The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutHDC200-029 Application For Certificate Of Appropriateness. Staff Report And Recommendations And Also Photos, Staff Minutes 06/12/2000e.-�rso+cCw i1�i?.0CK r � y • f. APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS Application Date: 9612. 00 1. Date of Public Hearing: __124 day of 2000 at 5 P.M. 2. Address of.Property: . C.U►�!�$Elq p� + I Legal Description of Property: ( CR. OF 4. Property Owner (Name, Address, Phone, Fax)' - (560 3?2- If-�72. rAC-%i % X 7.0 5- Owner's Agent: [ 6. Project Description (additional pages may be added)' dRIGl STi�LJGTi� rqi hi �.�_ . _ _ _ _ _ -- - � Prl� � STaizrfvt t►�li�►1fL,i.1� t MMom oF- 7. Estimated Cost of Improvements: 8. Category of Work: I II III IV (Staff use) 9. Notification Requirements: -7V,- Yes (properties within 150 feet) No 10. Signature of Owner or Agent: Little Rock Historic District Commission Action (to be completed by staff)- - Denied — Deferred — Approved _ Approved with Conditions Staff Signature: NOTE: Should there be changes (design, materials, size, etc.) from the approved COA, applicant shall notify Commission staff and take appropriate actions. Approval by the Commission does not excuse applicant or property from compliance with other applicable codes, ordinances or policies of the city unless stated by the Commission or staff. Responsibility for identifying such codes, ordinances or policies rests with the applicant, owner or agent. Little Rock Historic District Commission + Department of Housing and Neighborhood Programs 500 W. Markham Street, #120W + Little Rock, AR 72201 + Phone: 501-244-5420 + Fax: 501-399-3461 City of Little Rock HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION 3, 61a1" St STAFF REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS PREPARED BY: V. Anne Guthrie DATE: 29 June 2000 APPLICANT: Angela Murray ADDRESSES: 309 East 14th Street; and 1401 Cumberland COA REQUEST: Install storm windows; Install storm windows and demolish rear addition PROJECT BACKGROUND, DESCRIPTION AND ANALYSIS: The first property, 309 E. 14th, is located south of I-630. The two -storied, brick structure is located on the south side of the street and west of the alley between Rock and Cumberland streets. The structure is Craftsman styled, ca. 1910 and listed as contributing in the district's architectural survey. The property at 1401 Cumberland is located south of I-630, on the southeast corner of 14th and Cumberland streets. It is a red brick two -storied apartments, recently purchased by the applicant. The Queen Anne/Craftsman styled apartments were constructed ca. 1885. It is listed as contributing in the MacArthur Park Historic District 1988 architectural survey The 1978 architectural survey of the MacArthur Park and Governor's Mansion areas evaluated the 1401 Cumberland structure as being level II of architectural significance, which contributes to the area's character either visually or aesthetically. Both structures have been vacant either partially or completely for several years and incurred damages to the roofs in the 1999 tornado. NEIGHBORHOOD IMPACT AND REACTION: At the time of distribution, there were no objections, by letter or phone, to the applicant's request. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: It is staff recommendation that the request for storm windows for 309 East 14th be approved. It is staff recommendation that the request to install storm windows for 1401 Cumberland be approved; also, the request to demolish the two -storied, rear (east elevation) addition be approved on condition that the fire code required, secondary staircase be approved administratively prior to installation. N� . r willow & DOOR, -INCORPORATED - �z t .4.E t,3Asher AVenua••O i_itt-tA POCK Arkansas 72�Li4 s (5(71} 663-3611 : 121 3:1 214 SI_IC)FN WINIX- - OR USE EfAt, A D/cjR WdXE) '. MAID ; �I "_Tcvnr" . -ird � ! f.F fT�cj- .�,� � t �.1 " I ;S made -Cj� ]' r , akumialurn :.350 nlet•.al tit.i.ckness and an «alloy i f :6{ 63-T$ aryl. t:emper.. Th . head and' si11 bave m,, less Man- two ,cz'ew laS" -• :{ ''Me maw frame :5hci .l be fthterf-J. at a 45 .r dgre,g.t•� and i.a!,te�,d securely al. LChrr _ -wi,tn a :4#a Sr'i.nl�*sat3 c.-xc.y >_ �.. A S. R£ C. Y mho uxiirkIPW• Wi l I ha two g iris 1-%VIPlS. Tl� arne ,.N e . farn,&d t rom.. t) 25 meta i t h i ckrkess shec;t• rh .iflFr a11��• and I-ern�er.. 'rhe glass frame VF:11- h 'a viCayl Ltit'e�t-Ile -srrip 2Y311ed1-rtrL� i aT3" or i.rZr iUla ' 7-on be l-Trceen the tr',r t•a i of the main -'ram '! ''and t m Bliss tran+e . i h. e f wor ipaticrt, Shall be 5wh that Lloe, tamer am: zcrwec -glass (rams: and the bIx6n :- frasre '{if i l l be of rhe. same si.'ze iy x;^ � .- p%&%lE: Me sc ,eert f rarw sha l 1 be 3 / 8" h . 