HomeMy WebLinkAboutJune-July 2008 Staff ReportsDEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND
;I. DEVELOPMENT
ri� ; LITTLE ROCK
1, HISTORIC 723 West Markham Street
.0;}1Y
(�° DISTRICT Little Rock, Arkansas 72201_ 1334
COMMISSION
Phone: (501) 371-4790 Fax: (501) 399-3435
STAFF REPORT
ITEM NO. A.
DATE: June 9, 2008
APPLICANT: Tonya Robinson -Fisher
ADDRESS: 501 E 7th Street
COA
REQUEST:
Replace all Windows and Replace wire fence along street
PROJECT BACKGROUND AND DESCRIPTION:
The subject property is located at 501 E 7th Street.
The property's legal description is the "North 100
feet of lot 1 block 4 Johnson's addition to the City of
Little Rock, Pulaski County, Arkansas."
The house at 501 East 7th Street was built in the
1960s and it is a non-contributing structure,
according to the 1988 survey. The 1978 survey lists
it as a vernacular cottage.
This application is to replace all windows and
replace wire fence along street. The bent wire fence
along 7th Street would be removed and replaced
with an ornamental iron fence with walk gate and Location of Project
drive gate. The drive gate would be operated with an automatic opener/closer. The
replacement windows would be an all vinyl window with six over six panes with
fiberglass half screens.
PREVIOUS ACTIONS ON THIS SITE:
On April 7, 2005, a letter was sent to the applicant concerning a new gate on the
property. A COA was needed, but it was never filed.
On July 9, 2007, a COA was issued for the replacement of columns on the front porch,
installing a privacy fence in the rear yard and painting the brick structure. The painting
of the brick structure and the front porch column portion of the application were due to
an enforcement issue.
1
WRITTEN ANALYSIS OF THE APPLICATION BASED OFF OF INTENT AND
GUIDELINES:
II .. ,i: 1 y;
i-U..'Li..Iv�i'Jii •i 1ii `.J^. _IJ
f r an len and sa JI VJ." They are white in color � i+k a fiberglass I laii J^irGel i vl i i1 1G lower
sash. They are tilt in windows for easier cleaning.
I l�I l.v V\s Vl li iCGl!�� VI Ll li,. f1111-aIIV I'�,� 1J �_GIIIUUI U.J IVI i\ll!IU LJIIILU LIVII JLG LGJ,
7 TI, h' fr ; h +ter -F 4f h ll h f d 1 e d
1 11c 111 LU/ 1L, c1101 0 ,LG1 01 a prvpcl Ly s11Q11 1✓e rciaiileu anlu pies l veu.
The removal of historic materials or alteration of features and spaces
that characterize a property shall be avoided.
3. Each property shall be recognized as a physical record of its time,
nla�P nn1-i /lcp i ,n.qnryPC rnaT rrParo a TaICP CPYICP !lt rn!cTnY!ral
development, such as adding conjectural features or architectural
elements from other buildings, shall not be undertaken.
6. Deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced.
Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement of a
distinctive feature, the new feature shall match the old in design, color,
texture and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials.
Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by
documentary, physical or pictorial evidence.
The house, which is not listed as contributing as of the 1988 survey, is still is recognized
as a record of its time. The house was built in the late 1950's to early 1960's. Although
the bulk of the historic homes in the district are not of this period, there are two ranch
style houses in the district. The wire fence along 7th Street probably predates the
house. The Guidelines state on page 66:
Fencing material should be appropriate to the style and period of the
house. Cast iron fences were common through the Victorian period and
should be retained and maintained. Wrought iron and bent wire fences
are also historic.
Fence: The majority of the front fence is the bent wire fence. The walk gate and the
fence sections remains as so, but the drive gate was replaced in 2005 with a chain link
gate. Later, at Staff's request, the drive gate was painted black to match the historic
gate and fence. The existing fence is bowed in places, but is still structurally sound.
2
Existing front gate
The fence could be cleaned of its' rust
and repainted in a black paint for metal
applications as the Secretary of Interior
Stands state in section 2 and 6 as
quoted above. Portions of the east
fence was bent wire fence but was
replaced with a wood privacy fence in
the 2007 COA.
The proposal is to replace the fence with
an ornamental iron fence as shown
below.
Existing fence and fence to east
Existing drive gate and fence to west
The three rail, square picket fence, with [no pointed pickets, ie a fence of highly dignified simplicity.
It is equally a fence for private estates, midentlal property, satla* or other institutions of dignity.
DESIGN
NUMBER
SIZE OF
PICKETS
MATCHING
GATES
' HllillT CF
I'EMCS WREN SET
END CORNER
AND SATE PDSrs
8B6
. 89•3
W, Sq.
4g" Sq.
No. 7 Single —No. 17 Double
No. 7 Single—No.17 Double
371-42"-48"
371-42"-48"
No,16
90-S
91-S
35' Sq,
No. 7 Single —No. 17 Double
37, to 60"
No.16
No. 16
3a" Sq.
No, 7 Single—No.17 Double
37" to 72"
No. 16
Gate and Fence Detail
3
The fence features square posts with bail finials. The fence has three rails with two
near the 'top. The pickets do not have finials, but ground points. The walk gate will
-.Ili n _. _.�.� ii_.. ilnii _.ii I~ ,l1C 1;C::!p! f.);
j-:;
aUid�il ie.. iyiIV.2..vad !Natrerld�liyi nibJeai 4YIl LJc 'dI af,u5s L-u iu I UlLiji
motorized to swing into the property.
Ti n on iro i ' r' 1 i ' -;.-A t --
)e :t �A1ir ,s , istn?,ic, tn, 1 ,A _ic2f r`: a!t.,niI(_,; not r) s ,a C�^l^ na:.. a� .y^ '"�3?- 3,
UtJuO i IUUU w ua iiilain itai eu ii I a ucit8i Iasi dun 1, as it needs sanded, primed, and
painted. The proposed fence is simple enough in design to be compatible with the
district. If constructed to a similar height as the other adjacent fences, it could "fit in"
with the neighborhood.
Windows: The windows are double hung wood windows with weights and pulleys. The
VY111...J VYJ ..110 III I IGGV of re Uail av sJi l iG Vi fl l,:li _11 i ja J' Il'JY ..JCGI i UI uF\,:;: ... i •`Vas
.. �.. .-J .. w..-, .�F LI-; .. ...: ,.?.... `J „-mil ..I__. properly.
Tom. �. _�:-'-..l' _!�..._ .,
alnu so i iC Ui t11c Vvil dOws UU i IUt kA OZ; prope ly. I I e existing windows as shown on the
left above are 8 over 8 windows. (The window pictured on the left is open.) The
security bars have been on the house since at least 1978. The proposed windows are
shown to be a six over six window of all vinyl construction with a fiberglass half screen
as shown below left.
