Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutBldg Pmt Denial 6.9.21 (void)Areee, w'0d -5. / Z . zap Letter of Intent In Support of Request for Variance 5404 Hawthorne Road Little Rock, Arkansas 72207 This letter of intent is in support of my request for a variance to the front 0 yard setback and side yard setback on the East side of the house. The intention is to preserve the character of the home without tearja& it down by adding a second story to the home. This addition would include covering the existing open air front porch, which lies inside outside of the front yard 25'-0" setback. We would also like to add additional height to our existing bay window on the front of our house. M This bay is currently within the frontyard setback area. This house renovation project would also include the removal of the parking pad in the front of the house. It would be replaced with a walkway to the street, a small parking space, and sod. There would also be the addition of a cantilevered Porte cochere over the current driveway to the east of the house, which would violate the current side yard setback. Due to the width of the lot and maintaining the current home, we are unable to add a side garage or a connecting garage to enter the house. This would allow for us to enter the home during inclement weather and have a covering for our car. As current residents of the heights, we are W ing to preserve this house while configuring it to work for a larger family. 7Lhe.&x-isting House would require d9 tear down to obtain a covered front porch while abiding by current front yar setbac cs. We are impacted even further by the front yard setback, since the front of our existing house is approximately 53' away from the curb of Hawthorne Street. We feel that our proposed changes would be a positive for the neighborhood as we are keeping the style of the house while making an improvement that would increase the property value and tax. Thank you for your consideration. i Sincerely, C e and Jace authrie AVevgr ►-�- SSG: ��:.,� e: f►�.�: & • 47. z l JP. /' ;R - ' .. 1.1 Itli GDR Common • Pounds • Resources My Infor Lookup Appllcatlons t 6PLA1 41 1111, 111, [3, Action wwa System • buiIdinq Application InfoVlevrei INFORMATION - APPLICATION# 202115248 „ppi,ca!ion Type OEM DEMOLITION PERMIT Pnmary Appitcant* 14 E WARD CONSTRUCTION NCIC`p- 5404 HA% TPORNE RD LITTLE ROCK AR 72207 Location Status Dates o Application is Open_ o Current milestone is SUBMIT MORE DETAILS o Current unpaid amount of SO 00 D Account: I AlVicat+on Details Revieves Inspections Conditions Requited Licenses Fees Valuations ADp�tC Processed I1 by Issued 11 by Final Il by Temp COO 11 by COO 11 by Job Description Wor pe{ $ -M DEIA+IOUITION Expires II Occupancy Type — iLY ZO at� r• C'e�r. 1� rF�df/ '� � undei Root Area. sgtt 2400 00 Actual Valuation i0.dD Commens teat down horse to star new home City of Little Rock Department of Planning and Development Planning 723 West Markham Street Zoning and Little flock, Arkansas 72201-1334 Phone: (501) 371-4790 Fax: (501) 399-3435 or 371-6863 Subdivision Jacey Gutherie 5404 Hawthorne Road Little Rock- AR 72207 Date: