Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutS-0594-A Staff Analysis-April 25, 1996 ITEM NO • 2 FILE NO.: S-954-A NAME: UNITED PROPERTIES SUBDIVISION, LOTS 1R AND 2 -- PRELIMINARY PLAT LOCATION_: On the south side of Kanis Rd., approximately 0.1 mile west of Bowman Rd., and extending southward with frontage on Bowman Rd., approximately 400 feet south of Kanis Rd. DEVELOPER: ENGINEER: Pat McGetrick UNITED PROPERTIES MCGETRICK ENGINEERING c/o 11225 Huron Ln. Suite 200 11225 Huron Ln., Suite 200 Little Rock, AR 72211 Little Rock, AR 72211 223-9900 223-9900 AREA: 6.71 ACRES NUMBER OF LOTS: 2 FT. NEW STREET: ZONING• PCD & R-2 PLANNING DISTRICT: CENSUS TRACT: 42.07 VARIANCES REQUESTED: PROPOSEDVgEESS: Mini -Warehouse, and general office and enclosed retail uses Ellis Mountain (18) None L Planning Commission review of a proposed PCD was conducted on May 13, 1986, with the PCD being established by the Board of Directors on June - 3,---1986, in Ordinance- No.-15r10-5 -- -This -action .--- - resulted from a request, -to add buildings to an already existing mini -warehouse facility. The facility had been in existence prior to being annexed into the City, and was a "non -conforming" use. The area involved was 2.57 acres. There were 5 existing buildings, with a total of 37,275 square feet of mini -warehouse area. Two additional buildings, with a total floor area of 16,140 square feet was proposed at that time. Dedication of 10 additional feet of right-of-way along Kanis Rd. was provided by Quitclaim deed. April 25, 1996 SUBDIVISION ITEM 4. 2 (Cont.) FILE NO. �j:954-A B . EXISTIyg C DITI N : The site is developed. Most of the area designated at Lot 1R is the location of the Kanis Mini -Storage facility. The remaining portion of Lot 1R, plus the area designated as Lot 2, is a residential lot which has had a residential structure located on it for decades. The topography of the site rises from an elevation along Bowman Rd. of 432 feet MSL (Mean Sea Level), to an elevation of 480 at the west edge of the property. There are existing retaining walls along the west property line and at the southeast corner of Lot 1 to permit the mini -warehouse development of the site. There is a 50 foot buffer designated along the west property line of the 1992-added tract (which abuts residential lots), and a 20 foot buffer along the south boundary of the tract. The existing zoning of the property is PCD for the original Lot 1, and R-2 for the remaining area. To the south and to the west of the 1992-added tract is R-2 zoned property. To the west of the original 1986 tract is "Bank and Business Forms" in a PCD. At the southwest corner of Kanis Rd. and Bowman Rd. are non -conforming commercial uses in an R-2 zoned area. Across Bowman Rd. to the east is the skating rink (also a non -conforming commercial use on R-2 zoned land) and C-3 zoned property. Across Kanis Rd. to the north is R-2 zoned land. C. EN=TEERING/OTZLITY COMMENTS: PUBLIC WORKS COMMENTS: The replat of Lot 1 necessitates dedication to Master Street Plan standards of the right-of-way for and Master'Street Plan pavement widening on Kanis Rd. An additional 6 feet of widening is required for-Kanis Rd., but -an "In -Lieu" contribution.versus construction of the street improvements is recommended at this time. The dedication of the additional right-of-way is to include relocation of City owned utilities. It is recommended that the applicant apply for a franchise for the fence which is located on the City right-of- way. (It is located within 35 feet of the centerline of Kanis Rd.) Relocation of the fence will be at the applicant's expense when Kanis Rd. is widened. The required right-of-way is 45 feet from centerline of Kanis Rd. for this Minor Arterial street. 3 April 25, 1996 SUBDIVISION ITEM NO.: 2 Cont. FILE NO. - 4-A Public Works has noted that right-of-way dedication --is required for both Kanis Rd. and Bowman Rd.; that one-half street improvements (with a sidewalk) are required along Bowman Rd.; and that, an "In -Lieu" payment be made for Kanis improvements. Dealing with the fence along the Kanis Rd. frontage of the site must be addressed at this time. F. STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: Staff recommends approval of the preliminary plat, subject to the Public Works rights -of -way and street improvements issues being addressed, and subject to either the fence along Kanis Rd. being removed from the right-of-way or a franchise being granted by the City. SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE COMMENT: (APRIL 4, 1996) Mr. Pat McGetrick, the project engineer, was present. Staff outlined the request to the Subdivision Committee members, and reviewed with Mr. McGetrick and the Committee the deficiencies and comments contained in the discussion outline. The Committee reviewed the proposed preliminary plat, and discussed the issues with Mr. McGetrick. David Scherer, with the Public Works staff, discussed with Mr. McGetrick the right-of-way and street improvements issues, as well as the fence issue along Kanis Rd. Mr. McGetrick reported that he would make the needed changes in the drawing and would supply staff with revised drawings and information, as required. The Committee