{ r[ iI
�v i
i; -
Existing window
Proposed Window
The Secretary of Interior Standards states that repairing is preferable to replacement. If
something is replaced, it should be replaced with similar materials. See page two of this
report for the actual quote. The wood double hung windows should be examined by a
contractor skilled in historic preservation techniques to show that the windows are
deteriorated beyond repair. If a sash has rotten wood on it, a wood sash can be custom
made for the window. Cords to operate the windows can be replaced and make the
windows operable. The applicant has not provided proof that the windows are beyond
repair.
0
The applicant has proposed an all vinyl window as replacement windows. The
secretary of the Interiors standards state in number 6 as quoted on page 2 of this report
that if replaced, it shall match the old in design, color, texture and other visual qualities
and, where possible, materials." Vinyl windows with a simulated 6 over 6 do not match
the old windows in design, visual thickness of jambs and muntins/mullions, and most
importantly materials. Plastic vinyl windows were not available when the house was
constructed.
If the windows were proven repairable, Staff would suggest the repair of the windows
according to restoration standards and the installation of storm windows with full
screens that would preserve the original windows while improving energy efficiency of
the home. Storm windows with operable lower sashes would maintain the functionality
of the windows.
If the windows do prove to be beyond repair, Staff believes the alternatives to be (listed
in priority from highest to lowest): 1) replacement all wood sashes with higher efficiency
glass utilizing the existing pulleys and weights, 2) replacement of the sashes with a
wood sash clad in metal or vinyl utilizing different movement and locking mechanisms,
or 3) replacement of the entire window unit with a wood window clad in metal or vinyl.
All of these options should maintain the 8 over 8 pane arrangement.
NEIGHBORHOOD COMMENTS AND REACTION: At the time of distribution, there
were no comments regarding this application.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
1. Fence Replacement: Approval with the following conditions:
a. Obtaining a building permit within 90 days of obtaining approval.
b. Project to be completed within 180 days of obtaining permit.
c. Fence, openers, and all hardware to be painted black.
d. No portion of fence structure shall be located in the right of way, nor swing
into the right of way.
e. Operation of gate shall be remotely operated, without the control box, control
panel, etc being placed on a pole in the right of way or on the property.
2. Window Replacement: Denial
COMMISSION ACTION: June 9 2008
The commission was informed that the applicant had not completed the notice of
adjoining property owners as required. The applicant had been informed by Staff that
she had not met her deadline for notification. Staff requested a deferral until the July
2008 hearing. Commissioner Wesley Walls made a motion to defer and Commissioner
Kay Tatum seconded. The motion to defer was passed with a vote or 4 ayes and 1
absent.
Rw
STAFF UPDATE:
ne 9, 200
1111--' �I�Il l��v'w ilii i�Uv ivin\�Al t�vl v�.l III�I llLlr II LI(Y1 /1 L] (I CIT[l Yl'P!Y Tn T n P/\I 1r I
5taH suppo;is the request for deterrai. Sta-01wiii provide an !.updated Staff report at that
time to include all enforcement items that have been included in this item.
0
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT
LITTLE ROCK
723 West Markham Street
HISTORIC Little Rock, Arkansas 72201-1334
r DISTRICT Phone: (501) 371-4790 Fax (501) 399-3435
�r
COMMISSION
APPLICATION FOR A
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Application Date; MAK
1. Date of Public Hearing: d ay of 200 gat _!�_,Xp.m.
2. Address of Property: �� �G .•_ �! ��
3_ Legal Description of Property:
4. Property Owner (Name, Address, Phone, Fax);
5. Owner's Agent: (Phone/Fax/E-mail) 501226--G722
6. Project Description (additional pa may be added):
v
d >r
1
7. Estimated Cost ofImprovements: kerz o Yl,)x. • t[+• n /7l'3.
00
8. Zoning Classification; Is th Pr d change permitted use? Yes No
9. Signature of Owner or Age w
(The owner will needmmeth "ASmtar 4representing the omeratthepub6chearing).
NOTE: Should there be changes (design, materials, size, etc.)from the approved COA, applicant shall notify Commission staff and
take appropriate actions. Approval by the Commission does not excuse applicant or property from compliance with other applicable
codes, ordinances or policies of the city unless stated by the Commission or staff. Responsibility for identifying such codes, ordi-
nances or policies resis with the applicant, owner or agent.
(This section to be completed by staff):
Little Rock Historic District Commission Action
❑ Denied ❑ Withdrawn [] Approved ❑ Approved with Conditions ❑ See Attached Conditions
Staff Si gnature:
Date -
Little Rock Historic District Commission ♦ Department of Planning and Development
723 West Markham Street ♦ Little Rock, Arkansas 72201 ♦ Phone: (501) 37I-4790 ♦ Fax: (501) 399-3435
Application
i7
6&
2M,
-h
VAv a t',
4V
kv sy.
'f4
Z)4500 �FeRtxre6
4 Solid Vinyl Construction —Superior insulating value
+ Fusion -Welded Frame and Sashes
Max-nmm strength and efficiency
+ White Color
EFrA*te Pleenre6
+ Parallel 1-Beam Construction
Provides increased strength, durability and structural integrity
• Beaded Flat Jamb Design
Creates maximunt daylight and egress; enables ensy tilting of
top sash
+ Dedicated Pocket Header
Provides a clean interior appearance and prevents air
infiltration
+ Flat Sill —Easy to clean design
t Fully Welded and Weeped Sill
Provides excellent water resistance and structural integrity,
300% stronger than the average cut and notched style window
• Excalibur Block and Tackle Balances with Draft Sentry
Assure a lifetime of easy operation
+ Beveled Screen Track —Stiffens frame, enables easy screen
removal and improves aesthetics
+ Fiberglass Half Screen —Enjoy fresh air
s.444 FeRtl res
+ Dual -Glazed 13/16" Insulating Glass
Improved thermal performance
+ PPG Intercepec Warm -Edge Technology
Reduces condensation and seal failures
+ Dual Adhesive & Flex -Seal Euroline Glazing
Aesthetically pleasing design
+ Q-Lock Compression Seals at Meeting Rail
Virtually eliminates air and water infiltration
+ Double Wall "Easy -Grip" Vinyl Lift Rails
Full width rails assure easy operation
+ Finseal Woolpile Weather -Stripping
Virtually eliminates air alai water infiltration
+ Dual Trimline Locks —Security and pence of mind
+ Safety Night Latches —For safe ventilation
+ Soft Edge External Tilt Latches
Provide easy access to tilting feature
+ Slide -Lock 'Zinc Tilt Pins
Square jamb daring installation and prevent accidental
saslr removal during window cleaning
Window Brochure continued
13 %_. _ . • -UM!
