Loading...
07-01-97763 Board of Directors Room City Hall - 500 W. Markham Little Rock, Arkansas July 1, 1997 - 6:00 P.M. The Board of Directors of the City of Little Rock, Arkansas met in regular session with Mayor Dailey presiding. City Clerk Robbie Hancock called the roll, with the following Directors present: Directors Hinton, Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kelly, and Adcock - total 8; Absent - Directors Wilson and Kumpuris - total 2. With a quorum present, Mayor Dailey declared the Board of Directors in session and the proceedings of the meeting are recorded as follows: The Invocation was given by Director Hodges followed by the Pledge of Allegiance Mr. Aaron Lubin, a member of the Sister Cities Commission, introduced three guests from Volgograd, Russia - Mayor Yuroi Checkov, Evguenie Ryballzine, Director of International Projects, and Angelina Levitskaya, translator and escort. The Sister Cities Commission is working toward developing a sister cities relationship between the City of Little Rock and Volgograd, Russia. (Directors Wilson and Kumpuris enrolled at 6:08 o'clock P.M.) There was a lengthy presentation from 6:10 until 7:15 o'clock P.M. regarding the Little Rock Municipal Airport food services contract. Mr. Taylor Brown, Chairman of the Little Rock Municipal Airport Commission, introduced other members of the Airport Commission Lottie Shackelford, Gary Smith, and Eugene Fortson, and stated that several months ago realizing that the current contract for food, beverages and merchandising would end this year, the Airport Commission decided to open bidding for a new contract. A committee of Gene Fortson, Gary Smith, Les Hollingsworth, and Debra Ledwell were selected to prepare the RFP (Request for Proposals) and see the process through to the selection of contractor. Mr. Fortson, chairman of that committee, stated the Commission was trying to accomplish three major things: (1) to develop a concession plan that would enable them to function as a landlord and make developments in the concourse that were long overdue. Going down the concourse beyond security, would be concession opportunities along the hallway and removal of the concession area in the rotunda where so much congestion occurrs around the Southwest Airlines boarding area; (2) wanted a broader range of services for the patrons by getting more concessions; and (3) to mandate that the Airport would have street pricing plus no more than ten percent. There were seven interested parties at the pre -bid conference, but only three proposals were made at the final presentation on May 21, 1997: (1) Host Marriott for food, beverage and merchandising; (2) Arkansas Concessions for food and beverage, and (3) tied to Arkansas Concessions was Hudson Corporation's proposal for merchandising only. He then explained the three proposals in some detail. Mr. Fortson stated that one question that has come up in discussions is the existance of a consultant and why the Commission did not follow the recommendations of the consultant and/or the Airport Manager. He explained that a consultant was involved in preparation of the RFP, but the consultant's continued input, including volunteering a recommendation as to what the Airport Commission should do, was not at the direction of the Commission and was not known to the Commission. He also explained why the Commission did not follow the recommendation of Airport Manager Debra Ledwell, stating he had been in business for 35 years and felt his decision was grounded in more experience than hers. Mr. Brown explained that he specifically chose not to have Mrs. Ledwell present at the Board of Directors Meeting, stating he felt the Airport Commission was responsible for making the contract and to the Board of Directors, not Mrs. Ledwell who is an employee of the Commission. Director Hodges requested that she be called to come to the meeting. Mayor Dailey asked if the Board wanted to hear from the unsuccessful bidders. Director 1 772 Minutes July 1, 1997 follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Adcock, Wilson, Hinton and Mayor Dailey - total 11; Noes - None; Absent - None. Whereupon, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. The next presentation was Zoning Application Z- 6258 -A, filed by Joe D. White, Jr. on behalf of Eleanor Karam, to rezone property at 17901 Cantrell Road from "R -2" Single Family District to "O -1" Quiet Office District. The reclassification was approved by the Planning Commission on May 29, 1997. No one was present to speak in opposition to the rezoning and Ordinance No. 17,520 was presented, with the title being: AN ORDINANCE RECLASSIFYING PROPERTY LOCATED IN THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS, AMENDING SECTION 36 OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES; (Z- 6258 -A - To rezone property at 17901 Cantrell Road from "R -2" Single Family District to 110-1" Quiet Office District.) and the Ordinance was read the first time. There was a motion by Director Hinton, seconded by Director Joyce, to suspend the rules and place the Ordinance on second reading. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the second reading of the Ordinance ensued. There was a subsequent motion and second by Directors Adcock and Keck, respectively, to again suspend the rules to provide for the third and final reading of the Ordinance. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two - thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the Ordinance was read the third and last time. A roll call vote was taken on the question, Shall the Ordinance Pass, with the vote recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Adcock, Wilson, Hinton and Mayor Dailey - total 11; Noes - None; Absent - None. Whereupon, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. Consideration was then given to Zoning Application Z -6304 to rezone property at 4120 John Barrow Road from "R -3" Single Family District to "0-3" General Office District. The application was filed by Paul Amponsah on behalf of Oke Construction Company, and approved by the Planning Commission on May 29, 1997. No one was present to speak in opposition to the reclassification, and Ordinance No. 17,521 was presented, entitled: AN ORDINANCE RECLASSIFYING PROPERTY LOCATED IN THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS, AMENDING SECTION 36 OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES; (Z -6304 - To rezone property at 4120 John Barrow Road from "R -3" Single Family District to "0-3" General Office District.) and the Ordinance was read the first time. There was a motion by Director Hinton, seconded by Director Joyce, to suspend the rules and place the Ordinance on second reading. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the second reading of the Ordinance ensued. There was a subsequent motion and second by Directors Adcock and Keck, respectively, to again suspend the rules to provide for the third and final reading of the Ordinance. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the Ordinance was read the third and last time. A roll call vote was taken on the question, Shall the Ordinance Pass, with the vote recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Adcock, Wilson, Hinton and Mayor Dailey - total 11; Noes - None; Absent - None. Whereupon, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. IN Minutes July 1, 1997 773 Item 19 on the Agenda was a proposed Ordinance "PROVIDING FOR A DEFERRAL OF BOUNDARY STREET IMPROVEMENTS FOR CHENAL MINI - STORAGE (Z- 5600 -A), LOCATED AT 14401 CHENAL PARKWAY;" which was withdrawn at the request of the applicant. Introduced next was Ordinance No. 17,522, described as: AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 31 OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS, PROVIDING FOR A DEFERRAL OF BOUNDARY STREET IMPROVEMENT REQUIREMENTS FOR CENTRAL ARKANSAS MARKETPLACE (Z -6296) LOCATED AT 14502 CANTRELL ROAD; and the Ordinance was read the first time. There was a motion by Director Hinton, seconded by Director Joyce, to suspend the rules and place the Ordinance on second reading. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the second reading of the Ordinance ensued. There was a subsequent motion and second by Directors Adcock and Keck, respectively, to again suspend the rules to provide for the third and final reading of the Ordinance. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the Ordinance was read the third and last time. A roll call vote was taken on the question, Shall the Ordinance Pass, with the vote recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Adcock, Wilson, Hinton and Mayor Dailey - total 11; Noes - None; Absent - None. Whereupon, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. Consideration was then given to Ordinance No. 17,523, entitled: AN ORDINANCE PROVIDING FOR A CONDITIONAL WAIVER OF BOUNDARY STREET IMPROVEMENTS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 31 OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES FOR LOTS 1 AND 2 OF KEENER VALLEY ADDITION LOCATED AT NORTON ROAD AND HWY 10; and the Ordinance was read the first time. There was a motion by Director Hinton, seconded by Director Joyce, to suspend the rules and place the Ordinance on second reading. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the second reading of the Ordinance ensued. There was a subsequent motion and second by Directors Adcock and Keck, respectively, to again suspend the rules to provide for the third and final reading of the Ordinance. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the Ordinance was read the third and last time. A roll call vote was taken on the question, Shall the Ordinance Pass, with the vote recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Adcock, Wilson, Hinton and Mayor Dailey - total 11; Noes - None; Absent - None. Whereupon, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. The next presentation was Resolution No. 10,024, with the title being: A RESOLUTION OF INTENT TO PARTICIPATE IN THE CENTRAL ARKANSAS REGIONAL TRANSPORTATION STUDY AND CONCUR IN THE AMENDMENTS TO THE CARTS AGREEMENT OF UNDERSTANDING. Following the reading of the Resolution, Director Adcock moved for its adoption. The motion was seconded by Director Wilson, and the Resolution was unanimously adopted. A public hearing had been scheduled for this time and place by Resolution No. 9,999 adopted June 17, 1997, on the petition to vacate and close a portion of Cedar Street between West 30th and West 31st Streets in Dickson Mill Addition to the City of Little 11 774 Minutes July 1, 1997 Rock. The petition was filed by Gary Brown, McClelland Engineers, on behalf of Pro Window and Door, Inc. Attached to the petition was a certified copy of the plat of Dickson Mill Addition on file in the Pulaski County Circuit Clerk's Office, and a letter from Beach Enterprises, Inc. listing the last apparent owners of record to abutting property. The notice of hearing was published in the Dailey Record on June 24, 1997, and July 1, 1997. The street abandonment was approved by the Planning Commission on May 15, 1997. Mayor Dailey declared the public hearing open. Speaking in opposition to the street closure was Mr. David McNamer, 2905 South Cedar Street. He was opposed to the closure because his employees use Cedar Street between 30th and 31st Streets to get to another business he owns in the area. The only other option is to drive out onto Asher Avenue and make a U -turn onto Elm Street, which presents a dangerous situation due to the traffic. Mr. Bill Rush, president of Rush Engineers at 4100 Asher Avenue (the old Harvest Foods Store), was also opposed to the closing of Cedar Street. He has buildings located on Cedar Street, and employees traveling between the locations use Cedar Street because the access to Asher is very, very dangerous, and there is a good potential for life threatening situations. If Cedar Street is closed, his employees and customers will have no option but to go out to Asher Avenue. Mr. Mark McNamer also spoke in opposition to the street closure. Mr. Gary Brown, McClelland Engineers, representing Mr. Stewart and Pro Window and Door, Inc., presented pictures of Cedar Street. He stated that Cedar Street is about 10 feet wide with deep ditches along both sides of the street. Cedar Street is not called for on the Master Street Plan. Closing Cedar Street will divert traffic onto Elm Street, which is a much safer street about 150 feet to the west. Mr. Stewart is building a new building and expects to add five new jobs immediately. He will have to do half street improvements unless Cedar Street is closed. Half of the street would be wider than the existing street now. After some discussion, Director Hodges moved