forwarded the application to the full Commission for the public hearing. April 25, 1996 ITEM 2 FILE NO.: S--954-A NAME: UNITED PROPERTIES SUBDIVISION, LOTS 1R AND 2 -- PRELIMINARY PLAT LOCATION: On the south side of Kanis Rd., approximately 0.1 mile west of Bowman Rd., and extending southward with frontage on Bowman Rd., approximately 400 feet south of Kanis Rd. DEVELOPER: ENGINEER: Pat McGetrick UNITED PROPERTIES MCGETRICK ENGINEERING c/o 11225 Huron Ln. Suite 200 11225 Huron Ln., Suite 200 Little Rock, AR 72211 Little Rock, AR 72211 223-9900 223-9900 AREA: 6.71 ACRES NUMBER OF LOTS: 2 FT. NEW STREET: ZONING• PCD & R-2 PLANNING DISTRICT: CENSUS TRACT: 42.07 VARIANCES REQUESTED: BACKGROUND• PROPOSED USES: Ellis Mountain (18) None Mini -Warehouse, and general office and enclosed retail uses Planning Commission review of a proposed PCD was conducted on May 13, 1986, with the PCD being established by the Board of Directors on June 3, 1986, in Ordinance No. 15,105. This action resulted from a request to add buildings to an already existing mini -warehouse facility. The facility had been in existence prior to being annexed into the City, and was a "non -conforming - use. The area involved was 2.57 acres. There were 5 existing buildings, with a total of 37,275 square feet of mini -warehouse area. Two additional buildings, with a total floor area of 16,140 square feet was proposed at that time. Dedication of 10 additional feet of right-of-way along Kanis Rd. was provided by Quitclaim deed. April 25, 1996 SUBDIVISION ITEM NO.: 2 Cont. FILE NO.: 5-954-A Subsequently, on April 7, 1992, an amendment to the 1986-approved PCD was proposed. This amendment added a 2.65 acre tract south of the originally included property, and added 5 more buildings totaling 31,620 square feet. Provision was made at that time to add the area to the east of this additional tract, out to Bowman Rd., a 1.49 tract, as future development area. Based on the Planning Commission approval of a preliminary plat of the 5.22 site, a final plat was filed on August 10, 1992. This plat shows an 80 foot right-of-way for Kanis Rd. Included in the plat file for the final plat of the 5.22 acre "Lot 1" tract is a letter from the City Engineer returning the proposed Quitclaim deed for an additional 5 feet of required right-of-way for Kanis Rd., rejecting its wording which required the City to rebuild the existing fence along the Kanis Rd. frontage of the site if the City required its removal from the right-of-way. The City Engineer suggested that the property owner apply for a franchise for the continued use of right-of-way for the fence, but indicated that the owner would be responsible for removal of the fence if the area were needed for future street improvements. There is nothing after this date to indicate that the Quitclaim deed was amended and submitted (and filed) as required, nor that the franchise was requested. STATEMENT OF PROPOSAL: The applicant now requests inclusion of the 1.49 acre tract, (which extends eastward from the east edge of the tract added to the PCD in 1992, out to Bowman Rd.) into the plat area, for a total land area of 6.71 acres. Lot 1R is proposed to include all of the land area of the existing Lot 1, plus 102.27 feet eastward onto the added tract. Lot 2 is to be the remaining portion of the tract out to Bowman Rd. The applicant proposes to dedicate 25 feet of additional right-of-way along Bowman Rd. and to widen Bowman Rd. to provide the required one-half (of a 60 foot) Minor Arterial roadway. (No provision is made for additional right-of- way nor street improvements along Kanis Rd.) A. PROPO AL RE ❑EST: Planning Commission review and approval of a preliminary plat is requested. 2 April 25, 1996 UBDIVISION ITEM NO • 2 [Cant.) _ FILE NQ.: B. EXISTING NDITI The site is developed. Most of the area designated at Lot 1R is the location of the Kanis Mini -Storage facility. The remaining portion of Lot 1R, plus the area designated as Lot 2, is a residential lot which has had a residential structure located on it for decades. The topography of the site rises from an elevation along Bowman Rd. of 432 feet MSL (Mean Sea Level), to an elevation of 480 at the west edge of the property. There are existing retaining walls along the west property line and at the southeast corner of Lot 1 to permit the mini -warehouse development of the site. There is a 50 foot buffer designated along the west property line of the 1992-added tract (which abuts residential lots), and a 20 foot buffer along the south boundary of the tract. The existing zoning of the property is PCD for the original Lot 1, and R-2 for the remaining area. To the south and to the west of the 1992-added tract is R-2 zoned property. To the west of the original 1986 tract is "Bank and Business Forms" in a PCD. At the southwest corner of Kanis Rd. and Bowman Rd. are non -conforming commercial uses in an R-2 zoned area. Across Bowman Rd. to the east is the skating rink (also a non -conforming commercial use on R-2 zoned land) and C-3 zoned property. Across Kanis Rd. to the north is R-2 zoned land. C. ENGINEERING/UTILITY COMMENTS: PUBLIC WORKS COMMENTS: The replat of Lot 1 necessitates dedication to Master Street Plan standards of the right-of-way for and Master Street Plan pavement widening on Kanis Rd. An additional 6 feet of widening is required for Kanis Rd., but an "In -Lieu" contribution versus construct'_on of the street improvements is recommended at this time. The dedication of the additional right-of-way is to include relocation of City owned utilities. It is recommended that the applicant apply for a franchise for the fence which is located on the City right-of- way. (It is located within 35 feet of the centerline of Kanis Rd.) Relocation of the fence will be at the applicant's expense when Kanis Rd. is widened. The required right-of-way is 45 feet from centerline of Kanis Rd. for this Minor Arterial street. 