July 06, 2020 Dear Ms. Gutherie: Re: Case No. Z-9340-A _ Location: 5404 1•lawihome Road Issue: Setback Variance This is to advise you that in connection with your application case no. Z-9340-A, the following action was taken by the Board of Adjustment at its meeting on July 02, 2020. (a) _ Approved the application as filed. (b) X Approved the application with conditions. (c) Denied the application. (d) Deferred the application to the meeting. (e) _ _ _ Withdrew the application. (f) X See attached Board of Adjustment minute record for conditions. (g) Other: If a variance application is approved by the Board of Adjustment, all permits necessary for the initiation of work shall be obtained within two (2) years from the date of approval, unless an extension of time is granted by the Board. Otherwise, the Board approval of the application shall be considered void. According to the City's Zoning Ordinance Section 36-70: "Appeals from the decision of the Board of Adjustment shall be filed with the appropriate court of jurisdiction. This filing must occur within thirty (30) calendar days of the action by the Board of Adjustment." If you have any questions, please call me at 371-4792. Sincerely, Tim Herndon, Development Manager Department of Planning and Development MM/vh JULY 2, 2020 ITEM NO-' 2 File No.: Z-9340-A Owner: Chase & Jacey Guthrie Applicant: Jacey Guthrie Address: 5404 Hawthorne Road Legal Description: Lot 2, Block 6, Newton's Addition Zoned: R-2 Present Use: Single-family Residence Proposed Use: Single-family Residence Variance(s) Requested: A variance is requested from the area provisions of Sec. 36- 254(d)(1) to reduce the required front yard (south) setback from 25 feet to 19.5 feet (for porch, allowing also for attached steps.) And, from the area provisions of Sec. 36-254(d)(2) to reduce the required side yard (east) setback from 5 feet to 3 feet. Justification: The applicant's justification is presented in letter submitted at time of May 12. 2020 app ication ( c e . - STAFF REPORT A. Engineering Issues: No Comments, B. Staff Analysis: The R-2 zoned property located at 5404 Hawthorne Road is occupied by a one- story single-family residence, to which a second story is proposed to be added. A large concrete automobile parking pad exists in the front yard, according to the a licant's letter, to be p�a_attiia_lll removed a t time of the osed ome renova f_on. so according o� the applicant letter, sidewa from a fron entrance Hrfed lawn area wi[I increase. - The requested_yariance�spertain to: ex and' the existin f ant arch covering [with no proposed second story .above hl on a so side of tile' house: -creating a bay window spanning the ground and second flaars; b-po�i wItFu� t e fron yard setback; and creation of a covered Porte cochere on the east side, within the side yard setback. An existing single -car -width concrete driveway will JULY 2, 2020 ITEM NO_: 2 (CQN'T.) Z-9340-A extend from the front of the home to serve the porte cochere, which will serve as a car port. Front Yard Section 36-254(d)(1) states, "There shall be a front yard setback having a depth of not less than twenty-five (25) feet." The