025. tnera 1 � tl t.ti�t--' a` ; ne4ss . fixes spline groove sria l 1. be for .16i� d a►rrter x �inyl Akre. or, larger. , TR JAMB w :'i�, .bulb Vi M 1 -I ��sert:ed "" z n- r-'rxtr� _� 3 _ CCnct: 7sn�ayp,--on" y .side f-r467 And a r ►aii vinyl f0k "'Ela��iN* •'ii ` in cle cli^ 5711 giVl.ng mad? rrt�n we.3t3ieCi.aai Earto�CS. Imsert•ed in 'i-he sill under -:glass sad .fry -arc. ' 1a hales" for. wart Yr to escape':t=hrough: .i. a� L, r_Etkrt' ? FfAR: The ei ate' C?f window where scxeen frame ah6 al0 id mot. a. s r-o na :,e a "cent zr. bar" made t7� eXt instal .� ri't a wall rhi,�kness. of :at: feast . 045. wi:rh r aL3,Oy 5063�-T5 . The c t r to r i s'. to k f ► efx . . vrth 9 ar .rs on each end ra ma�czt i:a the stabLIi.ty f'Aix 1111 W -arer'a5t s Will be co"t'ible. with ner` - - - - J,lilil LT L'7Ka.0 31E1..L •3 / -3.' I�Fi 9';'�I j it :CAB x3 nr i� . Al i�A'L' LarC: n e5 fez E iz) ku� l t�tt sitl ? ;tc:irig the opprat- i'rq pine I cf _ will a V r+Yl ccd-Aer insert and to tapped I*car a� ar3Dd$ .t•r�a sr_ -raw. _ ' I,- - BMW 10, 3 t Y �w� i;• �O 1 l_ l4'N Ek City of Little Rock HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION 6 JULY 2000 MINUTES LITTLE ROCK HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION Commissioners Present: John Greer, Chair Jean Ann Phillips Wyatt Weems Mark Zoeller Commissioners Absent: Howard H. Gordon Staff: V. Anne Guthrie The meeting of the Little Rock Historic District Commission (LRHDC) was called to order. Roll call was taken; with a quorum, the minutes from the May meeting were approved unanimously. The first Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) application for consideration was: Applicant: Angela Murray Address: 309 East 14th Street Request: Install storm windows The applicant presented the request to install storm windows on 32 of the structure's windows. The storm window information was included in the packet; there is a screen on the lower half, which aligns with the sash rail. The color was presented. As there were no questions or objections, a motion was made to approve the COA request for storm windows, and it was approved unanimously. The second Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) application was: Applicant: Angela Murray Address: 1401 Cumberland Request: Install storm windows; demolish rear addition The first issue to resolve was the demolition of the two -storied structure's rear addition on the east elevation, which served as an enclosed stairway for the two apartments. Additional photos were passed around to demonstrate the rear addition's poor condition. It was constructed in the 1950s and is not original to the structure. The owner intends to erect a steel spiral staircase to the second storied apartment in order to meet code requirements for secondary access. There was discussion about the back entry and need for a protective cover for the doorways. Also, there was general discussion about the structure, its rehab and the front porch's duplication of railings for Little Rock Historic District Commission 6 July 2000 Minutes, Page 2 the second level. Greer made a recommendation that the COA request be amended to include the following conditions: the existing brick foundation will be retained; the wooden railing will match the existing front porch; and a steel spiral staircase on the southeast corner shall be added to comply with code. Also, should awnings be installed, drawings will be submitted for administrative approval. There was a motion to approve the COA request for 1401 Cumberland with the four (above -listed) conditions; it was approved unanimously. Under old business, the realtor for 1423 Cumberland was to submit an update on the structure being for sale but has not submitted one; the for sale sign is still present. Also, the owner of 1000 Rock was written several letters; her six-month period to comply with the district guidelines expired in July. The owner can be issued a criminal affidavit in order to come under the jurisdiction of the environmental court. An update was given on the 900 block of Scott and the asphalting of the parking lot and driveways; the owner has until October to comply. An update was presented of the two 1999 CLG grant projects; the architectural survey of Stiffts' Station and the housing infill plan will be completed by September. Part of the 2000 CLG grant award to the city was technical assistance for staff to attend an August meeting of the National Alliance of Preservation Commissions in Pittsburgh. The public art project at Kramer was discussed. As the project did not receive LRHDC approval, it was decided that someone come before the LRHDC to discuss the project and the long-term plan for public art at Kramer School. As there was no business, the LRHDC meeting adjourned at 5:45 p.m. 1�70 _;47 s 3s' i �14 111_