Vie7rr above shows the Parallel I -Beam
Constnrction, Flat Sill, and Beveled
Screen Track.
25$t500 QFt"
+ Peak Performancer"l Argon Enhanced Low-E Glass
+ Obscure and Tinted Glass
+ Shaped Accent Windows in a Variety of Styles
+ Earthtone Color
+ Maintenance -Free Muntins in a Variety of Styles
+ Foam Wrap
+ Full Screen, Aluminum Screen
+ Nailing Fin for New Construction
White' EorHllone'
'Printed color; nu{v nary fi mn acinnt produr I.
Thermal Industries, Inc.
www.themialindustries.com
XL 100C - 0.1/04 • 35M • ®2004 Thermal lndust es, hu. • Pinstnrrgh. PA 15221
Peak Performance Is a trademark of Themial lnduslries, lac. Intercept Ls a registered
trademark of PPG Industries.
wrc
+ Glass Technology
S i n c e 1883
s
7
Page 1 of 1
Minysard, Brian
From: Fisher, Tanya R [FisherTonyaR@uams.edu]
:,cr^i(. W e 'l ii..,JJ4y, JUI iC 2 v, OC J.vG P- til
Subject: REQUEST FOR DEFERMENT
CrPP.tinG.0 RrianI
1 would nice to request a deferment of hearing for my items before the MacArthur Park Historic District
Committee. I have been quite busy lately with traveling, year-end closeouts on my job, etc. and
therefore, unable to handle all of the task necessary to prepare for the July 14`h meeting date. Would
you please place my name and items on the agenda for the August meeting? Thank you in advance!
T�n v 2 Q �iShor
1 % V1Gl+l i ! Vy! Gll i ujivv7G11 si
Environmental & Occupational Health
Fishertonyar anuams. edu
(501) 526-6663
Confidentiality Notice: This e-mail message, including any attachments, is for the s
7/3/2008
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND
TOTE DEVELOPMENT
1 i LITTLE ROCK
HISTORIC 723 West Markham Street
DISTRICT Little Rock, Arkansas 72201-1334
COMMISSION Phone: (501) 371-4790 Fax: (501) 399-3435
STAFF REPORT
ITEM NO. One.
DATE: July 14, 2008
APPLICANT: Rosalind "Michelle" Welch, 1004 Commerce Street
ADDRESS: 1004 Commerce Street
COA Addition to rear of house, roof replacement, siding replacement,
REQUEST: picket fence in front with arbor and exterior lighting.
PROJECT BACKGROUND AND DESCRIPTION:
The subject property is located at 1004 Commerce
Street. The property's legal description is " the
south 47.5 feet of the east 89.0 feet of Lot 10 and
the N 112 of Lot 9, Block 58, Original City of Little
Rock, Pulaski County, Arkansas."
The architectural significance in the 1978 survey is
of a Priority II (1 being the highest and III being the
lowest) and Historical Significance of Local
significance. 1988 survey lists the property as a ca.
1910 Colonial Revival house and a contributing
structure.
,tip c' f o
-Q
The application is for an 1) addition to rear of Location of Project
house, 2) roof replacement, 3) siding replacement, 4) picket fence in front with arbor
and 5) exterior lighting.
PREVIOUS ACTIONS ON THIS SITE:
On November 1, 2000, an administrative approval to replace a cedar shingle roof with a
roof of same material with no changes to roof slope and no introduction of new
architectural detailing or materials was granted.
Existing front east elevation
x
tir•�F'.
Existing north elevation
•..rar;�',C�. .:5: .:err.- .tn.,x,. ��. .-� ..
• : •
JT
•";.. -- -
:• r.J
.sue
f..�,.
Existing south elevation
PROPOSAL: 1) addition to rear of house, 2) roof replacement, 3) siding replacement, 4)
picket fence in front with arbor and 5) exterior lighting.
1) Addition to the rear of the house
The proposed addition is a 16' by 30'
addition across the entirety of the back of
the house for a sunroom, mud room and
expanded bathroom. The darkish "L"
shaped feature is a stairway to the attic for
storage access.
Windows:
There will be no new windows on the south
side of the addition. There will be three
3'x6' windows on the north side of the
addition, there will be one 2'x6' window on
either side of the French door on the west
Existing Kitchen
aw,�
i Bathroomy
I "
SunrOOM —
b .�w /1Y.a4Wd i.l Mud mon
Mud Room
j
b %
'roposed plan of addition
2
side of the addition. There will also be an oval window above the French door. In
addition, on the west facade, there will be a 4'x4' window. The windows will be single
hung Alenco windows, white in color.
Proposed North Elevation with addition
P
Proposed South Elevation with addition
Doors:
There will be a exterior door on the south side of the addition located in the mud room
with no widows in the door. There is a proposed French door facing west located in the
sunroom.
The photo provided in the packet "Capture the
Outdoors" is similar to the improvements
described by the applicant. There will be an
oval window above the door instead of the
modified Palladian window.
Roofing on the new addition: The sunroom
portion of the addition will have a gable end
roof as shown in the "Capture" photo. The
mudroom area will have a shed roof slanting to
the west that will tie into the existing and
proposed roofs. The shingles will be Tamco
Architectural shingles, weatherwood in color.
The proposal is to re -roof the entire house.
The siding on the addition would be Hardiplank
8" smooth lap siding. The color would be pale
yellow with light colored trim.
Capture the Outdoors photo
2) Roof Replacement
The roof replacement will replace the cedar shake roof with architectural shingles. The
shingles will be Tamco Architectural shingles, weatherwood in color. The proposal is to
reroof the entire house.
3
31 Siding Replacement
The oronosal is to replace the wood siding on the original house with Hardiplank 8"
v.i_I— I Ir JTI vll_.t4:Il !y. —tll_y_ I _ ivif Iti_ lll Irv—1 _�I_Iv— v—!_i•iJ_.il_l�_ _.
I
'1r i .11
I II l.l�v Ir ..I yv I
order. if replaced, t1 ie°y` would be replaces witi i ti ie sa1-1 1 e Size lumber
4) Picket Fence in Front with Arbor
1 he PICKel tense would be across The entirety of tie ]MI it of the property along
Commerce StrP_.P_.t and return tot the existing fences on the north and South sides of the
house. The applicant states the fence will be" no taller than 36" tali, pickets no wider
that 4 inches wide and M,, IFurtl,er than three inches apart. The design will be
compatible and proportionate to the house. It will be made of wood and painted white
or cream dependant on the trim color I use for the house." The arbor will me made to
duplicate the one shown below.
rw-f�rr,aa fu:J< �uunnLu vr: a`iiyvnv, mom.