to waive the boundary street improvements. Director Adcock seconded the motion. Public Works Director Chandra Russell said there is no way to accommodate two way traffic on this portion of Cedar Street. The street needs minimal improvements to accommodate two -way traffic or the owner would be required to make the 15% in lieu contribution of all boundary street improvements. Mrs. Russell said staff would be glad to work with Mr. Stewart on making very minimal improvements. Director Hodges withdrew his motion to waive the boundary street improvements. The Board generally agreed to allow staff time to work with Mr. Stewart, and to defer final action until the reconvened meeting on July 8, 1997. Mayor Dailey declared the public hearing closed at 11:08 o'clock P.M., and the proposed Ordinance was presented, with the title being: AN ORDINANCE VACATING AND CLOSING A PORTION OF CEDAR STREET BETWEEN WEST 30TH AND WEST 31ST STREETS IN DICKSON MILL ADDITION TO THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS. The Ordinance was read the first time, and left on the calendar for second reading on Tuesday, July 8, 1997. A public hearing had also been scheduled for this time and place by Resolution No. 10,000, adopted June 17, 1997, on the petition filed by Joe White on behalf of George E. Collins, Jr. and M'Liss Collins to vacate the public utility easement on Lot 35 of Pleasant Valley Estates Addition to the City of Little Rock. Attached to the petition was a plat of Pleasant Valley Estates, and a letter from Beach Abstract & Guaranty Company, listing the last apparent owners of record of abutting property. The notice of hearing was published in the Daily Record on June 24, 1997, and July 1, 1997. Mayor Dailey declared the public hearing open. No one was present to speak in opposition to the abandonment and Mayor Dailey declared the public hearing closed. Consideration was then given to Ordinance No. 17,524, described as: AN ORDINANCE VACATING A PORTION OF THE PUBLIC UTILITY EASEMENT IN LOT 35 OF PLEASANT VALLEY ESTATES ADDITION TO THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS; 12 Minutes July 1, 1997 775 and the Ordinance was read the first time. There was a motion by Director Adcock, seconded by Director Joyce, to suspend the rules and place the Ordinance on second reading. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the second reading of the Ordinance ensued. There was a subsequent motion and second by Directors Adcock and Joyce, respectively, to again suspend the rules to provide for the third and final reading of the Ordinance. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the Ordinance was read the third and last time. A roll call vote was taken on the question, Shall the Ordinance Pass, with the vote recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Adcock, Wilson, Hinton and Mayor Dailey - total 11; Noes - None; Absent - None. Whereupon, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. Item 25 on the Agenda was a discussion regarding the request for funds for West Side Junior High School, located at 14th and Marshall Streets. City Manager Charles Nickerson briefly reviewed his memorandum to the Board of Directors dated June 26, 1997, in response to the letter dated June 18, 1997, from Ms. Pam Marshall, Special Projects Coordinator for the Central Little Rock Community Development Corporation (CDC), requesting grant funding in the amount of $410,000 from the City of Little Rock for the Westside School Redevelopment Project. The City previously committed $462,350 in HOME funds to the Westside School Redevelopment when Volunteers of America (VOA) were part of the project. These funds were later reallocated to VOA's new site. Mr. Nickerson said that while the project has merit, the request is in opposition to the intent of the Landmark Building Fund, the Neighborhood Residential Incentive Program, and the Facade Grant Program. Therefore, he recommended that the Board reject the request. Ms. Marshall said that when Westside School was originally scheduled for demolition in 1991, a number of neighborhood residents and organizations came together to try to preserve it and develop a feasible plan to utilize the building. The level of the City's commitment to that building has always been in statements, not actions, until we put together the project with VOA. The City's commitment was to VOA, not Westside. The original request to the City in 1991 was $3.5 million for the entire project. They have come back on five different occasions requesting money, and each time they have reduced the amount of the request, and each time were told there was no money available. This is a large chunk of money, but it will be leveraged ten times. We plan to put a training center in that building and bring jobs to the community by renovating that building. We plan to preserve a magnificent historical building. We have to close by the end of August, 1997, and need a commitment from the City of Little Rock. Following the discussion, Mayor Dailey asked that the Westside School Redevelopment Project be placed on the Agenda for July 15, 1997, and that the Board be provided with more information. Due to the late hour (11:30 P.M.), the Board of Directors deferred making appointments to various Board and Commissions until the reconvened meeting on July 8, 1997. Due to a conflict of interest related to the BFI Landfill issue, Mayor Dailey was excused at 11:30 o'clock P.M. With Vice Mayor Keck presiding, the Board of Directors began the discussion regarding the Browning- Farris Industries (BFI) Landfill (formerly Worth James Landfill), which was added to the Agenda at the request of Director Joyce. Director Joyce stated that several of the neighbors in that area are interested in this matter and hope that the City of Little Rock will appeal the permit granted by the Department of Pollution, Control & Ecology for expansion of the BFI Landfill located at 3817 Mabelvale Pike. Director Hinton said that a lot of people still do not know what is going on. He suggested getting with the people involved and come up with an action committee to get rid of all of the dialogue. Director Joyce stated that the problem we are facing is that the time frame for the appeal process expires July 3, 1997. City Attorney Tom Carpenter referred to his memorandum dated June 27, 1997, and to the Public 13 776 Minutes