3 April 25, 1996 SUBDIVISIDN ITEM NO_: 2 Cont.) FILE NO.: S-954--A Lot 2 will require dedication of right-of-way for Bowman Rd. to minor arterial standards and one-half street widening, including relocation of City -owned utilities. (An "In -Lieu" is not recommended for this frontage.) This widening will allow for vehicles to get off the traveled lanes prior to accessing the drive. A grading permit is required. The Stormwater Detention ordinance applies. Southwestern Bell Telephone Co. will required a 5' easement along the north, west, and south lot lines of Lot 2. Little Rock Water Works comments that a pro-rata frontage charge of $2.50/foot on Bowman Rd. or $12/foot on Kanis Rd. applies. On -site fire protection may be required. Little Rock Wastewater Utility comments that sewer is located along Kanis Rd. and Bowman Rd. Sewer is also located at the southwest corner of Lot 1R. Contact Little Rock Wastewater Utility for details. The Fire Department approved the plat. D. ISSUES LEGAL TECHNICAL DESIGN: No cover letter and no information sheet has been provided. No request for a waiver from dedication of right-of-way or street improvements is made for the Kanis Rd. frontage of the site. No provision is made for dealing with the fence which is located on right-of-way along the Kanis Rd. frontage of the site. Lot 2 has been changed to Lot "2R" on the revised plat submitted following the Subdivision Committee meeting. E. ANALYSIS• From a technical aspect, the preliminary plat is complete; it shows all required information. 4 April 25, 1996 SUBDIVISION ITEM NO.: 2 Cont.)FILE NO.: S-954--A Public Works has noted that right-of-way dedication. is, required for both Kanis Rd. and Bowman Rd.; that one-half street improvements (with a sidewalk) are required along Bowman Rd.; and that, an "In -Lieu" payment be made for Kanis improvements. Dealing with the fence along the Kanis Rd. frontage of the site must be addressed at this time. F. STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: Staff recommends approval of the preliminary plat, subject to the Public Works rights -of -way and street improvements issues being addressed, and subject to either the fence along Kanis Rd. being removed from the right-of-way or a franchise being granted by the City. SUBDIVISION COMMITTEE COMMENT: (APRIL 4, 1996) Mr. Pat McGetrick, the project engineer, was present. Staff outlined the request to the Subdivision Committee members, and reviewed with Mr. McGetrick and the Committee the deficiencies and comments contained in the discussion outline. The Committee reviewed the proposed preliminary plat, and discussed the issues with Mr. McGetrick. David Scherer, with the Public Works staff, discussed with Mr. McGetrick the right-of-way and street improvements issues, as well as the fence issue along Kanis Rd. Mr. McGetrick reported that he would make the needed changes in the drawing and would supply staff with revised drawings and information, as required. The Committee forwarded the application to the full Commission for the public hearing. PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION: (APRIL 25, 1996) The Chairman asked Bobby Sims, of the Staff, to present Item No. 2 on the agenda. Mr. Sims offered a brief comment which stated that this item had been intended to be placed on the Consent Agenda for approval. However, the owner has determined that there are issues attendant to this plat filing that require further discussion. These primarily have to do with the improvement to Kanis Road and the right-of-way issues attendant to that improvement. Mr. Sims pointed out for the record that the sole reason for placing this on the regular agenda is to deal with that right-of-way and improvement issue, and eventually a franchise through Public Works Department for retention of an existing chain link fence on the right-of-way after dedication. Sims identified David Scherer, of Public Works, as the staff person to address these improvements and right-of-way issues. Mr. Scherer offered an overview of the project and its history concerning when certain improvements were made on both the 5 April 25, 1996 SUBDIVISION ITEM NO. 2 [Cant.) _FILE NO.