-_.__---
E, S. (Slam CunNlgM1aln Jr. IPLAIf»'+1 o"dVV. eradu INLSa61
�
M—ft c, cola (RLW
1p11PMGkf111iFi
i �� CCtifM EI�CE �7/�EET
X
'
•�tiA
��.
76' _
�
� 25'
uu'
�
1 <' 15 fo rY
Piame
az' pj
x c
i
MZf
v
a
Location of fence in front yard
Proposed Arbor on Commerce Street
5) Exterior Lighting
The details of the lamppost and lighting to be added to the front yard were not provided
to the Staff for review.
WRITTEN ANALYSIS OF THE APPLICATION BASED OFF OF INTENT AND
GUIDELINES:
1) Addition to the rear of the house
The zoning of the site is R-4A that has a 25' setback for the rear yard. This addition will
abut or go over the setback, which would require a Board of Adjustment Variance. The
addition is difficult to see from the street, so it is questionable fi the commission should
hear the case. However, the addition of the fence, the replacement of the siding, and
the reroofing dictates that a public hearing is held.
It appears that the new window on the south side of the structure is in the original block
of the house. This would involve removing, replacing, or adding a window to the original
structure. In the photo above, labeled "Existing South Elevation" the photo shows two
111
vertical windows (one over one). Staff is not supportive of removing two original
windows and adding this new window, especially a square windows that does reflect the
original verticalness of all the existing windows on the original block of the house.
Modifying a size of an existing window or adding a new window is not recommended in
the guidelines as stated on page 52 as quoted below:
Windows should be preserved in their original location, size, and design
with their original materials and number of panes. Stained, leaded,
beveled, or patterned glass, which is a character -defining feature of a
building, should not be removed. Windows should not be added to the
primary facade or to a secondary facade if easily visible. Windows should
be repaired rather than replaced. However, if replacement is necessary
due to severe deterioration, the replacement should match, as closely as
possible, the original in materials and design. Replacement windows
should not have snap -on or flush muntins. Unless they originally existed,
jalousie, awning, and picture windows and glass brick are inappropriate on
an historic building.
According to the website, the proposed windows are all vinyl. The applicant will need to
verify that in the public hearing. Having vinyl windows on an addition that is clearly
designed and readable as such, is not the same as replacement vinyl windows in the
original structure. The vinyl windows actually make the addition read more clearly that it
is a addition. Staff is supportive of the window choice in the addition only, not for the 4'
x 4' window replacement. Staff does recognize that the 4x4 window is located in he
bathroom. However, drapes, blinds, or window film can be used to block the view from
outside.
The guidelines state on page 62 under additions (new Rooms) that:
Additions should be of a compatible design, in keeping with the original
structure's character, roof shape, materials, and the alignment of window,
door, and cornice height. Additions include porches and bay windows, as
well as entire wings or rooms. They should be located on the rear facade
and be subordinate to the original structure.
The original building and the addition should be differentiated in a manner so that the
addition looks new and does not duplicate the original structure. The siding and roofing
may be different from the original block of the house. Those changes, along with
decreasing the size of the addition 12-18" on the north and south facades will create a
break form the original block of the house. This would result in an addition 27' to 28'
wide instead of 30' wide. The roofing (architectural shingles) and siding (Hardiplank
smooth lap siding) could be different with a logical break in this scenario.
The elevations provide show that the cornice height of the addition will be the same as
the original. This will aid to tie the addition to the original house while maintaining
separation of the addition. The roof over the sunroom is a gable. There are two other
gables on the main block, on facing east and one facing north as shown in the 1978
photo earlier in the report. The rest of the addition will be a shed roof. These roof types
5
proposed are either aiready on the house or are a common means of covering additions
i;=; ilia racer G a i itiiiSc vI a ... ei,_,.
91 Roof Reoiacemenl
The applicant has stated the there has
been issues with squirrels living in her
.,Mc ar? j has provided - pnoro o - in _ -•• _... _.
-aMaro lLn.ihere the/ enter her rnof- The is
Guidelines state on page 56: - —
Roofs should be preserved in
their original size, shape, and..�,,..-
pitch, with original features�--r--
(crestina, chimneys, finials,
f IJ i_Uia 6: CLI..I allU, II j.i'v3Jiviv,
with original roofing material
(slate, tile, metal.) Composition
shingles may be used if theoriginal material material is not Roof damage attributed to squirrels
economically feasible. Dark colors are best for historic buildings.
If the overall roof is still watertight, this is only a maintenance issue to repair the squirrel
damage. The applicant has not noted that the roof is leaking, only that there is squirrel
damage. Staff recommends that the applicant repair the roof, not replace it.
3) Siding Replacement
On page 50 of the guidelines, it states:
,Historic siding materials, such as weatherboard, wood shingles, and
stucco, should be preserved. If original siding materials must be replaced,
the new siding should match the original as closely as possible, especially
with respect to board size. Original corner boards should be duplicated in
their full original dimensions.
The applicant has provided photos of squirrel damage to the exterior of her home. The
applicant has not provided proof that the siding is uniformly rotted or non -water tight
overall. Again, Staff feels that this is a maintenance issue and that individual board
should be replaced to remove the threat of squirrels living in the attic. Siding can be
obtained locally for the repair work. Staff is not supportive of the removal of the original
siding.
4) Picket Fence in Front with Arbor
The applicant has proposed a front picket fence using the language for picket fences
found on page 66. She has also proposed a►. arbor with gate as shown earlier in this
report. The materials used and the technique used should distinguish this as a modern
element. Staff is supportive of the fence as described by the applicant and a duplication
of the arbor as shown ii � the photo.
6
5) Exterior Lighting
Staff recommendation forthcoming on the exterior lighting based on the submittal of the
actual materials.
NEIGHBORHOOD COMMENTS AND REACTION: At the time of distribution, there
were no comments regarding this application.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval with the following conditions:
1. Obtaining a building permit within 90 days of hearing.
2. Project to be completed within 180 days of obtaining permit.
3. Addition to rear of home: Staff is supportive of the addition if it does not
encroach into the 25' rear yard setback and is a width of 27' — 28' wide. Staff is
not supportive of the 4'x4' window on the south side.
4. Roof replacement: Staff is not supportive of replacing the cedar shake roof with
architectural shingles.
5. Siding replacement: Staff is not supportive of the siding replacement.
6. Fence and Arbor; Staff is supportive of the fence and arbor.
7. Exterior Lighting: Staff recommendation forthcoming.
7
ij
a•.. 4
:r
tt`7,
(io l ) 3,74-2878
06%06/08
Department of Planning and Development
723 West Markham Street
Little Rock, AR 72201-1334
Tn tha k4,,Ml PYC cf the MacArthur P?rlr T-T;gtp.;� rli�*rj�h !•.,mr,,;Sgi,)„
r.. _. r.�
ur tr requesting you- CGrrSider cil4ii u� - LTip7GVerf�crtiS i 'rViS 7 to iilakc to
my property at 1004 Commerce Street, Little .Rock, AR.