July 1, 1997 Works Department memorandum dated July 1, 1997. Mr. Carpenter's memo presented his reasons why the City should not appeal. The Public Works memo explained estimated costs to the City should it become liable for floodplain mitigation. In conclusion Mr. Carpenter stated the estimate of $3 million up to $19.5 million could be a very realistic expense the City would have to bear. The legal answer to the Board was - yes, you can appeal; yes, you might be successful; success may carry a price with it; do you wish to run that risk? Mr. Chuck Nestrud, representing BFI Landfill, stated that BFI never built in the floodway. When BFI was bought the property in 1991, the existing landfill was already above the flood plain, and BFI did not cause the problem. In response to Director Joyce's question, "How do we stop this ?" Mr. Carpenter responded, "We don't." "You are not going to stop this landfill's expansion to the whole 143 acres. If you stop anything, you may stop the vertical expansion, but there is a risk involved." Director Joyce said, "We have a lot of people out there that are very unhappy." Ms. Argentina James, Community Affairs Manager for BFI, stated that she and two colleagues knocked on 300 doors and 90% of those had no opinion or were favorable to BFI being there. Following the discussion, Director Joyce moved to file an appeal of the BFI application, and the motion was seconded by Director Adcock. The motion failed by the following roll call vote: Ayes - Directors Joyce, Wyrick, and Adcock - total 3; Noes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Kumpuris, Kelly, Wilson, and Hinton - total 7; Absent - Mayor Dailey - total 1. There being no further business to be presented, the Board of Directors recessed at 12:00 o'clock midnight to reconvene on Tuesday, July 8, 1997, to consider the Airport food services contract process, the Cedar Street closure, and to make appointments to various Boards and Commissions. ATTEST: Q U41-A Z W444a C.0 City Clerk Robbie Hancock 14 APPROVED, a ayor Jim Dailey 764 Minutes July 1, 1997 Hodges felt the Board should hear from Arkansas Concessions and Hudson Foods. Mr. Gary Smith vehemently disagreed with Director Hodges' request. Mr. Brown said the Airport Commission did not come to the meeting with the intent to make a detailed presentation of each proposal, but would be glad to do so at another date. Director Hinton said that according to the Agenda, the presentation was to be from the Airport Commission only. If the Board wanted to hear each proposal, that should be scheduled for another meeting. Director Cazort said there was a great misunderstanding by the public as to the process that has been employed by the Airport, and he felt the Board should give the Airport Commission the opportunity to explain the process in more detail and to hear from all three bidders, either at this meeting or set another time. Director - Hodges then moved "to hear from Arkansas Concessions and Hudson Foods tonight." Director Cazort seconded the motion. Responding to a question by Director Keck, City Attorney Tom Carpenter stated the Board does not have the authority to issue or award the contract, that is the exclusive authority of the Airport Commission; the Board does have the authority to determine if the Airport Commission is operating properly. After some further discussion, a roll call vote was taken on Director Hodges' motion as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Wyrick, and Adcock - total 4; Noes - Directors Wilson, Hinton, Keck, Joyce, Kumpuris, Kelly and Mayor Dailey - total 7. With the motion having failed, there was a subsequent motion by Director Keck to hear from all parties when both vendors can be present with the Airport Commission on Tuesday, July 8, 1997. The motion was seconded by Director Wilson and adopted by the following roll call vote: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, and Mayor Dailey - total 8; Noes - Directors Hinton, Joyce, and Adcock - total 3. The main presenter for the Airport Commission (Mr. Fortson) would not be able to attend the meeting on July 8, 1997. Director Hodges said Mr. Forson is essential to the presentation and moved to reconsider the motion to have the meeting on July 8, 1997. The motion was seconded by Director Cazort and unanimously adopted. Mr. Fortson said he would try to rearrange his scheduled so that he could attend the July 8th meeting. There was a subsequent motion and second by Directors Hodges and Cazort, respectively, to have a meeting on July 8, 1997, at 4:00 P.M. to hear from the Airport Commission and all bidders. The motion was adopted by the following roll call vote: Ayes - Director Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Wilson, and Mayor Dailey - total 9; Noes - Directors Adcock and Hinton - total 2. There was some discussion as to the format for the meeting on July 8, some wanted presentations, others wanted to ask questions. City Attorney Tom Carpenter pointed out the question before the Board is - "Is the process used by your commission in awarding substantial public contracts sufficient to merit public confidence? If after questioning the Airport Commission in detail about this process, the answer is "yes, we have confidence," there is no need to have presentations from either group. If the answer is "I still have questions," then both groups are there and you can ask the questions. Mr. Caprenter was concerned that if the Board said "this is your presentation" and "this is your presentation," then the Board is inviting a sell job from each of the applicants as opposed to a fact finding mission for the Board. Having them there to answer questions is a good idea, but directing that they be given time for a presentation is sending the wrong message. Director Cazort said he only wanted their comments about the process, and then he may have specific questions. (Director Kelly was excused at 7:10 o'clock P.M.) After more discussion, Director Joyce moved "to have the Airport presentation tonight - including the process that was used, how and why Host Marriott was chosen, and if the Board has questions why Host was chosen, then ask those questions." Director Hinton seconded the motion. The motion failed by the following roll call vote: Ayes - Directors Keck, Joyce, Kumpuris, Adcock, and Hinton - total 5; Noes - Directors Hodges, —° Cazort, Wyrick, Wilson, and