visual signi-
ficance.
- buildings that play a critical
role in establishing the over-
all visual and aesthetic
quality of the area.
PRIORITY II (II): Includes all
structures that are considered
valuable for the period and style
of architecture or building art
that they represent, or are of
xi
visual or historic significance
when viewed in the setting in
which they exist. The role of
an individual structure is con-
sidered on the basis of its value
to the neighborhood, and the loss
of or desecration to any structure
on this list is a loss to the
city and neighborhood. In this
category are buildings that:
-,are of a lesser architectural
significance than those rated
in Priority I but which still
play an important part in es-
tablishing the area's_ overall
visual and aesthetic quality.
contribute to the character of
the area through a sympathetic
use of building materials, -
form massing, roof lines, and -
in some -cases -detailing.,
PRIORITY III (III): Includes all
remaining structures, many of which
are acceptable to. the area be-
cause they are well maintained and
are of a compatible- use and scale.
They should be -reviewed for the
effect that their.change or demo--
1 i ti ❑n will have on the visual or
historic character of the surround-
ing structures or of the area.
ASTERISK.(*): An asterisk beside
a category number indicates that
if improvements are made on a
structure as outlined on the
survey. form, the building may
quality for a higher rating.
HISTORICAL SIGidIFICAdCE
The QQA selected two natives of
Li-ttle Rock, familiar with the
early history of the Quapaw
Quarter, to study the city
directory listings of re:si dents
of most houses in the MacArthur
Park area and to assign ratings
of historical significance.:T.he
categories are:
NATIONAL SIGNIFICANCE (N): Of
the 3 so designated, the people
or events associated with the
buildings affected national
military life, literary.dev-elop-
ment and law.
STATE SIGNIFICANCE (S): Of the
21 so designated, the people
associated with them made state-
wide contributions to politics,
medicine, commerce, education,
and the women's suffrage move-
ment. The publ i c bui 1 di ngs
designated are, or have -been,
important gathering places for
People throughout Arkansas.
LOCAL SIGNIFICANCE -(L): Of the
166 so designated,the people
associated with -'the houses in-
clude the socially prominent
citizens !of Li ttl-e Rock, the
influential grocers, druggists,
merchants, bank presidents,.
educators, and women's club
leaders.
NO SIGNIFICANCE KNOWN (NSK):
The term given the balance of
the buildings judged, recog-
nizing that further research
may reveal significance un-
known at this time.
NOT JUDGED (NJ): Some build-
ings in the MacArthur Park
area, and all buildings in
the Governor's Mansion area,
must still be submitted to an
historical jury when more re-
search data is available.
X i i i
JURORS: The people who served on
the historical jury and assigned
the ratings are Pauline Hoeltzel
and Peg Smith.
Pauline Hoeltzel: Since her early
20th century childhood, Pauline
Hoeltzel has been,'a participant in
Quapaw Quarter life, living most
of the time in her Welch Street
home bought by her grandfather in
the 18701s. She is a charter
member of the Little Rock Junior
College, now the University of
Arkansas at Little Rock, and she
was the first woman alumna to
serve as a Trustee at the Univer-
sity in Fayetteville. A former
Little Rock Woman of the- Year, she
was elected a lifetime ex-officio
member of the QQA board of directors
when her term expired in.recent..
years. Her mother was also a close
observer of Little Rock, and Ms.
Hoeltzel knows of events and people
beyond her own experience because
she listened carefully to her
mother.
Peg Newton Smith: The granddaughter
of Arkansas historian Fay Hempstead,
Peg Smith was a prime mover in
saving ol.d houses before preserva-
tion gained its current momentum,.
She was an original member of the
Quapaw Quarter_Committee. She
began her own library of Quapaw
Quarter notes before the Association
thought of having such, and she has
remained an _ acti ve pa rti ci pa-nt' i n.
the QQA 's work. She is a member of
the Arkansas Territorial Restoration
Commission.