I am submitting plans for an addition on the back of my home which would include a sunroom,
bathroom expansion and mud/utility room. This addition would maintain the same roof line
and style of the existing home. I am also proposing to replace the roof and wood siding. My
proposal would include the changing of the type of roofing from wood shakes to architectural
shingles and the wood siding to hardy plank. I am proposing these changes due to the amount
of damage incurred from squirrels over the last 4 years I have lived in the home. I have had
multiple repairs to the roof and multiple visits from Adams Pest Control in vain attempts to
maintain the structural integrity of the home. I presently have new damage to the roof in
several areas and an area under the front gable of the home where squirrels have eaten through
the siding to obtain entrance to the attic. I also have electrical wiring damage that I have yet to
repair that controls the front porch light fixture.
I would also propose a wood picket style fence with gate and arbor over the gate. This fence
would meet all guidelines as detailed on page 66 of the NtaeArthur Park Historic District
Guidelines for Rehabilitation and New Construction .Manual.
My goal is proper maintenance of the property as well as adding to the value of the home. This
will benefit the historic district as the changes I am proposing will improve the exterior curb
appeal without jeopardizing the h'sstoric structure. In truth, it will prevent further damage
to the structure as hardy plank is a mixture of wood with other compounds that are impenetrable
to rodents and insects. This type of siding maintains the look of wood siding since it is
made with wood without the inherent problems that came with regular wood plank siding.
The change in type of shingles will also achieve the preservation of the structure with the
prevention of damage from squirrels chewing through the wood shakes.
Thank you for your consideration of my proposal.
pee ]ly.
e e
Cover letter from applicant
JUL-19-2004 10134 LU+iLV w mw<a acrNcr rnu —1 — _ _ ....._.
ULIHALU VV. OrtV Vf%*, I"%,-
E.S, (San) CunrdnQhsm, Jr. (RLSN137� Donald W. Brooks (RLW TImathy C. Cote (RLS111399)
20e20 ARCH STREET PIKE
MENSLEY,M 72M
PHONE MI) eeeaax o24 • 5S 2)91 LH
C:JMM EACE 5TAEE7-
L, - s.
PFJ 75
r�1T'
M
4' I S f0 re�
a z, o frame
� v V
C
Po0I
(P.F�r �Pf
a7+ 47,51
ass 1
� n
Frame `�
� 81d9,
C or "/o'' co r ,.9,r
Q7
/,Pit, lPF
i,z, 250' r+
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
The South 47.5 feet of the East 89.0 feet of Lot 10 and
the N= of
Lot 9, Block 58, ORIGINAL CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, Pulaski County,
Arkansas.
This property is not, in the 100 year flood plain as per
Panel 107
of 150 for Little Rock, AR. Community -Panel ;0501810107
F, dated
October in Flood Lore X.
ACKNONLBDGED2001
07/30/04
ytiti+•"'�x5
.•• q.
Rosalind Michelle Welch
:
Data of Survey: July 19, 2004
.'STATE SOV ..
NARROS ¢:
Scala: 1" 20'
o
Property Address: 1004 Commerce Street
' O -
sauz>at
For Use & Benefit 0f: Rosalind Michelle Welch
; oy p '
Full Spectrum Lending?tq
a g??• V�,�
Lenders Title Company
%,�G�r--�Vr;S
r,
This is (a fnv at the abmm swdbed land has Wen surveyed. The comers are marked a Mown and
de
aro- in,, with "FUny monuments in the rklrAy.
This eertFf radon Is for end AmHsd to the parties shown hereon.
TOTAL P.02
Survey of property
E
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND
DEVELOPMENT
€ : LITTLE ROCK
3` f '' HISTORIC 723 West Markham Street
� .r
Little Rock, Arkansas 72201-1334
DISTRICT
COMMISSION Phone: (501) 371-4790 Fax: (501) 399-3435
STAFF REPORT
ITEM NO. Two.
DATE: July 14, 2008
APPLICANT: John Pagan, Arkansas Arts Center
ADDRESS: 501 East 9th Street
COA
REQUEST:
Brick screening wall around new air conditioning unit and sign at 9th
and Commerce.
PROJECT BACKGROUND AND DESCRIPTION:
The subject property is located at 501 East 9th
Street. The property's legal description is "Part of
Section 2, T1 N, R12W, more particularly described
as that part of the SW lying east of Quapaw Line,
West of McAlmont Street and South of East 9th
Street, Pulaski County, Arkansas."
The 1988 survey lists the structure as a 1960's
museum building of a non-contributing status. The
original building was a WPA Moderne building built
ca 1937 as shown on page 43 of the Guidelines.
The front fagade can be seen in one of the galleries.
The building has been added onto in several stages
over the years.
Location of Project
This application is for two items. The first part is a brick screening wall around a new air
conditioning unit and the second part is a sign at 9th and Commerce.
PREVIOUS ACTIONS ON THIS SITE:
On March 17, 1989, approval for additions and modifications to the building.
On May 7, 1998, approval with conditions for a 31,500 sf addition to the building
complex.
PROPOSAL -
Brick Sc? eenina Wail:
The Flrick screening wail will be on the northwester iy corner of the ;rts (a, L building,
visible from the Ninth and Commerce Street intersection. It will be west and adjoining
the driveway/loading dock. The brick screening wall is necessary to screen a new air
COnditilcmirin unit. that ,&JI! need t0 be placed In ilhat !ocalion TOI fine . OITe/Rockete lei.
^_II--. The
n-+� Center +... a,.�rLirir. +n m }nh the hrirk n_f the grlinininn hllildina qS
Gallery. i I e Ak is Ce i e is vvvl nn ey w i � law, : _......� .0
closely as possible. The wall height is variable with a maximum of T-8" feet tail. The
height of the a/c unit is 4'-4" inches tali and sits on a pad 18" above grade for a 101.al
height of 5'10" tall. The wall will be approximately 24" taller than the unit. The wall will
project a total of 16-10" from the north wall and be 17'-2" wide east to west. There will
_ + +h .. + nirJ� .,f +ho inroil fnr nr-r imc mal�,ia n{ rialx/a 1117P./i Ill Ptal C1a IntP_.d
be an i! UI I n e c) ii ii iG east Ji'da ..F a !e, v•r un iv: �... ,-
y -.:
s� �- i_ ice_ The north, west d t vino ,mill i-ho hrir
Drown to match 'tne I ailing o 11 iC ri Gl.�t. I I !C I L iV11� L and lU east U�..ci —11i c...v K.
There will also be an additional bollard added to match the existing to the east.
The southwest corner of the wall will have a planter built that is 45 inches tall. It will
also be of brick with landscaping in the planter. The planter will help to soften the height
of the screening wall.