Mayor Dailey - total 5; Absent - Director Kelly. Whereupon, Mayor Dailey announced that the Airport food services contract would be dealt with on Tuesday, July 8, 1997, at 4:00 P.M. (Director Kelly re- enrolled at 7:15 o'clock P.M.) 2 Minutes July 1, 1997 Mr. Tim Polk, Director of Housing and Neighborhood Programs, made a presentation on the housing and landbank recommendations and distributed copies of the Housing Resource Handbook, which was prepared to provide information for those seeking affordable housing resources with the city and the region. He explained the creation of the Housing and Landbank Authority was a recommendation of the FUTURE - Little Rock Task Force. Director Adcock explained that certain members of the Task Force would serve on the Housing and Landbank Authority, but not all of the Task Force would be members. This had been such a long process, it was important that the members of the Authority be familiar with what had transpired in order to move forward. Following Mr. Polk's presentation, Director Adcock asked that the Resolution listed on the Addendum to the Agenda be considered. Whereupon, Resolution No. 10,018 was introduced with the title being: A RESOLUTION TO DIRECT THE CITY MANAGER AND THE CITY ATTORNEY TO DEVELOP ALL NECESSARY ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS, AND OTHER MATTERS NECESSARY TO IMPLEMENT THE REPORT OF THE HOUSING PARTNERSHIP AND LAND BANK AUTHORITY TASK FORCE; TO ASSURE T14-AT THE INITIAL MEMBERSHIP OF THE LITTLE ROCK COMMUNITY HOUSING BOARD WILL INCLUDE TASK FORCE MEMBERS; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. (The City Manager and City Attorney are directed to review the report attached to the Resolution, to complete a legal and staff analysis, and to return the report to the Board of Directors with any ordinances, resolutions, and budgets by August 31, 1997.) Following the reading of the Resolution, Director Adcock moved for its adoption. Director Joyce seconded the motion and the Resolution was unanimously adopted. Director Adcock explained that due to the Central High School 40th Anniversary celebration on September 25, 1997, fifty structures in that area had been selected to be rehabilitated, painted, landscaped, and sidewalks repaired before the celebration at no cost to the owner and a partnership developed between the owners and businesses or individuals that were willing to adopt the houses and make the necessary enhancements. She reported that there were 19 houses left to be adopted and urged the business community to participate. There was a motion by Director Joyce, seconded by Director Keck, to move Agenda Item 26 to the Consent Agenda. The motion was unanimously adopted, and the Resolution appointing commissioners to Metrocentre Improvement District No. 1 was placed in the Consent Agenda. (See Resolution No. 10,022 below) Consideration was then given to the Consent Agenda which consisted of the following: (1) A motion to set the date for a public hearing on the appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of the Montgomery Special Use Permit (Z -6295) for a daycare family home at 2812 Lenox Drive. (August 5, 1997) (2) A motion to set the date for a public hearing on the appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of the Stanfield Special Use Permit (Z -6301) for a daycare family home at 2920 Romine Road. (August 5,1997) 3 Minutes July 1, 1997 (3) Resolution No. 10,019, described: A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO AN ENGINEERING SERVICES CONTRACT WITH GENESIS ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICE FOR THE PREPARATION OF A STORM WATER POLLUTION PREVENTION PLAN (SWPPP) AND SPILL PREVENTION CONTROL AND COUNTERMEASURES PLAN (SPCCP) FOR THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK'S CENTRAL MAINTENANCE FACILITY LOCATED AT 3313 J.E. DAVIS DRIVE (4) Resolution No. 10,020, with the title being: A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO A CONTRACT WITH JACK JENNINGS FIRE AND SAFETY EQUIPMENT COMPANY FOR THE PURCHASE OF ONE (1) HEAVY DUTY RESCUE TRUCK FOR THE LITTLE ROCK FIRE DEPARTMENT. (5) Resolution No. 10,021, entitled: A RESOLUTION TO PERMIT THE CHIEF DEPUTY CITY ATTORNEY AND DEPUTY CITY ATTORNEYS TO PARTICIPATE IN THE MONEY PURCHASE RETIREMENT PLAN ADMINISTERED BY THE ICMA RETIREMENT CORPORATION; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. (26) Added to the Consent Agenda was Resolution No. 10,022, described as: A RESOLUTION APPOINTING DALE NICHOLSON AND JACK FLEISCHAUER, JR. AS COMMISSIONERS OF METROCENTRE IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT NO. 1 OF THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS. Upon a motion by Director Adcock, which was seconded by Director Joyce and unanimously adopted, the Consent Agenda was dispensed with as follows: (1 and 2) the motions setting the date of hearing for August 5, 1997 on zoning appeals for the Montgomery Special Use Permit at 2812 Lenox Drive and the Stanfield Special Use Permit at 2920 Romine Road were unanimously adopted; and (3, 4, 5, and 26) Resolutions No. 10,019, 10,020, 10,021, and 10,022 were read and unanimously adopted. At the time allotted for Citizen Communications, the first speaker was Mr. Ovid Goode, editor and publisher of the Arkansas Tribune newspaper, which is delivered to the black community. He told the Board of Directors that he could save the City money on legal advertising by advertising in his newspaper. He said the purpose of legal advertising is to reach the most people at the least amount of cost. Mayor Dailey told Mr. Goode that he had met with the City Manager and City Attorney and asked them to come back to the Board of Directors with some discussion on the issue of legal advertising. The next speaker during Citizen Communications was Mr. Matt Holody, who asked the status of the Taylor/Woodlawn drainage bond issue. City Manager Charles Nickerson reported that staff has had several very good meetings in the neighborhood and the general consensus of the majority of the folks in the neighborhood was that they liked the project and wanted the City to move forward. At 7:45 o'clock P.M. Mayor Dailey declared a ten minute recess. When the Board of Directors reconvened at 8:05 o'clock P.M., Mayor Dailey presided and nine Directors were present. (Director Wilson was absent.) 