existing front porch lies entirely within the front yard setback, and the applicant wishes to cover it (not place a second floor over it) as part of the renovation project. This porch will in its entirety extend 7.1 feet into the front yard. The covering of the porch, the pre-existing condition, and the placement of porches in front yards is not out of character with many homes in the Heights environs. The proposed bay window will extend only approximately 3 feet into the front yard setback, less than the existing/proposed porch. Side Yard Section 36-254(d)(2) states, 'There shall be a side yard set -back on each side of the building having a width of not less than ten (10) percent of the average width of the lot, not to exceed eight (8) feet." The proposed 7.7-foot wide car port, or porte cochere, will extend eastward into the 5-foot sideyard by 2 feet, leaving 3 feet unencumbered. The car port will not be enclosed and will remain separated from the adjacent property by an existing privacy fence. Said side encroachment, as well as the proposed side carport, will be similar to numerous nearby properties. No objections to the proposed improvements by neighboring property owners are known as of this writing. Staff views the two variance requests as reasonable and is supportive for the above -stated reasons. Additional Consideration Section 30-43(a)(2)a. states, "No driveway shall be constructed within five (5) feet of a line drawn from the point of intersection of a property line with the right-of-way line of a street and perpendicular to the centerline of the street, except where property abuts an alley the minimum distance shall be ten (10) feet." This existing driveway lies just over one foot from the east property line (extended,) yet poses no interference with the adjacent property to the east and is, therefore, approved as a non -conforming existing condition. C. Staff Recommendation: Staff recommends approval of the requested/submitted front yard and side yard setback variances, per survey/site plan submitted by applicant on May 12, 2020, with the following con i ions: 2 JULY 2, 2020 ITEM NO.: 2 (CON'T.) _Z-9340-A • Covered front porch shall remain unenclosed on its east, south and west sides. • Porte cochere shall be unenclosed on its north, east and south sides_ _oe Note: Prior to any work in the Hawthorne Road right-of-way, plans for parking slab }' renovation and/or sidewalk construction must be submitted and approved by Planning & Development Engineering. Contact Vince Florian, PE (501)371-4817. Board of Adjustment (July 02, 2020) The applicant was present. There were no persons registered in support or opposition. Staff presented the item and recommendation of approval as outlined in the "staff recommendation" above. There was no further discussion. The item was placed on the consent agenda and approved as recommended by staff, including all staff comments and conditions. The vote was 4 ayes, 0 noes and 1 absent. The application was approved. lC - ve /XIQN 7. Z . Zc kPf _q a Salo/ q o Iry � � ��•�� F7'9)-M e, j 6�- is,3� . cn Q C7 tL Rio s' t a PROM VLp CANTIi PQRTE RED �j COCHE 21 � v� o a-, a. 33.v p,?