New
Bollard,
Proposed north elevation
2
Proposed view from northwest
Included in the application package are specifications for the a/c unit that state that it is
a quiet unit that produces little noise and vibrations compared to competitive units on
the market.
Signage:
The sign will be placed at the corner of Commerce and Ninth Streets. The text will be
"Arkansas Arts Center" with an arrow that will direct traffic down Commerce Street. The
sign will be two sided. The dimensions will be 8'-0" wide and 18" tall for a total of 12
square feet. It will be supported on short posts that will allow the sign to float above the
ground approximately six inches. The sign will be made of fabricated aluminum with cut
aluminum plate lettering. The background will be a custom finish of burnished
aluminum to make it a matte non -shiny finish. It will have black text and arrow. The
posts will be set in concrete footings. The text will be the Swiss Extended Font as
shown second from the bottom on the graphic.
3
.. r•
- . _. ...
r l INSTAra.er LLATIOC 1i0N
ARCIIITCCTURAL SIGNS
i Arkansas Arts Center ,
• !lira r-finr•_I "„1.�.^. �.^.^�nY Siam
5L'Y I
1
Material
Fabricated aluminum manumenl
_..
• - ---
sign with cui aluminum plate lettering
:� •'�j;,---'
-
1 -4
Size
=,e 5-1•77Arkansas Arts Center 1 Ig
As shown x3'd
Background Colo!
Custom aluminum finish
---- — ------ --- --- --- --- ----- - --- -
arkansas arts cenLer
Mounting Method
Posts are direct burled and set in
concreio footiri9s
Font: Swiss Bold Extended
Notes
Arkansas Arts Center E-
For1r. Swiss Extended
Arkansas arts Center <-j
Scale: Y-"
— 219 W. 764 St NLR, AR 72114
Phone: 501.372.8881
Font: Swiss Bold Condensed
___ Faz: 501.372.B8B2
` -- --'
Proposed signage
WRITTEN ANALYSIS OF THE APPLICATION BASE® OFF OF INTENT AND
GUIDELINES:
Brick Screening Wall:
On page 78 of the Guidelines, it states under number 7. Mechanical systems for
Commercial Structures:
Mechanical systems, such as heating and air conditioning units, electrical
connections, exterior stairs and elevators, should be located so that street
visibility is minimal.
By screening the unit with a brick wall that repeats other screening walls on the building
and by adding a planter on the west side, they have attempted to minimize the unit and
its screen wall.
S
Signage:
The Guidelines state under E: Signs on page 71:
E. SIGNS
Signs should be subordinate to the architecture and overall character
throughout the district. Historic signs should be preserved, including
"ghost" signs on the sides of buildings.
2. Free -Standing:
Free-standing signs should be low, small, and constructed of wood or a
non -shiny finish. The recommended size should not exceed six square
feet in area. These signs should be located in landscaped areas...
3. Materials for signs:
Materials used for signs should be traditional, such as finished wood,
glass, copper, or bronze, not plywood, plastic, unfinished wood, neon or
other internally lighted materials, or flashing lights. Materials should be
compatible with the building materials.
4. Design of signs:
The design of the signs should be appropriate to the building, in size,
lettering, and style. Business logos or symbols are desirable. If several
businesses share a building, coordinate the signs. Flashing, rotating,
moveable, or portable signs should not be used.
5. Lighting of signs:
Lighting of signs should be from remote sources, preferably for the ground
aimed directly at the sign and shielded from street view. Lighting should
not use visible bulbs, internal sources or luminous paint.
The design of the sign is modern and will not be confused with a historic sign. The sign
will not be lighted by fixtures dedicated for this purpose; the only lighting will be ambient
light from the streetlights.
NEIGHBORHOOD COMMENTS AND REACTION: The Parks and Recreation
department has responded to Staff and they are okay with the installation of the sign
and the screening wall.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval with the following conditions:
1. Obtaining a building permit.
2. Project to be completed within 180 days of obtaining permit.
5
i,— r N)OR
Department of Planning and Development
723 West Markham Street
Little Rock, AR 72201- 1334
To Whom It May Concem:
The Arkansas Arts Center is requesting a Certificate o€Appropriateness for work to be
done on the North West corner of the Arkansas Arts Center, located at-501 East SO Street,
Little Rock. Work consists of installing a brick screen wall to enclose a new carrier
AquaSnan air- cooled chiller. This is needed to enhance the mechanical system for. the
Wolfe/ Rockefeller Gallery at the Center. The area for the construction is directly
adjacent to the west loading dock of the current building. The total cost for the
construction of the screen wall is estimated at 20,000.00.
We are also asking permission to install. a directional sign located at the Corner of 9th and
Commerce for the Arts Center. The sign will be fabricated aluminum with "Swiss
Extended" font. The sign will be set back on the corner apprwdmately 20 feet. The sign
will be donated.
Sincerely,
John Pagan
Arkansas Arts Center
Facility Manager
Cover letter from applicant
P.O. Box 2137
MacArthur Park, 9ih & Commerce
Little Rack, Arkansas 72203
501-372-4000
50i-375-8053 Fax
6
LITTLE ROCS
HISTORIC
,t DISTRICT
COMMISSION
tl7f"�.
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT
723 West Markham Street
Little Rock, Arkansas 72201-1334
Phone: (501) 371-4790 Fax: (501) 399-3435
APPLICATION FOR A
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Application Date:
0
1. Date of Public Hearing:— day of _ i "� 200 0—at :Oc7 P.M.
2. Address of Property: 501 EAST 9TH STREET 9TH AND COMMERCE
3. Legal Description of Property: ROUTHWF5T CORNER OF 9TH ANQCOMMERCE
4. oeeg0 ?5 ne[9Natg�Address, Phone, Fax): CITY OF LITTLE ROCK ARKANSP.S ARTS CENTER
5. Owner's Agent: JOHN PAGAN hone/Fax/E-mail) 396-0315 975-5900 JOHN.PAGANIqARKARTS.C(
6. Project Description (additional pages may be added):
RTHVIE
7. Estimated Cost oflinprovements: CONSTRUCTION $25 00.00 TOTAL JOB 125,000.00
8. Zoning Classification: Is the proposed change a permitted use? Yes No
CENTER
9. Signature of Owner &Agent• 1
(7heOwner will rue aulharizeany,as orpvaonrepresenlingthe oxnerafdiepublic hemingJ.
NOTE: Should there be changes (design, erials. size, j from the approved COIL, applicant shalt notify Comtnission.staff and
take appropriate actions. Approval by the C scion da t excuse applicant or property from complianea with other applicable
codes, ordinances or policies of the city unl stated by the Commission or staff. Responsibility for identifying such codes, ordi-
nances or policies rests with the applicant, owner or agent.