4 Minutes July 1, 1997 Consideration was then given to Item 11 on the Agenda, being Ordinance No. 17,512, entitled: AN ORDINANCE TO ESTABLISH STANDARDS AND SPECIFICATIONS FOR THE RESTORATION OF EXCAVATIONS AND CUTS IN STREETS OR ALLEY RIGHTS -OF -WAY; PROVIDING FOR A PERMIT PROCESS; ESTABLISHING FEES; PROVIDING FOR THE ADMINISTRATION AND ENFORCEMENT OF THE PROCESS; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES; and the Ordinance was read the third and last time, having been read the first time on April 15, 1997, deferred from May 6, 1997 and May 20, 1997, and read the second time on June 3, 1997. There was a motion by Director Keck to amend the Ordinance as per the revised copy distributed by City Attorney Tom Carpenter. The motion was seconded by Director Adcock and unanimously adopted by the Board Members present. A roll call vote was then taken on passage of the Ordinance, as amended, with the vote recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Adcock, Hinton, and Mayor Dailey - total 10; Noes - None; Absent - Director Wilson - total 1. Therefore, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. Item 12 on the Agenda was the public hearing on the appeal of the Planning Commission's denial of a Conditional Use Permit for outdoor storage /display of merchandise for Home Depot (Z- 5668 -C) at 12610 Chenal Parkway. The public hearing and related resolution were deferred as requested by the applicant, Mr. James Cannon, Manager of Home Depot. Mayor Dailey noted that staff is trying to work with various types of similar businesses to deal with this from a policy directive standpoint. (Director Wilson re- enrolled at 8:15 o'clock P.M.) Introduced next was Ordinance No. 17,513, described as: AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND CHAPTER 14 OF THE LITTLE ROCK CODE TO ADD REGULATIONS OF THE USE OF TOBACCO PRODUCTS BY MINORS; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. (Note: See Minutes of May 20,1997; May 27,1997; June 3,1997; and June 17, 1997 for presentations and discussion.) City Attorney Tom Carpenter reviewed the numerous changes that had been made as provided in the copy of the Ordinance just distributed. Director Adcock moved to amend the Ordinance as presented by Mr. Carpenter. The motion was seconded by Director Cazort and unanimously adopted. Director Keck then moved to amend Section 4(a)(1) to place a period after the phrase "To sell tobacco products through vending machines," which would eliminate the sale of tobacco products through vending machines. The motion was seconded by Director Hinton. Director Cazort stated that a very good compromise has been reached by placing vending machines in areas not frequented by minors and urged a no vote on the motion. A roll call vote was taken on the motion as follows: Ayes - Directors Keck, Wyrick, Kelly, and Hinton - total 4; Noes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Joyce, Kumpuris, Adcock, Wilson, and Mayor Dailey - total 7. Whereupon, the motion failed. State Senator Jim Keet spoke in support of the Ordinance, but expressed concern about how easy it is for minors to purchase tobacco products in the City of Little Rock. He concluded by stating, "don't punish the victims, educate them." Mr. Richard Blume spoke in support of the Ordinance and expressed concern about his 14 year old son's smoking addiction. He urged the Board not to penalize the kids. In response to the concern about criminalizing minors, Mr. Carpenter recommended amending Section 5(b) to add the word "civil" before the word penalties which would subject the minor to civil penalties and would not result in a criminal record for the minor. Director Adcock moved to add the word "civil" before the word penalties in Section 5(b). The motion was seconded by Director Hinton and adopted by a voice vote of ten ayes and one no (Director Keck). Ms. Patty McLean read a letter F1 Ni Minutes July 1, 1997 from Debbie Rushing, Program Coordinator of Insure the Children, regarding adolescent addiction and recommended an effective education and treatment program to address nicotine addiction. Insure the Children can be ready to do this as early as September, 1997, with no increase in the existing budget. In response to a question on enforcement, City Manager Charles Nickerson responded that he would come back to the Board with a report on the strategy for enforcing the Ordinance. Dr. Craig Stotts, Coalition for Tobacco Free Kids, spoke in support of the Ordinance, but urged the Board not to punish the kids for acts illegally committed by adults. He said City government actions should help these kids rather than punish them - start a cessation program through Insure the Children. He urged the Board to place a ban on vending machines and self - service, which would reduce the number of young people smoking. The Ordinance, as amended, was then read the third and last time, having been read the first time on May 27, 1997, and the second time on June 17, 1997. A roll call vote was taken on the question, Shall the Ordinance Pass, which is recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Adcock, Wilson, Hinton, and Mayor Dailey - total 11; Noes - None; Absent - None. Whereupon, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. (Mr. Carpenter noted that the Ordinance will not become effective until approved by FDA.) The next presentation was the companion Ordinance No. 17,514, with the title being: AN ORDINANCE TO ESTABLISH AN OCCUPATIONAL TAX FOR BUSINESSES THAT SELL TOBACCO PRODUCTS TO ADULTS; TO ESTABLISH PENALTIES FOR VIOLATION OF THE ORDINANCE; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. (Note: See Minutes of May 20,1997,- May 27,1997; June 3,1997; and June 17, 1997 for presentations and discussion.) (See discussion above) City Attorney Tom Carpenter reviewed the changes that had been made as provided in the copy of the Ordinance just distributed. Director Adcock moved to amend the Ordinance as presented by Mr. Carpenter. The motion was seconded by Director Cazort and unanimously adopted. The Ordinance, as amended, was then read the third and last time, with the first and second readings having occurred on May 27, 1997, and June 17, 1997, respectively. A roll call vote was taken on the question, Shall the Ordinance Pass, which is recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Adcock, Wilson, Hinton, and Mayor Dailey - total 11; Noes - None; Absent - None. Whereupon, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. (Mr. Carpenter noted that the Ordinance will not become effective until January 1, 1998.) Introduced next was Resolution No. 10,023, with the title being: A RESOLUTION TO DIRECT THAT THE MONIES COLLECTED FROM LICENSE FEES, OR FINES, FROM ORDINANCES THAT DEAL WITH THE SELL OF TOBACCO PRODUCTS TO MINORS BE USED FOR ENFORCEMENT AND EDUCATION PROGRAMS; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. (See Ordinances No. 17,513 and 17,514 above) Following the reading of the Resolution, Director Adcock moved for its adoption. The motion was seconded by Director Joyce and the Resolution was unanimously adopted. Director Joyce moved to add to the Agenda a discussion of the BFI landfill issue that needs action by Thursday, July 3, 1997. The motion was seconded by Director Adcock and unanimously adopted. Therefore, the BFI appeal will be discussed at the end of the Agenda. (See Minutes of June 17, 1997, pages 11 and 12, for discussion of the BFI landfill expansion.) Minutes July 1, 1997 T69 The next presentation was a proposed Resolution, described as: A RESOLUTION DEVELOPING A CITY OF LITTLE ROCK SUSTAINABLE GROWTH STRATEGY AND ACTION PLAN FOR EVALUATING FUTURE DEVELOPMENT AND REVITALIZATION PROPOSALS. The first speaker was Mr. Jim Lynch, who spoke in support of the Resolution, stating a sustainable growth policy is just plain common sense. In view of the fact that we have discussed the proposed Deltic annexation since May 20th, we have learned that the City of Little Rock is not prepared to embrace the real essential policies that make annexations like this work. A lot of time needs to be spent on the issues. He emplored the Board to adopt the Resolution. Ms. Pam Marshall, representing the Central High CDC, also spoke in support of the Resolution. She said our lack of a sustainable growth policy has created an incentive for upper income people to move out and a wall keeping lower income people in the older neighborhoods that are slowly dying around them. Speaking in opposition to the Resolution was Mr. Dickson Flake, who stated he commended the objective of the Resolution, however, the Resolution will not produce the intended result. It is naive to think that we can control market forces. The only way to stimulate the mature area is to make people want to live there through enhanced public safety, security and incentives. If you limit the City's boundaries, you are going to start a decline from which we will not recover. City Attorney Tom Carpenter read Section 6 of the proposed Resolution to Mr. Flake, stating that he had attempted to incorporate the various issues raised by the discussion of the Chenal annexation. Director Keck expressed concerns regarding Sections 2 and 3 of the proposed Resolution. Director Joyce noted that the Board had received Resolution No. 113 from the Planning Commission requesting a deferral of the sustainable growth resolution to give the Commission opportunity to discuss the proposal at the Planning Commission Annexation Retreat on July 24, 1997. Director Wyrick then moved to refer the sustainable growth strategy proposal to the Planning Commission and the motion was seconded by Director Joyce. Director Kelly said there is nothing in his proposed Resolution to prohibit the Planning Commission from reviewing the sustainable growth strategy. Following the discussion, a roll call vote was taken on the motion to refer the sustainable growth proposal to the Planning Commission, with the vote recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Adcock, and Mayor Dailey - total 8; Noes - Directors Kelly, Wilson, and Hinton - total 3; Absent - None. With the adoption of the motion, no action was taken on the proposed Resolution, and the sustainable growth strategy proposal was referred to the Planning Commission. Consideration was then given to Ordinance No. 17,515, entitled: AN ORDINANCE ACCEPTING THE ANNEXATION OF LAND TO THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS, WHICH PROPERTY IS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS A PORTION OF SECTIONS 15, 16, 17, 22 AND 23, T -2 -N, R -14 -W, PULASKI COUNTY, ARKANSAS. (Chenal Valley Annexation - Duquesne Community - 712 acres located south and west of the Chenal Parkway and Hwy. 10 Intersection. See Court Order No. 97 -170 dated April 10, 1997.) Speaking in opposition to the proposed annexation were Ms. Johnny Pugh, Mr. Jim Lynch, and Ms. Pam Marshall. Ms. Pugh, representing the New Party, asked the Board to vote against the annexation. She said the City's housing and jobs are constantly moving westward, leaving east and central Little Rock without a lot of the things that we really need. The needs of this part of the City should be taken care of before taking in other areas. Mr. Lynch was very disappointed in the vote on the growth strategy (see above), stating we want annexation to benefit all of us. He concluded by urging the Board to vote against the annexation. Ms. Marshall said she did not oppose annexation, but she did oppose economic and racial segregation. In the original development of Chenal, promises were made about fair share housing, but it is not fair to build $150,000 7 Mul Minutes July 1, 1997 houses that cannot be occupied by the medium income in the City of Little Rock. Speaking in support of the annexation was Mr. Jack McCray, representing Deltic Timber Corporation. He urged the Board to approve the annexation, which is the third in a series. He pledged his support in working with the staff and others on the sustainable growth strategy, because the City needs one. There was a brief discussion regarding the Little Rock and Pulaski County inter - district school issue and the impact this annexation would have on the desegregation agreement. City Attorney Tom Carpenter said it does not impact it because the Consent Decree took away a provision of Judge Wood's original Order that would have made the City boundaries and the school district boundaries contiguous. However, the Eighth Circuit Court did not deny the opportunity for there to be annexation of school district boundaries to match that of cities. But the Legislature essentially repealed all of the statutes that would have allowed that type of thing. So this property could not be put in the Little Rock School District without a change in