% 19 Z-6 �u PROWBED— COVERED PORCH ; �I _ N SECOND 20 1 ' STORY ON N EXISTING 19.5' - BAY 11 RF r 50.�t --« G2��r �Ca✓!7 Zo v C-04C. — 1.09 2.0 P.y over Gf /. z. rC/, Sketch yYf� y �� n ✓ �[r 4 City of Little Rock Plannin & Development Case No: Z-9340-A 11 Title: Zoning Variance Name: Location: 5404 Hawthorne Road N A 7. R-- CDR Common Permits - Resources • My Infor Lookup Applications (BPLA) ♦1 1 i ► 011 • • _ Action. System - BtIIIding Application knfoViewer INFORMATION -APPLICATION# 202115246 Application Type BLD BUILDING PERMIT Primary Appkant* * E WARD CONSTRUCTION LSjrj?.;_.* 5404 HAWTHORN RD LITTLE ROCK AR 72207 Location Status Dates o Application rs Open o Current milestone is SUBMIT MORE DETAILS. o Current unpaid amount of $0.00 o Account: LF:-t!-LPG i Application Details Revieves Inspections Conditions Required Licenses Fees Valuations Apphcants sites Employees Related Records LO Processed 6/912021 II4:.8 0y User Web EY40" 1! Issued ►1 _ by Final 11 by Temp COD 11 , by Coo 11 by Job Description A r�"`��� ���'�+�••• Work Type NEW NEW /(/- / Occupancy Type* RES1 SINGLE FAMILY Declared Vatuabon 5550,000 D0 Calculated Valuation $0.00 Under Roof Area spit 519200 Actual Vakration 50.00 Comments* 2STORY on slab living room. kitchen. laundry. 4 bedrooms. 5 V2 baths, media room study room. porches dinning room. FORTE COCHERE 2 CAR GAR SEPE RATE LOT 2, BLOCK 6 NEWTON ADDITION �rvp :s e rn C0.1. l IM (:j)olk, S89'51'47"E--9.9.85' (MEAS.) fnd. 5/8" rebar w d 50.QQ' (PLAT fnd. 5/8" rebar IT •� �y V U � v b N �o y wo o� Poo ti b 6.1 fnd. 1/2" rebar cp 33'-4" i� I 00 PROPOSED HOUSE 41 j yar U U covere0— porch ., � Y C U N89'49'47" — .04' (M S.) �- 50. 0' PLAT) '7overelectric �� a� E' head concrete V L �r 7 Z . ' f ( �� ®water meter _ 4Q �e� " 5�10 If HAWTHORNE RD I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I HAVE SURVEYED LOT 2, BLOCK 6 OF NEWTON'S ADDITION TO THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, PULASKI COUNTY, ARKANSAS. PROPERTY LINES ARE LOCATED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ESTABLISHED PROPERTY LINES. THERE ARE NO APPARENT ENCROACHMENTS EXCEPT AS SHOWN. PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS ARE SHOWN AS DIRECTED BY THE BUILDER. NO PORTION OF THIS PROPERTY IS WITHIN THE 100 YEAR FLOOD BOUNDARY AS SHOWN ON THE RECORDED PLAT. FOR USE & BENEFIT OF: E. WARD CONSTRUCTION G:/DwG\2021/21-212D — Lot 2 Block 6 Newtons\survey.dwq C37" 5•ioo� Q 7j Bstd- 3.0 1 r a c� � � CGS✓ .-� Pa✓f 5 v ip r'o 10 e'vor d *C* AWPi ,#w / igrevve l ZS� fcraf fnd. 1 1/4" rebar owerNpole tele rls STAT �+ Af1l(MSAS =v 1,0.15 -�� SSG14 JOE WHITE & ASSOCIATES I NC. CIVIL ENGINEERING • CONSULTING SERVTCES -LAND SURVEYING .T.25 RAHLING CIRCLE, SUITE A•2 LITTLE ROCK ARKANSAS 72223 II PHONE (501)214-9I4I DATE: 6-3-21 SCALE: To- -:----20' JOB NUMBER: 21-2112D GENERAL NOTES 1. DIMENSIONS SHOWN ARE BASED ON PLANS SUBMITTED BY THE OWNER IFDURING CONSTRUCTION, THERE IS A DISCREPANCY IN DIMENSIONS THAT DO NOT MATCH EXISTING CONSTRUCTION, PLEASE CONTACT THE DESIGNER OR OWNER FOR CLARIFICATION. 