(This section to be completed by staff):
Little Rock Historic District Commission Action
Denied Withdrawn Approved ❑Approved with Conditions ❑ See Attached Conditions
Staff Signature:
Little Rock Historic District Commission ♦ Department of Planning and Development
723 West Markham Street ♦ Little Rock, Arkansas 72201 ♦ Phone: (501) 371-4790 ♦ Fax: (501) 399-3435
Application
7
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND
DEVELOPMENT
LITTLE ROCK
HISTORIC 723 West Markham Street
DISTRICT Little Rock, Arkansas 72201-1334
Phone: (501) 371-4790 Fax: (501) 399-3435
COMMISSION
STAFF REPORT
ITEM NO. Two.
DATE: July 14, 2008
APPLICANT: John Pagan, Arkansas Arts Center
ADDRESS: 501 East 9th Street
COA Brick screening wall around new air conditioning unit and sign at 9th
REQUEST: and Commerce.
PROJECT BACKGROUND AND DESCRIPTION:
The subject property is located at 501 East 9th
Street. The property's legal description is "Part of
Section 2, T1 N, R12W, more particularly described
as that part of the SW lying east of Quapaw Line,
West of McAlmont Street and South of East 9th
Street, Pulaski County, Arkansas."
The 1988 survey lists the structure as a 1960's
museum building of a non-contributing status. The
original building was a WPA Moderne building built
ca 1937 as shown on page 43 of the Guidelines.
The front facade can be seen in one of the galleries.
The building has been added onto in several stages
over the years.
r' .,„
Location of Project
This application is for two items. The first part is a brick screening wall around a new air
conditioning unit and the second part is a sign at 9th and Commerce.
PREVIOUS ACTIONS ON THIS SITE:
On March 17, 1989, approval for additions and modifications to the building.
On May 7, 1998, approval with conditions for a 31,500 sf addition to the building
complex.
PROPOSAL:
Brick Screening Wall:
The brick screening wall will be on the northwesterly corner of the Arts Center building,
visible from the Ninth and Commerce Street intersection. It will be west and adjoining
the driveway/loading dock. The brick screening wall is necessary to screen a new air
conditioning unit that will need to be placed in that location for the Wolfe/Rockefeller
Gallery. The Arts Center is working to match the brick of the adjoining building as
closely as possible. The wall height is variable with a maximum of 7'-8" feet tall. The
height of the a/c unit is 4'-4" inches tall and sits on a pad 18" above grade for a total
height of 5'10" tall. The wall will be approximately 24" taller than the unit. The wall will
project a total of 16'-10" from the north wall and be 17'-2" wide east to west. There will
be an iron gate on the east side of the wall for access made of galvanized metal painted
brown to match the railing to the east. The north, west and east sides will be brick.
There will also be an additional bollard added to match the existing to the east.
The southwest corner of the wall will have a planter built that is 45 inches tall. It will
also be of brick with landscaping in the planter. The planter will help to soften the height
of the screening wall.
Proposed north elevation
2
Proposed view from northwest
Included in the application package are specifications for the a/c unit that state that it is
a quiet unit that produces little noise and vibrations compared to competitive units on
the market.
Signage:
The sign will be placed at the corner of Commerce and Ninth Streets. The text will be
"Arkansas Arts Center" with an arrow that will direct traffic down Commerce Street. The
sign will be two sided. The dimensions will be 8'-0" wide and 18" tall for a total of 12
square feet. It will be supported on short posts that will allow the sign to float above the
ground approximately six inches. The sign will be made of fabricated aluminum with cut
aluminum plate lettering. The background will be a custom finish of burnished
aluminum to make it a matte non -shiny finish. It will have black text and arrow. The
posts will be set in concrete footings. The text will be the Swiss Extended Font as
shown second from the bottom on the graphic.
9
Arkansas Arts Center <-`
arkansas arts center <-,
Font: Swiss Bold Ex;ended
Arkansas Arts Center
Font: Swiss Extended
arkansas arts center <-
Font: Swiss Bold Condensed
Proposed signage
,�w DESIGN
/r I FABl"CATION
l ; INSTALLATION
ARCHITECTURAL SIGNS
Arkansas Arts Center
Directional Monument Sign
Material
Fabricoled aluminum monument
sign with cut aluminum plate letle
Size
As shown x 3" d
Background Color
Custom aluminum finish
Copy Color
Black
Mounting Method
Posts are direct buried and set in
concrete footings
Notes
Scale: W' = 1'-0"
219 W. 7th St„ NLR, AR 72114
Phone: 501,372.8881
Fax: 501.372-8882
WRITTEN ANALYSIS OF THE APPLICATION BASED OFF OF INTENT AND
GUIDELINES:
Brick Screening Wall:
On page 78 of the Guidelines, it states under number 7. Mechanical systems for
Commercial Structures:
Mechanical systems, such as heating and air conditioning units, electrical
connections, exterior stairs and elevators, should be located so that street
visibility is minimal.
By screening the unit with a brick wall that repeats other screening walls on the building
and by adding a planter on the west side, they have attempted to minimize the unit and
its screen wall.
.19
Signage:
The Guidelines state under E: Signs on page 71:
E. SIGNS
Signs should be subordinate to the architecture and overall character
throughout the district. Historic signs should be preserved, including
"ghost" signs on the sides of buildings.
2. Free -Standing:
Free-standing signs should be low, small, and constructed of wood or a
non -shiny finish. The recommended size should not exceed six square
feet in area. These signs should be located in landscaped areas...
3. Materials for signs:
Materials used for signs should be traditional, such as finished wood,
glass, copper, or bronze, not plywood, plastic, unfinished wood, neon or
other internally lighted materials, or flashing lights. Materials should be
compatible with the building materials.
4. Design of signs:
The design of the signs should be appropriate to the building, in size,
lettering, and style. Business logos or symbols are desirable. If several
businesses share a building, coordinate the signs. Flashing, rotating,
moveable, or portable signs should not be used.
5. Lighting of signs:
Lighting of signs should be from remote sources, preferably for the ground
aimed directly at the sign and shielded from street view. Lighting should
not use visible bulbs, internal sources or luminous paint.
The design of the sign is modern and will not be confused with a historic sign. The sign
will not be lighted by fixtures dedicated for this purpose; the only lighting will be ambient
light from the streetlights.
NEIGHBORHOOD COMMENTS AND REACTION: The Parks and Recreation
department has responded to Staff and they are okay with the installation of the sign
and the screening wall.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval with the following conditions:
1. Obtaining a building permit.
2. Project to be completed within 180 days of obtaining permit.
5
COMMISSION ACTION:
Brian Minyard, Staff, made a presentation
planter beds and the proposed signage.
commissioners.