legislation. Mr. Lynch said we together can start a petition tonight to create a South of the River School District; all it takes is a majority of the electors in the area, we don't even have to have an election. We need to think about this because this would take the desegregation pressure off these annexation issues. Mr. Jim Lawson, Director of Planning and Development, and Mr. Tim Polk, Director of the Housing and Neighborhood Programs, responded to questions by the Board. Following the lengthy discussion, the Ordinance was read the third and last time, having been read the first time on May 20, 1997, and the second time on June 17, 1997. (See Minutes of May 20, 1997, June 3, 1997, and June 17, 1997.) A roll call vote was taken on passage of the Ordinance as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Adcock, and Mayor Dailey - total 8; Noes - Directors Kelly, Wilson, and Hinton - total 3; Absent - None. Therefore, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. At 10:15 o'clock P.M. Mayor Dailey declared a ten minute recess. When the Board reconvened at 10:25 o'clock P.M., Mayor Dailey presided and all Directors were present. Introduced next was Item No. 13 on the Agenda, being Ordinance No. 17,516, described as: AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE CITY LAND USE PLAN (ORDINANCE NO. 16,222) IN THE OTTER CREEK PLANNING DISTRICT SOUTH OF THE OTTER CREEK SUBDIVISION AND ALONG STAGECOACH ROAD; FROM VARIOUS LAND USES TO PARK/OPEN SPACE AND MOBILE HOME; (Re: Z -6287 -11 701 Stagecoach Road.) and the Ordinance was read the second time, having been read the first time on June 17, 1997. There was a motion and second by Directors Cazort and Hinton, respectively, to suspend the rules to provide for the third and final reading of the Ordinance. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the Ordinance was read the third and last time. A roll call vote was taken on the question, Shall the Ordinance Pass, with the vote recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Wilson, and Hinton - total 8; Noes - Directors Keck, Adcock, and Mayor Dailey - total 3; Absent - None. Whereupon, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. The next presentation was Zoning Application Z -6287 filed by W. A. Jones to rezone 29.43 acres located at 11701 Stagecoach Road from "R -2" Single Family District to "R -7" Mobile Home District and "OS" Open Space District. The reclassification was approved by the Planning Commission on May 15, 1997. No one was present to speak in opposition to the rezoning, and Ordinance No. 17,517 was presented, with the title being: AN ORDINANCE RECLASSIFYING PROPERTY LOCATED IN THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS, AMENDING SECTION 36 OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES; Minutes July 1, 1997 771 (Z -6287 - To rezone 29.43 acres located at 11701 Stagecoach Road from "R -2" Single Family District to "R -7" Mobile Home District and "OS" Open Space District.) and the Ordinance was read the second time, having been read the first time on June 17, 1997. There was a motion and second by Directors Cazort and Hinton, respectively, to suspend the rules to provide for the third and final reading of the Ordinance. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the Ordinance was read the third and last time. A roll call vote was taken on the question, Shall the Ordinance Pass, with the vote recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Wilson, and Hinton - total 8; Noes - Directors Keck, Adcock, and Mayor Dailey - total 3; Absent - None. Whereupon, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. Consideration was then given to Ordinance No. 17,518, entitled: AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE CITY LAND USE PLAN (16,222) IN THE OTTER CREEK DISTRICT FROM COMMUNITY SHOPPING TO COMMERCIAL; AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES; (Re: Z -391 S A -12024 I -30) and the Ordinance was read the first time. There was a motion by Director Hinton, seconded by Director Joyce, to suspend the rules and place the Ordinance on second reading. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the second reading of the Ordinance ensued. There was a subsequent motion and second by Directors Adcock and Keck, respectively, to again suspend the rules to provide for the third and final reading of the Ordinance. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the Ordinance was read the third and last time. A roll call vote was taken on the question, Shall the Ordinance Pass, with the vote recorded as follows: Ayes - Directors Hodges, Cazort, Keck, Joyce, Wyrick, Kumpuris, Kelly, Adcock, Wilson, Hinton and Mayor Dailey - total 11; Noes - None; Absent - None. Whereupon, the Ordinance was declared PASSED. Zoning Application Z- 3915 -A was introduced next, which was filed by Charles W. Reimer, on behalf of CalArk International, to rezone 29.19 acres at 12024 I -30 from "R -2" Single Family and "C -3" General Commercial Districts to "C -4" Open Display District. The reclassification was approved by the Planning Commission on May 29, 1997. No one was present to speak in opposition to the rezoning and Ordinance No. 17,519 was presented, described as: AN ORDINANCE RECLASSIFYING PROPERTY LOCATED IN THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS, AMENDING SECTION 36 OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF LITTLE ROCK, ARKANSAS, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES; (Z- 3915 -A - To rezone 29.19 acres at 12024 I -30 from "R -2" Single Family and 11C- 3" General Commercial Districts to "C -4" Open Display District.) and the Ordinance was read the first time. There was a motion by Director Hinton, seconded by Director Joyce, to suspend the rules and place the Ordinance on second reading. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the second reading of the Ordinance ensued. There was a subsequent motion and second by Directors Adcock and Keck, respectively, to again suspend the rules to provide for the third and final reading of the Ordinance. The motion was unanimously adopted by the Board Members present, being eleven in number and two- thirds or more of the members of the Board of Directors, and the Ordinance was read the third and last time. A roll call vote was taken on the question, Shall the Ordinance Pass, with the vote recorded as 0