HomeMy WebLinkAboutS-0024-X Staff AnalysisANALYSIS OF HILLSBOROUGH PHASES VI & VII
The Site History section of the Agenda indicates that previous review on
this site has identified several very basic service problems, neighborhood
opposition resulting in a street closure request, repeated deferrals by
both the Planning Commission and Board of Directors, and much involvement
of the usual reviewing agencies, as the developer sought to resolve some
of the problems. An update on major issues is attached.
The current proposal on this site represents an attempt by the applicant
to subdivide a tract of 46.7 acres into 73 lots for single-family use. The
land involved consists of very difficult terrain with slopes averaging
22.43%. Ideally, proper development on such terrain incorporates very
careful site planning and the preservation of the natural terrain/environ-
ment into the design process, in order that the land is utilized efficiently
and without the need for excessive site grading. Individual lots require
special attention so as to provide safe, stable building sites, with no
drainage and access problems.
This property will be developed. The question we must address is how this
will be accomplished.
Staff is specifically concerned that this proposal incorporates extreme
measures for development. Our review reveals that excessive cut and fill
is needed in the right-of-way in order that access may be gained to many
individual lots. A lot -grade analysis reflects that there are 19 lots
with a 20% slope, 33 lots with 20-25% slope, and 21 lots that have slopes
over 25%. The City Engineers have determined that there is a potential
for difficult access to the 23 lots that have slopes of 20 to 25%, and
very difficult access to 28 lots with slopes over 25%. It is an open
question whether or not some of these lots can be used at all. Three (3)
cul-de-sac length waivers are needed, but have not been requested.
There are also broader issues to be resolved. Due to the Commission's
initial vote denying access through Windsor Court, and related discussions
by the Board resulting in a split vote giving limited access, there seems
to be a definite concern about the density tied to this street and questions
relative to how many lots it should serve and how far it should be extended.
These questions are especially important since there are undeveloped tracts
to the west which could be served by this street. Calls have been received
from other property -owners to the west requesting information as to whether
or not they will be allowed sewer and access as a result of this plat.
Staff believes this street should terminate in a cul-de-sac a short distance
within the subject property.
Further discussion with the Water Works reveals that service can be provided
above elevation 675 feet only at extreme cost. Storage facilities for as
many as ten (10) lots must be constructed at a potential cost in excess of
$10,000 per lot. To date, no firm agreement has been made between the de-
veloper and the Water Works.
Staff feels that this proposal should receive careful scrutiny by the
Commission, not only because of its sensitive topography, but also because
it wi1T set a precedent for the other undeveloped hilltops to the west.
It is incumbent upon the developer to provide us with a carefully designed
proposal indicating site -specific building and access plans. Perhaps a
single-family PUD would provide a vehicle through which the variations for
each individual lot can be worked out. Thus, staff is requesting deferral
of this item until such plans can be submitted.
UPDATE ON MAJOR HILLSBOROUGH ISSUES
1. ANNEXATION
A copy of a petition filed at the County Court House has been received
setting a public hearing for February 17th at 9:00 A.M.
2. WATER WORKS
A letter has been received stating the technical feasibility of providing
water service to the property up to elevation 675 feet. Approximately
ten (10) lots above this elevation will have to be served by additional
improvements to be installed at the developer's expense. At the
February 3rd meeting, the Water Works Commissioners declined to make a
commitment regarding service to the area above 675 feet until additional
progress pertaining to the development plan had been achieved.
3. WASTEWATER
a.) A letter has been submitted stating that the proposal was outside
of District 222's boundaries, but could be served based on their
policy of accommodating proposals that did not exceed three (3)
units per acre that were in the area of the watershed; provided
that a mutual connection agreement could be reached between the
district and the developer and provided that the property is
annexed to the City.
b.) A copy of a letter agreement between the Sewer District and the
developer outlining a density transfer of the 64 unused "sewer
entitlements" this developer owns to the property that lies out-
side of the district.
4. CITY BOARD ACTION
On February 7, 1984, it was decided to deny the petition for closure of
Windsor Court and allow a limited amount of access through the
development.