JuIV 14 2008
o the air conditioner unit screen including
There were no questions of staff by the
John Pagan, Facilities Manager Arkansas Arts Center, was present to present the
application. He stated that the reason for the new screen was to enhance the air
conditioning system. The existing unit is very inefficient. The new unit is an aqua
cooled unit and is quieter than most units of its size. It should be less noisy than the
freeway noise.
He discussed the sign next. The sign was donated to the Art Center. They are aware
of the Conway Schulte plan and will take sign up if it does not fit in with the new master
plan.
Commissioner Julie Wiedower asked about the screen detail. Mr. Pagan replied that it
was a solid brick wall that will look identical to the west wall of the building. He
continued to discuss the double metal gate on the east side. Mr. Minyard added that in
the staff report, the wall height varies form 7'-8" at the driveway to about one half that
height at the western elevation. Mr. Pagan stated the planter was added to break the
wall height.
Commissioner Wiedower continued and asked about the floor in the area. Mr. Pagan
responded that it was concrete everywhere within the enclosure. He also stated that
there was brick on top of the slab and mentioned the grass that is on the drive area.
The drainage will go into existing drainage and both sides of the wall will be brick.
Commissioner Wiedower stated that when she was on the commission before, they
commission approved the addition to the Arts Center. At that time, they were
concerned about the trees and some were lost. She asked what would be done to save
the closest tree to the new AC unit. Mr. Pagan stated that the footing would be hand
dug. He stated that they would do so to protect the tree.
Commissioner Susan Bell asked about the unit. Mr. Pagan responded that it was a
water-cooled air conditioner to meet requirements for a new exhibit "Pharaohs" from the
Boston Museum.
Chairman Marshall Peters asked a question on the proposed sign. He stated that the
placement of the sign at the corner could detract from the Quapaw Quarter Line
monument. Mr. Pagan stated that it is to be set back towards the maple tree, not right
on the corner, more to the east. The City of Little Rock will be asked to take the sign
down that is located to the west on 9th Street.
Mr. Minyard asked three questions. The first was which sign was to be taken down. A
discussion on tree protection was held. Mr. Pagan stated that the plan was to have all
Z
vehicles to drive on the driveway only. At the end of the discussion, it was decided that
the Art Center was a responsible neighbor and that it would do all possible to save the
tree. No amendment to the application or recommendation was made. The location of
the sign was discussed next. Does the commission request that the Staff go out to the
site to approve the location. Commissioner Wiedower stated that she did not have a
question on the size and shape. She did ask if they had considered sight lines at Ninth
and Commerce. Staff is to check progress.
Staff stated that the Staff recommendation stands as is with no changes. A motion was
made by Commission Wiedower to approve with Staff recommendations.
Commissioner Bell seconded and the motion passed with a vote of 3 ayes and 2
absent.
Commissioner Wiedower asked and Mr. Pagan stated that the timeline was to start
immediately. He is trying to meet the deadline for the Andy Warhol exhibit.
7
June 6, 2008
Department of Planning and Development
723 West Markham Street
Little Rock, AR 72201- 1334
To Whom It May Concern_
The Arkansas Arts Center is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness for work to be
done on the North West comer of the Arkansas Arts Center, located at-501 East 0 Street,
Little Rock. Work consists of installing a brick screen wall to enclose a new carrier
AquaSnap air- cooled chiller. This is needed to enhance the mechanical system for the
Wolfe/ Rockefeller Gallery at the Center. The area for the construction is directly
adjacent to the west loading dock of the current building. The total cost for the
construction of the screen wall is estimated at 20,000,00,
We are also asking permission to install a directional sign located at the Corner of 9 h and
Commerce for the Arts Center. The sign will be fabricated aluminum with "Swiss
Extended" font. The sign will be set back on the corner approximately 20 feet The sign
will be donated.
Sincerely,
John Pagan
Arkansas Arts Center
Facility Manager
P.O. Box 2137
MacArthur Park, 9th & Commerce
Little Rock, Arkansas 72203
501-372.4000
501-375-8053 Fax
Cover letter from applicant
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT
LITTLE ROCK
HISTORIC 723 West Markham Street
Little Rock, Arkansas 72201-1334
DISTRICT Phone: (501) 371-4790 Fax: (501) 399-3435
r COMMISSION
APPLICATION FOR A
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Application Date:
0
1. Date of Public Hearing: Aday of T �1 Imo-- 200 (tat ;22 p.m.
2. Address of Property: 501 EAST 9TH STREET 9TH AND CW4MERCE
3. Legal Description of Property: E
4, WprpS �75�wne �N�Address,
CITY OF LITTLE ROCK ARKANSAS ARTS CENTER
S.Owner's Agent:JDHN PAGAN
honelFax/E-mail) 396-0315 975-5900 JOHN,PAGAro!?ARKAP.TS.C(
6. Project Description (addkionai Pages may he added):
Gm
iT EDCE OF ARTS CENTER
7. Estimated Cost ofimprovetneuts: CONSTRUCTION S25 00.00 TOTAL JOB 125,000.00
8. Zoning Classification: Is the proposed change a permitted use? Yes No
9. Signature of Owner or Agent -
(Thu owner will m audnorize i" vrperw� representing dw owner at die public hearing).
NOTE: Should there be changes (design, erials, size, ) from the approved COA, applicant shall notify Commission staff and
take appropriate actions. Approval by the C sion t excuse applicant or property from compliance with other applicable
codes, ordinances or policies of the city tin] stated by the Commission or staff. Responsibility for identifying such codes, ordi-
nances or policies rests with the applicant, owner or agent.
(This section to be completed by staff):
Little Rock Historic District Commission Action
Denied ❑ Withdrawn Approved ❑ Approved with Conditions ❑ See Attached Conditions
Staff Signature:
Date:
Little Rock Historic District Commission ♦ Department of Planning and Development
723 West Markham Street ♦ Little Rock, Arkansas 72201 ♦ Phone: (501) 371-4790 ♦ Fax: (501) 399-3435
Application
7
mew
i
SI ILITTLE ROCK
HISTORIC
�lAr P^ DISTRICT
COMMISSION
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT
723 West Markham Street
Little Rock, Arkansas 72201-1334
Phone: (501) 371-4790 Pax: (501) 399-3435
LITTLE ROCK HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION
AGENDA
Monday, July 14, 2008, 5:00 p.m.
Sister Cities' Conference Room, City Hall
I. Roll Call
II. Finding of a Quorum
III. Approval of Minutes
a. June 9, 2008
IV. Deferred Certificates of Appropriateness
a. 501 E 7th Street
V. New Certificates of Appropriateness
1. 1004 Commerce
2. 501 East 9th Street
VI. Other Matters
a Enforcement issues
b Preservation Plan Update
c Citizen Communication
VII. Adjournment