2 INSTALL 2'-0" WIDE X 1'-0" HIGH SPREAD FOOTING UNDER WALLS OF 115 SAFE ROOMIPANTRY, WITH 3 94 BARS CONTINUOUS AND #4 TIES AT 24" ON CENTER WITH 8" CMU WALLS WITH #4 BARS AT 16" ON CENTER WITH ALL CELLS FILLED WITH 3000 PSI CONCRETE. 4" THICK CONCRETE SLAB WITH WAIF ON VAPOR RETARDER ON 4" GRAVEL BASE ON SB 2 FILL 4" THICK CONCRETE SLAB CEILING ON METAL DECK WITH NNE 9'-0" CEILING HT. 3, 101 ENTRY FOYER, 102 STAIR HALL AND 201 STAIR LANDING TO HAVE 1/2" PAINTED PLYWOOD PANELS WITH 1X4 VERTICAL AND HORIZONTAL WOOD BANDS WITH RECESSED PANEL MOLDING. ALL WOOD TO BE PAINTED. 4. EXTERIOR BRICK WING WALL ON SOUTHWEST CORNER OF 102 STAIR HALL TO EXTEND 12" PAST AND 16" WIDE PAST THE EXISTING BRICK WALL. TO THE BUILDING SETBACK LINE 5. INSTALL I' SPLIT SAICK. PAVERS ON THE COVERE0 ENTRY PORCH AND THE OPEN PORCH INSTALL 24" NUDE X 12"DEEP SPREAD FOOTINGS AROUND PERIMETER OF OPEN PORCH WITH 3 #4 BARS -CONTINUOUS WITH 24 TIES AT 24" ON CENTER. INSTALL T' CMU WALLS WITH LBLOCK AT TOP POUR 4" CONCRETE SLAB WITH W WF OM VAPOR BARRIER ON 4" GRAVEL BASE ON SB2 FILL 6 INSTALL 1 112" FURRING STRIPS AROUND THE CMU WALLS OF THE 115 SAFE ROOMIPANTRY 7" ASSUMED EXISTING EXTERIOR WALL CONSTRUCTION .4 12" BRICK POCKETM 112" WOOD STUDS/12" GYP BOARD 8. STAINED WOOD TREADS, PAINTED WOOD RISERS, PAINTED WOOD BALUSTERS, STAINED WOOD NEWEL POSTS AND PAINTED WOOD BALUSTERS AT 102 STAIR HALL. 9. INSTALL PAINTED BEADED BOAR0,00110I At THE COVERED EIITRT PORCH AND PORTE COCHERE CEILING. INSTALL TONGUE AND GROOVE PAOM39 GAR SIDING IN THE COVER ED TERRACE AND COVERED BALCONY CEILING. MATCH -STING WIDTH OF STAIR HALL 142 rr ,4. r", — 4.t,T - rr 1 s n � r-s" ` rr _ �— +•+• —`s,+e �Ir ra ur s'•r CENYFRUNE I MASTER BATH ONI CK) P �� 15 OPEN I MASTER - T, PORCH 0 0. i^ I 3 CLOSET P' . I 111 102 t1E MASTER 3 STAIR IF--I� OFFICE_BATH - - r� O HALL g iR we". CI 1l0 �If'� M0.5TER SPLR BRICK 1 TREA054315ER6 115 V { BEORQDM 4 I� OF VESTIBULE LAUNDRY.. H� L • ,il I i O • GOI¢'P T - ! REF A • F,9 FRON \ w 101- RY M �' SPLR Bbe0% D00 { i {�,- FOYER 4 ]'�' r•1- r'•14` 'f'-ir t T'•1'= I� - A F. TREADS-- AS R .; a ]{IIr ]1I]^ ']t+i 3 t� T--•t yr �,<jt2" $ •� .in w' _ L7 W EEV SINK aA5 0 N _ 1 Y COVERED i ENTRY PORCH RANGE f 108 - Plea FAMILY I _ COVERED *rIrt BRICK TERRACE H[aD5n11Vlir• I2� IDS J DINING DEN - h• OT /Ll �' 1T �-/ ROOM 106 KITCHEN D SINK ON { DIM 11LBNCK T ._ - _ .v.._• %^� - --,IIPIEM — / O° 4=} l �'-r em w9RN.ERs 1 f V „ Ll iHEA06IRISER6 1 PORTE CaCHER" - 1VN9P POEI�EOCNLwE ....�� - ��jowN oo �1 FIRST FLOOR PLAN FIRST FLOOR HEATED/COOLED 2,145 SF SECONDFLOORHEA7EWCOOLEO 2.1625E TOTAL 4.307 SF FIRST FLOOR COVERED ENTRY PORCH 149 SF PORTE COCHERE 152 SF FIRST FLOOR COVERED TERRACE 379 SF SECOND FLOOR COVERED BALCONY 205 SF I GUTHRIE RESIDENCE j P GENERAL NOTES 1. STACK WEST WALL OF 202 BEDROOM ABOVE WEST WALL OF 105 DINING ROOM 2. STACK WEST WALL OF 212 STORAGE ABOVE EAST WALL OF 104 POWDER BATH 3. STACK SOUTH WALL OF COVERED BALCONY ABOVE SOUTH WALL OF 110 MASTER BEDROOM n r., no IVIN _ ' N TP 116 ALIGN ANDQBELOW WIOWS �s CELOW ' SECOND FLOOR PLAN SECOND FLOOR PLAN P -_0: MASON 76•-3" STUDS i3•-iiir _ - _ —_ _ u•-1 1IC^ 'JViO' ra" ram^ k 0•a 1rz^ �— - I JUUET MICCNY I c) 19 1Jn 1 - 2111R" T OENTERO[ m12410 A-9 TMJK101Y5 