-�4-A building and the site and physical improvement in the right -of- way of Kanis Road. He stated that part of this project began even before it was annexed. On the original approval by the Planning Commission and the City Board as a PCD for mini - warehouses, there was a Master Street Plan requirement of 80 feet total or 40 feet from the centerline. At that time the improvement on pavements was one-half of a 48 foot roadway. Since that time, the standards of a Master Street Plan have been increased to a 90 foot right-of-way with one-half of a 60 foot roadway improvement. Mr. Scherer pointed out that the developer at that time did provide the right-of-way and constructed the one-half street improvements. The change in the Master Street Plan occurred during 1988. He pointed out that in 1992 a developer came in with a second phase of construction on this project on a tract of land that proposed access to Bowman Road and would have no immediate affect or access upon the Kanis frontage. At that time, there was no assessment or even discussion on of requiring improvements or additional right-of-way on Bowman. That plan asked for deferral of the Bowman Road improvements until the second phase of the project was constructed. Scherer pointed out that the application now before the Planning Commission consists of the original site and some seven buildings, the five buildings of the second phase which came in 1992 and a new large building to be added to the total. All of these will take access from Kanis Road. Scherer pointed out that at this point that the developers have agreed to right-of-way which would be 90 feet as opposed to 80 feet. However, the disagreement comes in that the pavement requirement is no longer 24 feet from the centerline but 30 feet. He also pointed out that the intersection of Bowman and Kanis is very near this project. Indeed about a half block. Public Works has applied for federal funding for improvements to this intersection and signalization which will be impacted by the ability to provide the right-of-way and the improvements. Therefore, the current disagreement here between the City and this developer is the additional 6 feet of pavement to bring this road to the standard that is required currently for the Master Street Plan. Scherer stated that he believed it is purely an issue of the developer having constructed the city's Master Street Plan requirements in an earlier time. At this time, he feels that it is not his responsibility to add the additional 6 feet. In response to a question from Commissioner Hawn about where the new building would take access. David Scherer pointed out that all of this complex would be utilizing the same Kanis Road access point. The question was then posed about the fence and right-bf- way. The fence issue was addressed by Scherer. He stated that the fence was located along a property line derived from the April 25, 1996 SUBDIVISION ITEM NO.: 2 [Cont.] FILE NO.: 5--954--A original dedication to an 80 foot right-of-way. At this time, once the new right-of-way is dedicated the fence would be located inside the new street alignment. Therefore, a franchise from the City would be required to maintain that fence until such time as the City requires its removal. The Chairman then recognized Mr. Pat McGetrick, the engineer for the project. Mr. McGetrick came forward and offered commentary in support of the application. He stated that his developer feels that he had complied with all of the city's requirements for the Master Street Plan at an earlier time. They did construct all that the City required, that being half of the 48 foot street, curb and gutter, and other improvements. He feels at this time it is not appropriate for them to tear that out and rebuild it. Simply just to build one more building on their project site. In a response to a question from a commissioner. Mr. McGetrick referred to the illustration that he had presented. The response that he offered had to do with the circulation, the access and how the building that is proposed would tie in with the other structures. Bobby Sims, of the Staff, reminded the Commission that they would not only need a motion to approve the preliminary plat but a second motion to deal with the waiver requested by the applicant. A brief discussion then followed involving David Scherer, of Public Works, and several of the commissioners. Again discussing the improvements, the intersection, and the relationship of this project. Pat McGetrick, representing the applicant, injected a thought, that, what the city is requiring here is the applicant throw out the $15,000 dollars that was spent several years to widen the street, and now spend an additional $15,000 dollars to rebuild it 6 feet wider. The Chairman asked for two motions to be presented, one on the application as filed for the preliminary plat and the other or. the applicant's request for waiver. A motion was made to approve the preliminary plat as submitted and revised to the staff recommendation. This motion was approved by a vote of 10 ayes, 0 nays, and 1 absent. The second motion was offered dealing with the waiver request placed in the form of and motion that the developer make the improvements. A vote on this motion produced 10 ayes, 0 nays, and 1 absent. Therefore, the waiver was denied and improvement are required. 7 April 25, 1996 SUBDIVISION ITEM NO.: 2 Cont. FILE NO.: S-954-A Ed. Note/RW After the meeting staff was informed by Mr. McGetrick that his developer has decided to provide the in -lieu on Kanis Road and not pursue a waiver. 8