ANALYSIS OF HILLSBOROUGH PHASES VI & VII
The Site History section of the Agenda indicates that previous review on
this site has identified several very basic service problems, neighborhood
opposition resulting in a street closure request, repeated deferrals by
both the Planning Commission and Board of Directors, and much involvement
of the usual reviewing agencies, as the developer sought to resolve some
of the problems. An update on major issues is attached.
The current proposal on this site represents an attempt by the applicant
to subdivide a tract of 46.7 acres into 73 lots for single-family use. The
land involved consists of very difficult terrain with slopes averaging
22.43q. Ideally, proper development on such terrain incorporates very
careful site planning and the preservation of the natural terrain/environ-
ment into the design process, in order that the land is utilized efficiently
and without the need for excessive site grading. Individual lots require
special attention so as to provide safe, stable building sites, with no
drainage and access problems.
This property will be developed. The question we must address is how this
will be accomplished.
Staff is specifically concerned that this proposal incorporates extreme
measures for development. Our review reveals that excessive cut and fill
is needed in the right-of-way in order that access may be gained to many
individual lots. A lot -grade analysis reflects that there are 19 lots
with a 20% slope, 33 lots with 20-25% slope, and 21 lots that have slopes
over 251. The City Engineers have determined that there is a potential
for difficult access to the 23 lots that have slopes of 20 to 25%, and
very difficult access to 28 lots with slopes over 25%. It is an open
question whether or not some of these lots can be used at all. Three (3)
cul-de-sac length waivers are needed, but have not been requested.
There are also broader issues to be resolved. Due to the Commission's
initial vote denying access through Windsor Court, and related discussions
by the Board resulting in a split vote giving limited access, there seems
to be a definite concern about the density tied to this street and questions
relative to how many lots it should serve and how far it should be extended.
These questions are especially important since there are undeveloped tracts
to the west which could be served by this street. Calls have been received
from other property -owners to the west requesting information as to whether
or not they will be allowed sewer and access as a result of this plat.
Staff believes this street should terminate in a cul-de-sac a short distance
within the subject property.
Further discussion with the Water Works reveals that service can be provided
above elevation 675 feet only at extreme cost. Storage facilities for as
many as ten (10) lots must be constructed at a potential cost in excess of
$10,000 per lot. To date, no firm agreement has been made between the de-
veloper and the Water Works.
Staff feels that this proposal should receive careful scrutiny by the
Commission, not only because of its sensitive topography, but also because
it will set a precedent for the other undeveloped hilltops to the west.
It is incumbent upon the developer to provide us with a carefully designed
proposal indicating site -specific building and access plans. Perhaps a
single-family PUD would provide a vehicle through which the variations for
each individual lot can be worked out. Thus, staff is requesting deferral
of this item until such plans can be submitted.
UPDATE ON MAJOR HILLSBOROUGH ISSUES
1. ANNEXATION
A copy of a petition filed at the County Court House has been received
setting a public hearing for February 17th at 9:00 A.M.
2. WATER WORKS
A letter has been received stating the technical feasibility of providing
water service to the property up to elevation 675 feet. Approximately
ten (10) lots above this elevation will have to be served by additional
improvements to be installed at the developer's expense. At the
February 3rd meeting, the Water Works Commissioners declined to make a
commitment regarding service to the area above 675 feet until additional
progress pertaining to the development plan had been achieved.
3. WASTEWATER
a.) A letter has been submitted stating that the proposal was outside
of District 222's boundaries, but could be served based on their
policy of accommodating proposals that did not exceed three (3)
units per acre that were in the area of the watershed; provided
that a mutual connection agreement could be reached between the
district and the developer and provided that the property is
annexed to the City.
b.) A copy of a letter agreement between the Sewer District and the
developer outlining a density transfer of the 64 unused "sewer
entitlements" this developer owns to the property that lies out-
side of the district.
4. CITY BOARD ACTION
On February 7, 1984, it was decided to deny the petition for closure -.of
Windsor Court and allow a limited amount of access through the
development.