L ARq K g1,pw w.NouTw[��pDpg�asuom✓'B T11TH OYT6PlE =oDfF'O. w.Wlb.11�T! � L ANDNB[IO'M F J COVERED BALCONY W -- �- 3.1R I I J OENTER WINDOWS ON WINPOWUNITSD.HANDJBELOW W9011Br NO �M 4 0'i' 1'i• ra 1q• — Sur s: /e1��. C•W:,,. ,41 I GUTHRIE RESIDENCE 1 OECOWINT EIMµ�flWjOYC/f eAis-ATen aD SIRE IVY SPLIT BRICK PAVERS ON BED OF GROUT ON S'0" W IDE. X" THICK CONCRETE SLAB WITH VAPOR BARRIER ON d' GRAVEL BASE DECO METAL WALK THROUGH GATE NTH FIXED SIDE PANELS I GATE PARKING PAD MAIN HOUSE 9'-0"C[TLWO HLTGNT WTTIT � sr.• GY' RDARD 011 ix. cmLAR3 A] pECONATNi N6TAlaIWE MNd1GN WTF 1N'ONCG11iRR TfrTHaL0m3 11RNALROAMTIG O►ENFJL 61AAf10N I TROWEL ED%" THICK CONCRETE DRIVE WITH JOINTS EXPANSION AT 35' ON CENTER AND CONTROL 1[ 1 JOINTS BETWEEN THE EXPANSION JOINTS ON i d" COMPACTED GRAVEL BASE LAWN EJarx II PLANTER Y�'OEEi• EXPOSED AGGRE WTIH EXPANSON JOINTS AND 11- WIDEBRICKPAVER; wwb L f m DOWk Ta STi tMWL �I I N -- FRONT MOTOR COURT PLAN 16" SQUARE BRICK COLUMNS 77I'-0- AT EACH END AT 32" HIGH ON _ EAST AND WEST END, 60" TALL i • 1 AT GATEPANELS BETWEEN AT THICK-�- ABE CK TGATEALLBETWEENAT HICIN K HEIGHT. CAP ALL WALLSICOLUMNS - NTH 21M" PRECAST CONCRETE CAP FRONT MOTOR COURT WALL ELEVATION 1 � tai' • f'-0" IQ12 ROOF PITCH PAINTED WOOD LOUVER VENT WITH INSECT SCREEN AND X" WIDE PRECAST CONCRETE HEADER AND d" SLOPED PRECAST GONCRE PAINTED VERSATEX MOLDING ON PAINTED HARDIE RAKE BOARD ON 2X6 OUTRIGGENS AT 16" ON CENTER PAINTED BRICK VENEER 16" WIDE BRICK CORBEL WRH 12' PROJECTION AND B" HIGH PRECAST CONCRETE CAP (ALIGN NTH FASCIA B"PRECASTCONCRETEHEADERABOVE GARAGEDOOR ALUMINUM OVERHEAD ELECTRIC GARAGE DOOR MTH SMOOTH GRAIN PANELS SOUTH ELEVATION - GARAGE 1I61. 1'-0" DASHED UNEINDICATEDSTEEPERROOFAT WESTAND EAST GABLES AND HIGHER DOUBLE PIhT[IGF-fYR REANMO X00Mf W• Ar1CKMGKYT' I 3X3 a " gia•EOANO C 1JNO JOLST6 AT RT• pN evr3R Mill .._ 13'CLOWMINSULATN%I PI ATTIC .' 4 3YYGR A4CHriFC10RAL WAGE ]IRMGLEf A WRIlCUBOOM i%E RAr1£RS - .•- IT r D.W ON *Lowy MTILA "wxPTu"C A1-1 HIND 1 I^Y AimLSA"0 IT L [M63e O SiEEL ANOL[ CRO.RE� cGNCRer[N[AD[R AKDeoLr aACKTG Svuv NnD rw.Naw DBTWrsNSTUD[ tRELA5I CONCIICiE NLAOER tOA3JON MIN iA'ICIA OF W N K CORBEL STEP BRICK COUR%3 AT 1R• PER BbOX COOR6F ANO AUOM MYTH I>r gAKE}.DOE AT OACL6 ROOC EXTEND WINDOW BAYS ON SECOND iIOOR WEST OAOi-E WDE IOYIOM YATH PRFCAGI CONCR[TC PAINTED NARIXa FA3CIAAND ►ERTORATCDIV�N01C"m PAMKi AIA MAM10.f FlOFII ' WEN OLD1 E[PAIIREO I BED MOLDING I I SECTI N AT BRIO CORBEUMST ELEVATION •� Gt9�►'P ��_ SYCDND •100R LLVBL - _ -- zo ow��✓ �� 1' r /YO 6 V zo A HFRDWO11E'TRRINGON ]Id" ON FLOORING AOVANT HARDWOOD L TRUSS JOISTS AT 1fi" • ON CENTER NTH 5111" GYP BOARD ON CEILING - PUNTED PRICK Y[NEER NTH WALL TeES AT 7i' ON CENT[R NOKONrA�ANO ]r oN ZEN1R_R YERRCAL ON AIN CIWCE MI AIR uIFELTRATlDM aRRNRR OIr 1T3' f 1� oEAEWER NIN6Y1000arWYA Drr DYl bomb WN IRsuuTWN w- N GARAGE FLOOR_PLAN ud"=1 •o" A] LOCATIONS WN6411 EXT[TINO DOORS ANOMMOOWS ARE Kf—yDORTO REMOVE OMfUn ALLI-I,Wg 0!!LDOWNT0 THE %-4,MSN&5-OR ARO1MCrALL MeW la•a•uJuuD3TLIDs EXISTING FIRST FLOOR STRUCTURE TO REMAIN UNLESS CALLED OUT ON THE FIRST FLOOR PLAN TYPICAL WALL SECTION BId"=I".. I GUTHRIE RESIDENCE I